Merlin or Scorpion?

They both look lovely and I'm not in the market for either, but what's the pro's and cons of each? Which would you pick?

Haven't sailed a Scorpion since 1986, I think. Sailed Merlins a little round that time, too. Back then, they had a similar handicap, but the Merlin must have moved on a lot since.

I'd pick the Scorpion, for similar reasons to KW's above for the Merlin.

Many years ago, I sailed a season with a pal who had a newish Merlin.   I've gotta say it was lovely to sail, especially upwind.   A rather suspect a Scorp is less rewarding/harder work/more-pain-less-gain etc on the long upwind legs.   Dunno, I could be doing it a disservice.    So, I'd take the Merlin.   But then I like boats that are quick upwind as it get the hard bit over a bit quicker !

Only one option - go for the Merlin Rocket and b*gger the cost - you'll spend more on a car and get much less enjoyment.

The other thing to consider are the excellent open circuits that the Merlin's have - both National (Silver Tiller series) and regional eg Midlands and Thames as well as the usual Nationals and Inland champs plus the not to be missed Merlin Rocket week at Salcombe with 120 boats of all ages competing. There is also a Vintage racing scene if you're in to old woodies rather than FRP and carbon fibre.

But I will admit to a slight bias!

Depends what you mean by 'silly car'.

A brand spanking new Merlin Rocket will set you back about the same amount as your normal boring family car. If we are considering a silly, souped up car then a Merlin is considerably cheaper.

However, you do not need to buy new as Merlin's are very well built and a good secondhand boat will set you back a lot less than the family car. With a bit of pimping and a good helm/crew you can be competitive.