League of Snooty S.C's
Printed From: Yachts and Yachting Online
Category: General
Forum Name: Banter
Forum Discription: For all those non-sailing related discussions
URL: http://www.yachtsandyachting.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=8304
Printed Date: 28 Jun 25 at 7:59pm Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 9.665y - http://www.webwizforums.com
Topic: League of Snooty S.C's
Posted By: G.R.F.
Subject: League of Snooty S.C's
Date Posted: 19 Sep 11 at 9:38am
So, top of my league has always been Bewl, but now racing up there to a close second is Broadstairs, as condescending an experience as ever one might expect from club officers viewing the proceedings from on high at the Man of Kent recently.
My boat being out of action and no chance of getting it fixed on Saturday, my totally cissy crew substitute allowed me to cry off with a warning of 'force 6 and rain all day' only to be greeted by perfect conditions, sun and 2-3 so I visited the scene to watch.
Upon arrival they were on the water, there appeared to be a race crew way up in a box above some old fish murdering gallows establishment which involved a ladder, so not really a place to enter uninvited.
The course was displayed on boards below which made about as much sense as course boards generally do, there were three separate diagrams and there appeared to be three different events, just as I'm watching a chap starts to descend the ladder, so I ask 'which race are they on? Winston Churchill replies with his familiar victory signal, not a word.
I look at the 2nd map it just calls out buoys a,b,c not any indication of how many laps, so I could judge what leg they were on, er 'how many laps?' '45 minutes' the surly cove begrudgingly replies then turns on his heel to shamble off in his blue wellies to consort with another stripy jumpered result of brother and sisterly love.
I look up at the rest of the race team, ignorance, pure down their nose ignorance, and you wonder why...
Broadstairs, I've never raced there don't think I ever will now, the lads seemed to enjoy what looked like a great event and all the on the water stuff seemed to be going swimmingly, guns blazing star shells into the early autumn sunshine, late tourists taking the sun, lots of interest in all those boats out there, no one any the wiser as to what's going on.
Well it's a secret see, only the privileged get to sail... If only they knew the truth eh?
------------- https://www.ease-distribution.com/" rel="nofollow - https://www.ease-distribution.com/
|
Replies:
Posted By: JimC
Date Posted: 19 Sep 11 at 9:51am
Ripped from here http://drrickschaefer5.blog.com/tag/career-advice/ but widely found in different versions...
...a man who moves into a new town, and proceeds to ask the local sage what kind of people live there.
The sage asks, “What kind of people lived in your last town?”
The man answers, “Dishonest people; cheats and liars, and really unfriendly.”
The sage answers, “We have the same kind of people here.”
A second man moves into town and asks the sage the same question, “What kind of people will I find in this town?”
The sage asks the second man, “What kind of people lived in your last town?”
The second man answers, “Wonderful people; helpful, kind and loving.”
The sage now answers, “That is the kind of people you will find in this town as well.” |
|
Posted By: alstorer
Date Posted: 19 Sep 11 at 1:22pm
Graeme is much less abrasive in real life than online. Having now done a fair bit of traveling, I've experienced the odd club like he describes- not necessarily the big "commercial" ones. Some clubs do have a problem with their attitude towards visitors (sailing and otherwise) and even potential new members.
------------- -_
Al
|
Posted By: rogue
Date Posted: 19 Sep 11 at 1:56pm
Arriving in the midlands courtesy of a work relocation, I approached Draycote to find out about joining as returner to the sport.
I had intended to buy a Lark- lots of cheap fun for the recently graduated, only to be told 'we don't sail those here' by the office staff. Needless to say I didn't bother joining. As I also figured there was no where big enough to justify the cost of getting back in to the sport (ex-coastal sailor with a typical misplaced aversion to other little ponds around this part) and didn't bother buying the Lark either (shame, nice boats imo, but too old now to get the best out of them!).
