RS aero

Originally posted by jeffers http://www.yachtsandyachting.com/news/185311/RS-Aero-Magic-Marine-Nationals-overall Not a bad report and looks like fun was had by all. I do think the reporter should check the facts though as at no point (according to the results) were all 74 competitors on the water at the same time.

Originally posted by JimC Originally posted by iiiiitick ...plausible arguments to counter my prejudiced rants. Please stop doing this. Can't help it. Its an insane compulsion.

Originally posted by iiiiitick ...plausible arguments to counter my prejudiced rants. Please stop doing this.

Can't help it. Its an insane compulsion.

Originally posted by JimC Originally posted by iiiiitick This huge instant turnout is at the expense of other classes. 'one mans loss is another mans gain'. You're making the assumption this is a zero sum game. Not as simple as that. If we just think of Champs turnouts, do you suppose every one of those people went to a Champs in a different class last year that they won't go to this year, or is it possible some of them are full of new enthusiasm and going to a champs for the first time or first time for a while? Every class has people who own boats but for one reason or another are a bit down on enthusiasm and don't actually use them. If those people get enthused by a different class and start sailing regularly their old class is no worse off. Indeed it may be better off, since a decent boat may come on the market and be available for someone moving out of junior classes. So its not a zero sum game, its not one wins, the other loses, and a burst of enthusiasm for a new class or competition conceivably could benefit everyone.

Originally posted by iiiiitick This huge instant turnout is at the expense of other classes. 'one mans loss is another mans gain'.

You're making the assumption this is a zero sum game. Not as simple as that. If we just think of Champs turnouts, do you suppose every one of those people went to a Champs in a different class last year that they won't go to this year, or is it possible some of them are full of new enthusiasm and going to a champs for the first time or first time for a while?

Every class has people who own boats but for one reason or another are a bit down on enthusiasm and don't actually use them. If those people get enthused by a different class and start sailing regularly their old class is no worse off. Indeed it may be better off, since a decent boat may come on the market and be available for someone moving out of junior classes.

So its not a zero sum game, its not one wins, the other loses, and a burst of enthusiasm for a new class or competition conceivably could benefit everyone.

Edited by JimC - 31 Aug 15 at 2:00pm