Author |
Share Topic Topic Search Topic Options
|
Sailing-rocks1
Newbie
Joined: 12 Mar 09
Location: United Kingdom
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 15
|
Post Options
Quote Reply
Topic: Laser 2000 Vs RS 400 Posted: 12 Mar 09 at 3:04pm |
Thanks RS400.
You mention that there have been some improvements made to the rudder and plate. Any idea when this was done?
|
Richard
|
 |
Wes
Groupie
Joined: 24 Aug 05
Location: United Kingdom
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 97
|
Post Options
Quote Reply
Posted: 12 Mar 09 at 7:56pm |
Hi Richard.
A couple of years ago I was in the smae position as you. Looking between the RS200 and RS400. I bought the 400 as I wanted the faster boat thinking I'd soon get to grips with it coming from a windsurfing background. While I think i would have kept the 400, my 5'2" wife simply wasn't strong enough to sort out the front end, particually with my somewhat erratic helming. So, after about a year of swimming I sold the 400 and bought what i should have had from the start - the 200. So, if you are really positive that a fair amount of swimming will not put you off and that you will have a crew who can cope with front then I think it'll be a great buy. Mind you, they are getting to be in short supply at them moment! Where are you based? Can you get a test sail in one?
|
 |
Jamesd
Far too distracted from work
Joined: 01 Feb 08
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 377
|
Post Options
Quote Reply
Posted: 12 Mar 09 at 8:33pm |
ive known people to sail 400s as beginners and they have picked it up fine. thought id stick some points in from roger gilbert and a few of my own.
A few thoughts below from roger gilbert
Boats don't seem to get heavier... even the new ones leak a bit so don't worry about this too much... if its dry when you see it it's probably OK. No correctors ever, weights vary quite a bit but no one worries about it and hence it doesn't really matter...:-)
The foils were changed in around 2001 - definitely worth a new c/board if you can get one and new rudders are also much nicer though I never bothered to change mine. The new ones have near razor sharp edges and a near perfect gloss finish and are much stronger.... the old ones had around a 3mm trailing edge and a matt finish and ripples and bumps etc. They are allegedly the same shape but I'm convinced the new ones point better. It's v important to pack the foils into the case... normally there is about 2mm of slop on a new boat!
Mainsails last forever and don't really slow down at all in my opinion... I still use my 6 year old one! They shrink quite a bit especially in the bolt rope but this actually isn't much of a problem, just swing on the cunningham a few times! The problems tend to centre around not protecting the battens where they touch the spreader / shrouds.
The actual finish of the kite makes a big difference to how easy it is to fly and gybe... once the silicon breaks down it tends to stick to the jib - that said I notice very little speed difference between a brand new kite and a really old one in a straight line - there is an enormous amount to be gained from sailing the waves, changing angles, weight position etc. This is easily worth around 200m a nationals run in marginal planing conditions over even a well sailed boat... a new kite will only make a couple of lengths difference if you're lucky so I wouldn't worry about it too much to start... that said a new one is expensive. Once again the kite cloth was changed about 2 years ago... the new one is slippier but in my opinion definitely doesn't last as long! If you have problems flying the kite, before blaming it completely check the luff rope inside the kite... these can get untied / broken and the kite becomes completely unstable and impossible to fly... they're actually quite sensitive to the tension in this.
Jibs tend to suffer most, however they are made of a pretty heavy 5oz cloth so last reasonably well... look for wear at batten ends and check they aren't broken (it's generally not a good idea to wrap the sail around the forestay but many people do!). If they're broken its a nightmare to repair. Realistically a new jib should easily last a couple of seasons of events... probably slightly less if you use it every weekend... despite all the grumblings they actually last pretty well in my opinion.
Check the joins running down the sections of the foredeck... cracks here normally suggest something is moving - they're quite common and I don't know of many problems... so I suppose no cracks is definitely a good sign!.
There have been several revisions to the masts (honest!), hard to tell the difference unless you lay them side by side but things to look for are spreader ends permenantly fixed to shrouds... older masts had the blue detachable ends (which can fail and the mast will break )and a solid aluminium mast foot. Middle aged masts ( a slightly different section to old masts - one design... !) generally have the spreaders fixed to the shrouds and a mast foot (aluminium) with a central gap in it. New masts have the overhanging pulley option at the top. Don't think there is much between any of them tho', bend control is easily achieved using the RAM / spreaders.