I eventually joined two years later when I set my sights a little lower on the boat evolutionary scale and stupidly bought another knee wrecker- as this was 'allowed' at Draycote...
What did I discover... oh yes, there's a handicap fleet and yes, my prospective Lark would have been very welcome had I just spoken to someone else. Ironically years ago, the club had a very strong fleet of Larks and even had a Lark National Champion- I think he's still using the same spraytop!!!
Is it a snotty club... no, not really- is has it's quirks and petty squabbles like so many. But like a lot of clubs often accused of being snotty, it's just down to catching someone on a bad day.
|
Posted By: furtive
Date Posted: 19 Sep 11 at 2:23pm
I've got to stand up for Broadstairs and say that on the several occassions I've been there for open meetings they've come across as one of the friendliest and least 'snooty' sailing clubs out there. A bit quirky compared to some bigger clubs, but I think you have to expect that if you venture into darkest Kent.
|
Posted By: G.R.F.
Date Posted: 19 Sep 11 at 3:11pm
Don't get me wrong, I dare say there are some 'reasonable' types in fact my guess they were all out on the water putting on what looked like a great event (I'm really p1ssed that I missed it, light shifty winds and tide, I'd have loved that, instead I had the bread knife and daughter in tow they were equally impressed - not), it's just the whole way the sailing world is so often disinterested in the interested observer or passer by, as far as he was concerned I was just some punter on a day trip asking stupid questions and I didn't press the point, knowing what a pain in the neck it can be if you are a recorder or whatever it was they were doing up that ladder.(I do hope they were recorders and not just spectators) However it don't alter the fact they come across wrong and they are now No 2 in my Snooty Clubs list, I don't even get that sort of crap from Hayling, or Parkstone where every stupid question I might have asked has at least been answered civilly and the person happy to spend a little of his her time of day with the query. Broadstairs are a bunch of handicap bandits anyway imv so that incident did nothing to enamour me any further with them.. They shall forthwith be the butt of malicious jokes about sail snobs any time I feel like it.. They're worse than Whitstabewle and that's going some.. 
------------- https://www.ease-distribution.com/" rel="nofollow - https://www.ease-distribution.com/
|
Posted By: rogerd
Date Posted: 19 Sep 11 at 9:51pm
Grumpf at least someone spoke to you. I went to a lake club in the SW and I was ignored by just about everyone there. I have since learnt that I wasnt the only one who is treated this way.
|
Posted By: rogue
Date Posted: 19 Sep 11 at 10:18pm
Originally posted by rogerd
Grumpf at least someone spoke to you. I went to a lake club in the SW and I was ignored by just about everyone there. I have since learnt that I wasnt the only one who is treated this way. |
what do you expect Roger- surrounded by some of the best coastline this god-forsaken island has to offer and they choose to sail on a pond!!!
stay off the moor...
|
Posted By: G.R.F.
Date Posted: 19 Sep 11 at 11:22pm
Originally posted by rogerd
Grumpf at least someone spoke to you. |
Yeah but he didn't he just stuck two fingers up (to indicate race 2 I guess) I had to ask the 2nd question as he walked away. 
------------- https://www.ease-distribution.com/" rel="nofollow - https://www.ease-distribution.com/
|
Posted By: Jack Sparrow
Date Posted: 20 Sep 11 at 7:57am
Salcombe Y.C... If you happen to be sailing in Salcombe week with a wife a baby in tow, and you think it might be nice to have drink after the racing the the club. Don't bother, unless you want to spend a little more time away from your family. As I was aggressively told, with a wagging finger pointing to a sign. Absolutely NO children in the yacht club. It's out side for you. What a great club, I always make a bee line for there bar to spend my cash now, every time I'm down that way.
