RYA raises concerns over quality of evidence for MCZs
by Louise Nicholls, RYA 8 Mar 2014 16:46 GMT
8 March 2014
Flame Shell in Scotland © Graham Saunders, Marine Scotland Image Bank
Gus Lewis, Head of Legal and Government Affairs stressed the need for robust and balanced evidence to support the designation of Marine Conservation Zones (MCZs) whilst giving evidence to the Environmental Audit Committee this week.
The RYA is concerned about what appears to be a growing disparity between the amount of evidence relating to the environmental benefits of designation and that relating to the socio-economic impacts of designation. The Government is investing in the gathering of environmental data but not in the latter, which places the socio-economic argument at a disadvantage.
"We support the Government's current objective approach that if lawful activities are potentially going to be regulated or prohibited, then there must be robust evidence which clearly demonstrates that the protected flora and fauna does exist and that it cannot reasonably co-exist with local activities.
"However, if there is an imbalance in the evidence available then the decision-making cannot be objective".
The RYA also reiterated the need for some indication of potential management measures early on in the process of designation.
"Throughout the MCZ process the RYA consistently argued that it is just not possible to analyse the potential impact of an MCZ on recreational boating without some indication of the management measures that might be implemented," concludes Gus.
The Environmental Audit Committee is examining a range of topics in relation to MCZs following the Science and Technology Committee's report last year including: plans for implementing the 27 so far approved MCZs, how they will be monitored, managed and enforced, the plans to improve the evidence base for considering potential further Zones and what the balance of factors should be.
Love boating? Then why not join the association that promotes and protects, safe, successful and rewarding British boating. Join today and support the RYA in protecting your boating rights and freedoms. Take advantage of free advice and support on all aspects of your boating, as well as enjoying a range of fantastic personal member offers. Find out more by calling 0844 556 9556, email or visit www.rya.org.uk