Toestraps can wear on underside of thwart so check the wear and either replace them or don't sit out if they're worn!
Mainhalyards are always breaking... check if it is kevlar (standard fit), if so replace it straight away and save yourself some hassle - I'd strongly recommend 2:1 4mm spectra.
Most 400 masts will lean / bend slightly when setup with the same pin settings, 9/10 boats I've looked at require the LHS pin to be 1/2 a hole lower, so check bend when in its on the floor as well as in the boat.
Booms corrode and break at the main sheet blocks eventually.. worth a check.
Any slop in the rudder is a nightmare and if you get an older boat replacing all the pintles and gudgeons is well worth the cost. Also the tiller is rivetted into the rudder stock so if there is any play renew the rivets or replace with bolts.
Poles seem to be either bent through collision or indestructable in less than 40knts!
Another to check for is the condition of the hull where it sits on the trolley... some people put carpet on their trolleys and this holds moisture agains the hull which is a bad idea! Speaking of trolleys if you can get hold of a gunwhale hung one (they don't make them any more) they were much better, though harder to launch with... the new fibreglass cradle ones are pretty poorly designed and as soon as the boat rocks on the trolley in any wind the edges of the cradle snap and the whole thing becomes very unstable on the beach!
Happpy sailing...
Just some of my own thoughts:
the moulds were changed in 2001 which i think is about 1100+ numberwise. not a great deal of difference, apart from the foils.
the early 1200s were pretty shoddy built. But fast. like mine, 1210, its a fast boat but not very well made. paul bowen had 1225 and he sent it back a few times because of the quality. but they are oldish boats now (5 years old) and if anything is likely to go wrong it will have by now. so dont be too put off.
An older boat is fine, they still seem to be stiff and as long as it isnt to beaten about will probably be fine. 2nd at this years nats was number 9?? and 4th was 645. the hulls are very much the same whatever age as long as they have no repairs dents scratches etc. you do often find that they are very basic and often require a bit of money spent on them to get them up to a easy racing standard. i.e. the rope is pretty shoddy and blocks are crap.
The boats run very high rig tensions, 400-500lbs and some guys will increase to 600 although i dont like punishing my boat like that. at these loads, most boats will have cracks in places, mainly on the gunwhale (it looks like someone has wound the ratchet straps on too tight when trailing) they are only in the gel, but does suggest a lack of stiffness in the hull. But....if a boat doesnt have cracks there, it may be because it hasnt been run at these loads as the tuning guides only say 350lbs (no idea why). also you sometimes see cracks in the deck, on the joint of the cb case and deck, generrally from a fat helm.
Definately check for corrosion on the mast and the boom, look for cracks where the mainsheet blocks are (the guy that drilled two holes on the tension side of a member that has high loads applied wants sacking)
Roger mentions looking for cracks in the foredeck/deck joint and that suggests somethings moved. well on reason this moves is the post holding the deck up (in fron tof the mast) sometimes gets hit hard by the spinnaker pole and bends and thus moves the foredeck and cracks the joint. this isnt a big problem at all.
|
 |
RS400atC
Really should get out more
Joined: 04 Dec 08
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 3011
|
Post Options
Quote Reply
Posted: 12 Mar 09 at 8:53pm |
Originally posted by Wes
Hi Richard.
A couple of years ago I was in the smae position as you. Looking between the RS200 and RS400. I bought the 400 as I wanted the faster boat thinking I'd soon get to grips with it coming from a windsurfing background. While I think i would have kept the 400, my 5'2" wife simply wasn't strong enough to sort out the front end, particually with my somewhat erratic helming. So, after about a year of swimming I sold the 400 and bought what i should have had from the start - the 200. So, if you are really positive that a fair amount of swimming will not put you off and that you will have a crew who can cope with front then I think it'll be a great buy. Mind you, they are getting to be in short supply at them moment! Where are you based? Can you get a test sail in one?
|
The above is fair comment, the kite is not small. We have a couple of fairly petite female 400 crew in our club, but they are both quite fit and not scared of getting wet. One is 13 I think and the other has kids older than that! Depends how much wind you want to sail in, I originally took the view I'd sail with my wife in light air and find a student when it's blowing. We wimped out of a windy choppy open last year but apart from that I've had to look for crew for perhaps 5 races out of 70 or so. I'm happy with that, I can usually find another bloke in the same position, or its a good excuse to take a friend out. Our nationals at Mounts Bay could be a challenge if it blows!