------------- http://www.uk3-7class.org/index.html" rel="nofollow - Farr 3.7 Class Website
https://www.facebook.com/groups/1092602470772759/" rel="nofollow - Farr 3.7 Building - Facebook Group
|
Posted By: Rockhopper
Date Posted: 20 Sep 11 at 8:27am
Hmmm its funny really if my home club Broadstairs Is so rubbish then how come the guy who has just bought my vareo (oh and he comes from hythe) wants to sail the rest of season here at the very club you are moaning about.Still at least some of the hythe sailors came along to support the event unlike people from other clubs that are quite close to us
------------- Retired now after 35 seasons in a row and time for a rest.
2004 national champ Laser5000
2007,2010,National Champ Rs Vareo
|
Posted By: Rupert
Date Posted: 20 Sep 11 at 9:29am
As has been said, any club can seem unwelcoming if you catch the wrong person, and very welcoming if you catch the right one.
Clubs which have their race hut where the public can wander by have an interesting problem - they must get fed up with daft questions from grockles, but at the same time should keep a friendly face on or end up having their reputation tarnished on the internet, and causing the reputation of sailing to be tarnished in the wider community.
When in America last year, we went to a fantastic sailing club down West Virginia way. It was a Monday afternoon, so really didn't expect anybody to be there, just thought we'd look at the water and the boats. However, there were people there, the bar was open, we were bought drinks (and told, no we weren't allowed to buy, as not members, so the drinks were on them), the kids played on the enormous pirate ship they had on the shore, and we spent several great hours there. All in all, a very welcoming experience, and one I at least try and emulate at Whitefriars when visitors come down, and least to a small extent.
I think I would far rather see a list of clubs on here that people have been made to feel welcome at than one naming clubs at which they had a bad experience, which could be a one off. Mind, so could a good experience, I guess!
------------- Firefly 2324, Puffin 229, Minisail 3446 Mirror 70686
|
Posted By: AndrewLB
Date Posted: 20 Sep 11 at 11:53am
Well I can do both Rupert's "clubs that are good" and GRF's "clubs that hate you" categories.
Everywhere you go people tell you that Hayling is snooty and cliquey. I arrived there as a relative unknown 10 years ago having never been there before with a brand new 700 straight from chandlers ford. Within half an hour a couple of guys had offered to help unpack & rig it with me. Maybe it helped that I'd turned up with the growth class du jour but within a couple of weeks I felt part of the club. The staff are all really helpful and a good proportion of the fleet can be found in the bar afterwards discussing technique and tactics. I'm always surprised at the accusations of snobbery and wonder why it is that some people don't seem to feel welcome; are they intimidated? Is it the fact that sailing in the harbour requires a good year's worth of experience to know the marks and the tide? Who knows?
At the other end of the scale... A group of us had decided to try something different from our usual abersoch summer jaunt and decided to do Camel week instead. On the first evening we went to the club for a drink after racing to be told "I'm sorry but it's members only this evening". During their open summer regatta! Mental. Maybe they could tell we were from Wolverhampton but there was a real sense of being looked at down noses all week despite acquitting ourselves quite well on the water. Maybe it's moved on but it was very unwelcoming in 1997 and we didn't go back.
------------- RS100 227 (10.2)
|
Posted By: rogue
Date Posted: 20 Sep 11 at 1:38pm
Originally posted by AndrewLB
On the first evening we went to the club for a drink after racing to be told "I'm sorry but it's members only this evening". During their open summer regatta! Mental. |
Yep- had the same thing happen at Royal Burnham YC during Burnham Week- fortunately the Corinthian had a more tolerant approach to serving underage drinkers.
|
Posted By: winging it
Date Posted: 20 Sep 11 at 2:15pm
I know the club Roger refers to (I used to be a member there) but it's not on a moor and it's hardly a pond....otherwise his description is pretty much spot on I'm afraid.
My list of great clubs is probably topped by Bala - I've had so much great sailing there, but more importantly, the people are really friendly and helpful.
