Please select your home edition
Edition
Upffront 2020 Foredeck Club LEADERBOARD

Andersen's Compact Electric Winches: Space-saving Saviour or Subpar Alternative?

by Phil Anniss 14 May 09:00 BST
Andersen Compact Electric Winch options for all applications © Andersen

When choosing an electric winch, motor placement is a critical design decision. In a previous article, we delved into the options, cross-examining the differences between a horizontal, vertical and compact motor placement.

The ultimate factor behind choosing the motor placement of your new electric winch is the configuration of your boat and the space available in the cabin headroom or storage locker. Compact electric winches take up the least amount of space and are perfect for boats where headroom is at a premium.

Harken and Andersen both offer a compact electric winch range, designed with a smaller motor that takes up less space below deck than a horizontal or vertical electric winch. In this article, we'll take a look at Andersen's compact range.

Andersen's Compact Electric Winch Range

Andersen offer two compact winch models: below deck or above deck. The latter requires no space below deck at all, with the motor mounted straight onto the deck.

A common question regarding compact electric winches is 'How does a compact winch compare? Does a smaller motor mean you are settling for less?'.

The short answer is no. In this case, smaller does not mean less power. To achieve this, Andersen's compact winches utilise a different motor technology than their horizontal configuration.

Andersen's compact winches use a 'brushless DC motor', more affectionately known as a 'pancake motor'. These motors have a lower, cylindrical profile, drastically reducing the space required.

And despite the smaller size, these motors pack a lot of punch! Let's take a look at Andersen's size 40 24V electric winch, for example.

HorizontalCompact - Below DeckCompact - Above deck
Gear Ratio 1 (X:1)1.31.31.3
Gear Ratio 2 (X:2)666
Power Ratio 1 (X:1)8.98.98.9
Power Ratio 2 (X:2)404040
Motor Length (mm)300195200
Battery Capacity (ah)603535
Line Entry (mm)7979155

Advantages

As you can see from the table, all three models have the same power and gear ratios, but the compact models benefit from a dramatic battery saving. Whilst the horizontal model requires an additional 60 amp-hours of battery capacity per winch, the compact models require only 35 amp-hours per winch. This is far less draw on your boats electrical supply.

Another distinct advantage of Andersen's compact electric winches is the variable speed switch. When operating in their electric mode, most horizontal winches in the Andersen range typically operate at one speed, where there is no control on the speed of the winch.

This can have its drawbacks. For example, if the winch operator wanted to trim the sail, only needing a very small amount of line to be hauled in, having one electric speed can make it difficult, with the winch operating at a fast speed straight away as soon as the button is pressed. To get round this, the operator will have to only quickly press the button.

Andersen's compact winches have a variable speed switch, with the speed of winching changing depending on the pressure applied to the switch. Using this, the winch operator can lightly press the button and the winch will move slowly, until the desired sail shape has been achieved.

Drawbacks

However, there are some crucial things to bear in mind when considering a compact model. As Andersen's above deck model requires the motor to be mounted on deck, the line entry height is considerably higher, significantly altering the angle of approach of your lines. Your clutches, turning blocks and lines will likely need to be adjusted accordingly to achieve the recommended line entry angle of 3-8 degrees.

In addition, with the motor more exposed to the elements, additional precautions should be taken to protect from water ingress.

Price is also a major factor to consider: Andersen's compact electric winches are up to 60% more expensive than the horizontal configuration.

Conclusion

Andersen's compact electric winches are certainly a good choice for sailboats low on headroom space, and sailors can be certain they are not settling for less with regards to power. For sailboats where space is not a hindering factor, choosing Andersen's horizontal winch versus the compact range is a toss up between saving money or saving amp hours.

You can View the range of Andersen Winches on upffront.com or if you have any questions about switching to electric winches, you can contact or use the Winch Enquiry Form.

Related Articles

The Future of Deck Hardware
Morfrac Systems discusses how designs have come full circle Deck hardware has come full circle. Now, designers favour simple designs that make use of high-performance materials over complex concepts. We spoke to Nicolas Goldenberg of Morfrac Systems, the mind behind the disruptive morfblock. Posted on 24 Jun
Introducing Premium Ropes and Stirotex Fibre
A new UHMPE fibre is starting to appear in offshore classes Premium Ropes is an Amsterdam based rope supplier, rigging workshop and resource centre for all things running rigging. They quickly gained profile by running physical splicing workshops in the Netherlands and publishing videos on YouTube. Posted on 10 Jun
Light, Simple Line Control
upffront.com look at why the Antal Soft Loop Hook is a great idea Italian marine hardware manufacturer, Antal, have been creating sailing solutions since 1977 and have designed a range of sailing hardware. Their Soft Loop Hook is a lightweight, flexible, simple to use device for adjusting genoa or spinnaker sheet leads. Posted on 3 Jun
Antal's XT range and Maxi range
Electric winches undeniably make sailing more accessible Electric winches have long been a hot topic of debate at Upffront.com. On the one hand, they are a considerable financial investment and are often stigmatised for not being 'real' sailing. Posted on 28 May
A New Twist on Soft Shackles
The new LOOP Cover Shackles take things one step further LOOP soft shackles are a simple, yet highly versatile product. They can be used almost anywhere that you would use a conventional shackle and have an incredible strength to weight ratio, as you would expect from Dyneema. Posted on 21 May
Mantagua's Certified NAVIPRO Navigation Lights
Products enabling lighter, faster and safer sailing from upffront.com Lighter, faster and safer sailing is our mantra. Thus, we're excited to launch our new product category - Navigation Lights - on Upffront.com, to keep you safe at sea. Posted on 6 May
Karver KF V3 Furler Accessories Guide
upffront.com help you identify what will fit best into your set-up The Karver KF V3 range is now available at upffront.com and with this latest iteration of their popular KF furlers, Karver have moved away from dedicated top-down drums in favour of a more flexible modular system. Posted on 29 Apr
The LOOP Boa Constrictor Clutch
Maximise your deck space - build vertically! Deck space is prime real estate on a sailboat, with clutches and jammers vying for space, often on narrow areas such as the cabin top or mast. So what do you do if you can't fit any more clutches to your deck? Build vertically! Posted on 22 Apr
Horizontal, Vertical or Compact Motor?
Electric sailboat winch options examined by upffront.com You've chosen to upgrade from a manual winch to an electric winch. Now, you need to decide on motor placement. This is a critical design decision which largely depends on your boat's available space below deck. Posted on 15 Apr