Please select your home edition
Noble Marine 2020 - LEADERBOARD

Noble Marine Comet Nationals at Burghfield Sailing Club

by Chris Robinson 31 May 2017 08:46 BST 27-29 May 2017

There were twenty four entries for the Comet Nationals, sponsored by Noble Marine, at Burghfield Sailing Club over the bank holiday weekend, 27-29th May 2017. The first two days were held in conjunction with the Combined Comet Class Association Inland Championships for the Trios and Duos, also sponsored by Noble Marine. A ten race series was planned.

The first days racing was in wind gusting up to F4, which was stronger than expected. However, the Southerly breeze allowed the Race Officer, Ian Bullock, to set a trapezoid course with two beats, one for the Comet singlehander, and the other for the Trios and Duos. This ensured that the fleets did not mix. Gates were used instead of leeward marks, which provided additional tactical options. The singlehanders started first, which ensured the fleets were not too far apart at the finish, which minimised the wait between races.

In race one Eddie Pope was first to the windward mark, followed by Alan Bennett, while the leaders followed Eddie around the starboard gate. Boats further back tried the port gate, but there appeared to be no advantage to either side. Nigel Austin started to gain on the beat, but a capsize put him out of contention. Eddie gradually pulled away, and was never caught, while Chris Robinson caught Alan to take second.

As race one was rather short, an additional lap was added for the following races. Dave Harris was first to the windward mark, but he was caught on the following legs and there were several changes of lead. Dave had a near collision with Alan Bennett as he tried to exit the leeward gate on the port side, only to find his way blocked by Alan Bennett trying to exit to starboard. In the confusion Dave capsized, and this put him out of contention. Chris Robinson took the lead, and he was challenged by Chris Hatton on the third lap, and then by Alan on the final lap, but he kept the lead and won, with Alan second. The fleet returned to shore for lunch.

In race three Nigel was first to the top mark, followed by Ian Stone. However, Ian capsized on the run allowing Ben Palmer to move up into second. The wind had shifted, which resulted in the port side of the gate being favoured. However, this posed a dilemma for the competitors as this side required a gybe to exit the gate, while the starboard exit avoided the need to gybe in the windy conditions. Nigel and Ben pulled away from the rest of the fleet. Unfortunately they miscounted the number of laps, and sailed for the finish a lap early. This allowed Bob Dodds to take the lead, followed by Ian Stone, who had recovered well from his earlier capsize. Nigel and Ben realised their mistake and chased these two up the beat, catching Ian at the windward mark. However, they were unable to pass Bob, who held on to win, with Nigel second.

For the last race of the day, the wind had shifted slightly, which allowed the Race Officer to set a longer beat. However, the second beat was now shorter, so all fleets used the first beat, with the Trios starting first. Ian was clear ahead at mark one, and he began to pull away. Nigel also pulled clear, and began to catch Ian. A poor gybe by Ian at the gate allowed Nigel to get past, and he then kept the lead to win, with Ian second. Although the Race Officer thought about adding an additional race in anticipation of a lack of wind the following day, he decided that the competitors had had enough, and racing finished for the day.

At the end of day one Chris Robinson was leading, but by the thinnest of margins as Bob Dodds, who was in second place, was on equal points. However, with only six points separating the top eight places, the Championship was wide open.

The second day of racing started with no wind on the water and the postponement flag went up. Eventually an early lunch was called as the Race Officer was hopeful that the wind would fill in during the afternoon. The wind did not materialise, and the Race Officer's optimism waned. However, some of the fleet were still keen, so the fleet launched at 14:45. However, by the time they were on the water, what wind there was had disappeared and the racing was abandoned for the day. The evening was taken up with the AGM and a roast beef dinner, during which a pleasant breeze picked up. The Race Officer brought the start time for the next day's racing forward so that four races could be fitted in, which would recover two of the four lost races of day two.

The wind for the final days sailing was less than was hoped. However the wind direction had changed, which allowed the Race Officer to set a windward, leeward course the length of the lake. Chris Hatton led the fleet up the right hand side of the course, which avoided the islands. However, Alan went left and around the islands and this allowed him to catch Chris by the windward mark. These two pulled away from the rest of the fleet, but Chris was unable to catch Alan. The wind dropped, but then returned, which allowed the race to be completed.

A ninety degree wind shift before race six meant the course had to be reset. The Race Officer kept the windward/leeward configuration as it allowed the course to be adjusted rapidly, but moved to shorter laps. The race got underway, and Chris Hatton was ahead of Eddie at the first mark, with Alan not far behind. The wind dropped completely on the run, and as the fleet headed up the beat the Race Officer decided to shorten at the top mark. The wind filled in as the first three approached the finish, and there wasn't much distance between, them. However, the final places were unchanged.

There was a further postponement while the Race Officer waited for the wind to settle, and arrived with their drone to take some photos. After six races there were six different winners. Chris Hatton was leading Alan by two points, but there were four others within six points of Chris. In addition race seven would give an additional discard, and this would allow most of the others to discard a worse score than Chris.

Race seven started with an individual recall for Chris Robinson after he was pushed over the line. There were several boats very close at the front of the fleet for the first lap. They split into two groups as they passed each side of the leeward gate, and by the end of the second beat Chris Hatton was leading Eddie, followed by Bob. Eddie passed Chris on the run, but he miscounted the number laps, and started another beat instead of reaching to the finish. This allowed Chris to win, with Bob second, and Eddie third.