------------- the same, but different...
|
Posted By: Late starter
Date Posted: 20 Sep 11 at 2:31pm
I'm more inclined to think that there's sometimes a problem with "snooty SC members" rather than snooty clubs. As others have said, it's all down to the individual member one meets. I sail at a small club that I've always found to be incredibly friendly and welcoming, yet one or two of our committee members, unpaid and hard working though they may be, have the interpersonal skills of a cornered ferret and if approached by a newcomer can sometimes be incredibly rude. But for every ferret type I've met in sailing I've met dozens of friendly, pleasant, and helpful people !
|
Posted By: Contender443
Date Posted: 20 Sep 11 at 3:16pm
I've always thought of myself as a temporary member of any club I have attended an open meeting at. Especially as I have paid an entry fee to use all of the facilities. If they are not available to me then I won't be going back and I will tell the CA of my disapproval.
------------- Bonnie Lass Contender 1764
|
Posted By: Pierre
Date Posted: 20 Sep 11 at 3:42pm
Originally posted by Contender443
I've always thought of myself as a temporary member of any club I have attended an open meeting at. Especially as I have paid an entry fee to use all of the facilities. If they are not available to me then I won't be going back and I will tell the CA of my disapproval. |
Quite right. Absolutely spot on Mark. Well said.
I am of the opinion that if you don't want "outsiders" at your club then don't invite them. Problem solved really. And if you can't say anything nice, stfu.
PS... I am going to Whitefriars for free drinks. What a guy that Rupert is. HURRAH !!!!
|
Posted By: Rupert
Date Posted: 20 Sep 11 at 4:19pm
Bring the Osprey, Pierre, and I'll get Roger D up with his Hornet, and we can make a party of it...
------------- Firefly 2324, Puffin 229, Minisail 3446 Mirror 70686
|
Posted By: gordon1277
Date Posted: 20 Sep 11 at 4:26pm
Hi All
the last two clubs for the Phantom nationals have been great Stone sc and Lyme Regis.
I tend to avoid clubs with Members only bars as this lends itself to them and us attitude but I do have some sympathy with large clubs who have to run opens all year to solvent. But when my aged mother and wife turned up to see me come ashore from an open event and were told no you c'ant park in there your not sailing or a member with me having asked the petty hitler on the start of the causeway when I arrived in the morning.
I hope the attitude for that club has changed now as i think the lottery gave them lots of dosh.
My club in the past was not exempt due to some ex services people who still thought it was a wardroom and told one prospective member to come back when he was 3 ranks higher funnily enough he joined another club half a mile away.
Regards
Gordon
------------- Gordon
Lossc
|
Posted By: rogerd
Date Posted: 20 Sep 11 at 4:51pm
Originally posted by Rupert
Bring the Osprey, Pierre, and I'll get Roger D up with his Hornet, and we can make a party of it... |
Which bit of the Hornet do you want me to bring Rupert...
but if your buying....
|
Posted By: Jon711
Date Posted: 20 Sep 11 at 5:02pm
Roger, from one boat breaker to another, I have restrained from responding, differently.... But great response....
Jon
------------- Blaze 711
|
Posted By: timeintheboat
Date Posted: 20 Sep 11 at 5:29pm
The word "yacht" in the club's name normally sets the alarm bells ringing.......
There are so many clubs where I have been and had a great time on and off the water.
------------- Like some other things - sailing is more enjoyable when you do it with someone else
|
Posted By: Andymac
Date Posted: 20 Sep 11 at 6:36pm
Originally posted by timeintheboat
The word "yacht" in the club's name normally sets the alarm bells ringing.......
|
Or "Royal". The combination of the two, well...
|
Posted By: Quagers
Date Posted: 20 Sep 11 at 7:12pm
Thats not true, Royal Burnham Yacht club has been one of the friendliest ive ever visited (or maybe just the one I've got the most drunk at) I find the 'royal' clubs arnt actually that bad, its the clubs who wish they were 'royal' and try to emulate what they think it means to be one of these clubs that are worst.
|
Posted By: Pierre
Date Posted: 20 Sep 11 at 7:54pm
Originally posted by rogerd
Originally posted by Rupert
Bring the Osprey, Pierre, and I'll get Roger D up with his Hornet, and we can make a party of it... |
Which bit of the Hornet do you want me to bring Rupert...
but if your buying.... |
Why in god's name don't you stop using that melted down horse glue Roger?... Go mad and get a tube of UHU.
