Please select your home edition
Edition
Musto Windproof Knit

Why weren't Luna Rossa penalised in the Race 4 pre-start incident?

by Mark Jardine 29 Sep 2024 17:50 BST 29 September 2024
Luna Rossa Prada Pirelli vs. INEOS Britannia on Louis Vuitton Cup Final Race Day 3 - September 29, 2024 © Ricardo Pinto / America's Cup

Race 4 between Luna Rossa Prada Pirelli and INEOS Britannia in the Louis Vuitton Cup Final was full of drama, but one moment had had sailors asking questions on social media groups more than any other, and clearly riled Ben Ainslie and Dylan Fletcher on the British boat.

To British fans it looked like a clear windward-leeward situation. To Italian fans it looked like Luna Rossa was clear ahead. The reality lies elsewhere, and the key is in the Racing Rules of Sailing, and a particular Appendix C (Match Racing) rule that doesn't apply in the America's Cup.

Rule 13.2 'After the foot of the mainsail of a boat sailing downwind crosses the centreline she shall keep clear of other boats until her mainsail has filled or she is no longer sailing downwind.' has been removed for the America's Cup, and instead a boat just needs to be beyond the angle of the wind direction to have gybed, which meant that Luna Rossa had actually gybed far earlier than appears on screen, as we were all looking at the sails, not the angle of the boats to the wind, which isn't at all obvious on TV.

So, if the diamonds which surround the boats had intersected when INEOS Britannia protested, it may have been the British team penalised, or Italy, depending on whether Luna Rossa were judged to have given the Brits enough room to keep clear.

We, as everyday sailors, were looking at things from our own experience, and the rules we use. The America's Cup rules though are slightly different, which they need to be to accommodate racing these extraordinary machines.

When these kinds of situation arise, we'll try and make things clearer.

Rewatch the whole race in full: (the incident in question starts at 2 minutes in)

Mozzy's analysis of the call here:

Related Articles

Not done yet!
Bring on the 2026 Sydney to Hobart. One Skipper is really keen to get amongst it once more... By any means, as it turns out. So what keeps a person coming back to a race that will, given half a chance, belt the bejesus out of you for the better part of two days when you are part of the pointy end of the fleet? Ask Christian Beck Posted on 3 Nov
Spectacular Start to the Route du Rhum
Our video of the action plus the Monday morning fleet update It was a picture-perfect start in bright Autumn sunshine off Saint Malo as the 115-boat fleet started the 3,542 nautical mile Route du Rhum – Destination Guadeloupe on Sunday 1st November at 1.02pm French time. Posted on 2 Nov
Route du Rhum Video Preview
115 solo skippers, a huge race village, 2 favourites 115 solo sailors will be starting the Route du Rhum - Destination Guadeloupe on Sunday 1st November from St. Malo, France. Posted on 29 Oct
Who is maintaining the boat?
I was fascinated by John Curnow's recent editorial 'Who is sailing the boat?' I was fascinated by John Curnow's recent editorial 'Who is sailing the boat?' where he asked the question about whether sailing is becoming a purely technological battle, replacing the skills needed by a human to helm a yacht at the best speed. Posted on 27 Oct
Pietro Negri Interview
Pathways, Retention, and the Pivotal Olympic Decision Pietro Negri is one of the most knowledgeable and highly respected figures in the Italian sailing industry, and has a unique insight into what is happening at clubs, within classes, and to the sport as a whole. Posted on 27 Oct
A record El Niño, and the 2026 Sydney Hobart
How's that for conjecture? Talk about long-range forecasting! How's that for conjecture? Talk about long-range forecasting! You know, there is something rather intriguing, and decidedly attractive about the prospect of a record-breaking El Niño presiding over the 2026 Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race. Posted on 22 Oct
What next for Olympic sailing?
We speak to Sailingfast's Duncan Hepplewhite If there is anyone in the UK who gets to see exactly what is happening in the UK sailing scene and what is attracting sailors to the sport, then it's Sailingfast's Duncan Hepplewhite. Posted on 18 Oct
Ferrari Hypersail Technology and Innovations
We speak to the team and take a look Ferrari Hypersail is a project like no other, and has brought together experts from automotive, aeronautics, and of course the marine world, to build a yacht which is teeming with new ideas and new engineering. Posted on 17 Oct
Olympic Sailing and the Importance of Pathways
The classes and events that should be in the Olympics is always a contentious topic The classes and events that should be in the Olympics is always a contentious topic. Every type of dinghy, keelboat or board has its fans, and they will argue the point for its inclusion with fervour. Posted on 14 Oct
Who is sailing the boat?
Technology, AI, and the line offshore racing cannot afford to discover too late Well, the alternate headline is nowhere near as catchy. For it simply goes, ‘Technology, AI, and the line offshore racing cannot afford to discover too late.' So, accurate, yes. In-your-face? Definitely! Posted on 7 Oct