There was a further wait for the wind to settle, but by the time it did there was insufficient time for the Race Officer to set a course before the 2pm deadline set in the Sailing Instructions. Therefore, the racing was concluded with only seven of the ten races completed. Chris Hatton's win in the final race gave him the Championship. Eddie's error in that race cost him, as he had the same number of points as Bob, and count back failed to split them. The result of the last race was used, which gave Bob the runner up position.

Further back the Ladies prize was contested by Carol Butcher and Isla Macneal. Isla had a one point lead after the first day, but on the last day the positions were reversed by the end of race six, with Carol ahead of Isla by two points. In the final race both sailed a discard, which gave Carol the Ladies prize. The Newcomer prize was contested by Alan Hatton and Tim Higgs. Alan was ahead by two points after the first day, but his results on the final day put him well ahead at the end.

Overall Results:

PosRigSail NoHelm NameClubR1R2R3R4R5R6R7Pts
1stStandard48Chris HattonSevern SC43‑6‑721111
2ndStandard869Bob DoddsCrawley Mariners YC5413‑13‑8215
3rdStandard804Edwin PopeOgston SC15‑8‑1042315
4thStandard126Alan BennettStaunton Harold SC62‑11613‑718
5thStandard875Nigel AustinCransley SC‑9‑92137619
6thStandard867Chris RobinsonBurghfield SC2175‑115‑1520
7thStandard701Izac DoddsCrawley Mariners YC76‑13‑1154426
8thStandard597Ben PalmerBaltic Wharf SC383‑98‑11527
9thStandard844Paul HindeSevern SC10754‑22‑131036
10thStandard841Dave HarrisSevern SC‑11‑1210866838
11thStandard152Ian StoneMaidenhead SC8114217‑20(DNC)42
12thStandard599Paul JagoAttenborough SC12‑21(DNC)1279949
13thStandard532John CoppenhallHunts SC131012‑141010‑1455
14thXtra800Henry JaggersBeer SC141514‑17‑18121166
15thStandard484Richard SteptoeBaltic Wharf SC1513151316‑22‑1972
16thStandard845Nigel FernStaunton Harold SC(DNF)141616‑20161274
17thXtra838Alan HattonSevern SC‑201619(DNC)12191682
18thXtra886Andrew SimmonsRYA191991521‑23(DNC)83
19thXtra614Carol ButcherHawley Lake STC171718‑191418‑2084
20thXtra847Isla MacnealBaltic Wharf SC16201718‑2315‑2186
21stStandard400John SturgeonHawley Lake STC(DNC)(DNC)DNCDNC15141392
22ndStandard57Steve GregoryFrensham Pond SC(DNC)(DNC)DNCDNC9171793
23rdXtra849Timothy HiggsBurghfield SC1818(DNF)(DNF)19211894
24thStandard433Andy DaleEyott SC(DNC)(DNC)DNCDNCDNCDNCDNC125

Related Articles

Comets at Crawley Mariners
Bob Dodds proves to be the master of Hedgecourt Lake It's unusual for anyone to finish ahead of Bob Dodds in races held at his home venue of Hedgecourt Lake, and this once again proved to be the case at the Crawley Mariners Comet Open meeting held on 18 September. Posted on 21 Sep
Derbyshire Youth Sailing at Carsington
Happy to see a lot of sailors who were not only new to DYS but also to racing Saturday 11th September saw our sailors back at Carsington Sailing Club for our ninth event of this years series, the biggest water we visit, so a new experience for some. Posted on 14 Sep
Comets at Bala
An imprmptu event after the nationals was cancelled The 2021 Nationals should have been at Bala over the August bank holiday, but due to a Covid outbreak at the club the event had to be cancelled at the last moment. Posted on 9 Sep
Comets at Merthyr Tydfil
One of those lovely autumnal windless mornings The forecast was for light winds F2, gusting F3 from the southeast veering to south as the day goes on. As is often the case in September we have those lovely autumnal windless mornings. Posted on 8 Sep
Comet Championships at Winsford Flash
30 boats add to numbers at one of the largest Comet fleets in the country Winsford Flash Sailing Club, in the heart of Cheshire, was proud to host the 2021 Comet Class Association Championships over the weekend of the 17th and 18th July 2021. Posted on 29 Jul
Comets at Cransley
20 entrants, including all the Comets from the home club On Sunday 11th June 2021 we hosted the Comet Open (as we have done for annually for many years) but this years was wonderful on so many levels. Posted on 18 Jul
Comet Traveller's Series at Fishers Green
No weed this year so the whole lake was in use Fishers Green SC held their Comet open meeting as part of their traveller's series. The forecast of NE wind is usually considered a good direction but the wind would be up and down all day with big shifts creating a snakes and ladders affair. Posted on 22 Jun
Derbyshire Youth Sailing at Burton
23 sailors engage in some excellent battles in the sun With sun, a good wind and reasonable temperatures, Saturday the 24th April started out with great promise and as 23 boats were rigged at Burton Sailing Club we knew our second Derbyshire Youth Sailing Event of the year was going to be a good one. Posted on 30 Apr
Noble Marine sponsor 2021 racing season
Combined Comet class have events at Whitefriars, Llangorse and Exe The Combined Comet Class Association is delighted to announce the continued sponsorship from Noble Marine Insurance for the 2021 racing season. Posted on 30 Apr
Storm Jorge hits club racing at Welwyn Garden City
Comet powers past Supernova Welwyn Garden City Sailing Club races every Saturday morning throughout the year on Stanborough Lake. It may be a puddle by some standards - just 15.3 acres - but we have a lot of fun and last Saturday was no exception. Posted on 2 Mar 2020