The class association coaching helped us sort out gybes, so we don't capsize so often now!
It is a lot of boat, but I can't say you have to be a superstar to sail one. If you are the right size for an RS200, they have good racing, but we're a bit heavy and we have the club fleet of 400's 15 minutes drive from home. I would come back to my point about joining a fleet, I would have bought in to whatever looked a good boat/club/fleet combination. But I'm very pleased with the 400.
I don't know the details of the foil changes. Might be worth asking RS. They also have demo boats at Burgerfield and seem quite reasonable about people who intend to buy used.
Good Luck with whatever you go for!
|
 |
Mikey 14778
Far too distracted from work
Joined: 05 Feb 09
Location: United Kingdom
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 298
|
Post Options
Quote Reply
Posted: 13 Mar 09 at 12:21pm |
Originally posted by Jamesd
The boats run very high rig tensions, 400-500lbs and some guys will increase to 600... |
Is that measured on the forestay or the shrouds ?
|
|
 |
ChrisJ
Far too distracted from work
Joined: 07 May 04
Location: United Kingdom
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 337
|
Post Options
Quote Reply
Posted: 13 Mar 09 at 12:51pm |
Weight carrying ability is very similar in the Laser 2000 and RS400:
At our club, the 400 is sailed by people between 21 stone and 31 stone plus. Heavier people find it easier when it blows, and the light weights switch to a 200 when its too windy.
The regular L2000 racers vary between 18 stone (travellers winners) and 30 stone or so. Both boats have an average of around 24 stone or so.
Sheet loads on the L2000 are MUCH less than on the 400, so easier on the smaller / shorter people. On the circuit, there are lots more kids crewing / helming L2000 than you find in the 400: much more family oriented.
Both boats have good class racing on the circuit - if you dont want to travel, then choose what is at your local club. AND make sure that it is not just "boats in the dinghy park" but people on the water when you want to sail. We find we have more 400's out on a Sunday, and lots more 2000's out on a Saturday or Wednesday evening!
You can always buy both! Sail the 400 when its light winds and inland, and the 2000 when its stronger or out at sea...
|
 |
Jamesd
Far too distracted from work
Joined: 01 Feb 08
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 377
|
Post Options
Quote Reply
Posted: 13 Mar 09 at 1:06pm |
Originally posted by Mikey 14778
Originally posted by Jamesd
The boats run very high rig tensions, 400-500lbs and some guys will increase to 600...
|
Is that measured on the forestay or the shrouds ?
|
Measured on the shrouds.
forestay i believe is about 1.7 (ish) of that of the shrouds. but no one uses it.
ive only run it at 500lbs once and will only normally run at 400lbs, mainly because i sail on the sea and its more forgiving with a slacker rig in the waves, but there is a considerable increase in power/height with increased tension
|
 |
Jamesd
Far too distracted from work
Joined: 01 Feb 08
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 377
|
Post Options
Quote Reply
Posted: 13 Mar 09 at 1:15pm |
Originally posted by RS400atC
[QUOTE=Wes]
Our nationals at Mounts Bay could be a challenge if it blows!
|
gonna be bloody awesome if its windy down there.
Big waves are very easy to sail in, even in 30 knots of wind. Sailing in the solent, wind against tide in 30 knots is probably one of the hardest sailing conditions (in terms of boat handling) so if you wanna perfect your gybes i highly recomend spending a windy day falling over off of lee on the solent or hill head
|
 |
ChrisJ
Far too distracted from work
Joined: 07 May 04
Location: United Kingdom
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 337
|
Post Options
Quote Reply
Posted: 13 Mar 09 at 1:56pm |
And as for sailing the boats before you buy, always a good idea, but not something I practise!
I bought our first (of 3) RS400 in 2002 without ever having sailed one before: based on the fact there was a good fleet at my local club, and the people who saild them seemed to be of a similar standard.
I bought our Laser 2000 this time last year without ever having sailed one before: based on the speed of the boats in handicap races at Bloody Mary and Battle of the Classes that year, the friendliness of the fleet to new owners on their discussion group, the size of the fleets at Open Meetings, and the numbers in the dinghy park at our local club.
|
 |