I do actually have room for a beer fridge in the Osprey Rupert.
|
Posted By: laser4000
Date Posted: 20 Sep 11 at 10:17pm
Originally posted by G.R.F.
So, top of my league has always been Bewl, but now racing up there to a close second is Broadstairs, as condescending an experience as ever one might expect from club officers viewing the proceedings from on high at the Man of Kent recently.
|
Sorry grumpf but you're completely wrong on that one - Broadstairs is one of the best clubs i've ever done an open at. friendly, welcoming, great cheap curry and some fantastic drinking games in some great visitors vs. locals matches...
Deffo in my all time top 5 list of clubs to go to which is of course headed by West Kirby..
|
Posted By: Presuming Ed
Date Posted: 20 Sep 11 at 10:37pm
I doubt any of you know what a properly snooty club really is....
|
Posted By: Rupert
Date Posted: 21 Sep 11 at 8:47am
Never even occurred to me to try and darken their doors...
Mind you, I've know members, and they have been very nice chaps indeed!
------------- Firefly 2324, Puffin 229, Minisail 3446 Mirror 70686
|
Posted By: getafix
Date Posted: 21 Sep 11 at 9:20am
South Carn YC in Abersoch - went there first off years ago with a friend who was a member, very good time from what I could remember of it, second time I went as a non-member and guest it was elitist tosh I'm afraid but not on same scale of RSYC in Hamble or RYS in Cowes.. not all YC's are awful though, Lymington is great! +1 for HISC BTW too.
Amazes me how much kids get frowned on in some sailing, tennis & golf clubs... where do people think their membership is coming from in future? It's like Cycling clubs who won't even talk to you until you've proven yourself able to ride at the front on a Sunday for xxx miles.... haven't they heard of encouraging beginners?
|
Posted By: Andymac
Date Posted: 21 Sep 11 at 2:14pm
Originally posted by Quagers
Thats not true, Royal Burnham Yacht club has been one of the friendliest ive ever visited (or maybe just the one I've got the most drunk at) I find the 'royal' clubs arnt actually that bad, its the clubs who wish they were 'royal' and try to emulate what they think it means to be one of these clubs that are worst. |
That's a fair comment.
The generalisation of clubs with "Yacht" or "Royal" (or both) in their title is perhaps a little unfair, but goes some way to explaining some of the victorian elitist attitudes that you still sometimes meet.
Any clubs accepting 'sport for all' or community based grants SHOULD NOT be allowed to perpetuate ancient rules which differentiate.
More to the point, I thought entering a open / regatta gained you temporary membership of the host club and (within reason) use of the clubs facilities.
Unfortunately Rogue in an earlier post contradicts your view on Burnham...Or alternately, as Rupurt points out, it's sometimes down to meeting the wrong person on the wrong day.
|
Posted By: Mister Nick
Date Posted: 21 Sep 11 at 5:55pm
Originally posted by Andymac
Originally posted by timeintheboat
The word "yacht" in the club's name normally sets the alarm bells ringing.......
|
Or "Royal". The combination of the two, well... |
That's really not fair. The Royal Burnham Yacht club is very friendly - when we broke our mast doing a coastal race to Burnham, within 5 minutes of getting into the yacht club we had 4 offers for beds for the night, a few offers for lifts home in the morning and someone even asked if we wanted any help getting the boat home. If that's not friendly, I don't know what is.
|
Posted By: giraffe
Date Posted: 21 Sep 11 at 10:55pm
Originally posted by Jack Sparrow
Salcombe Y.C... If you happen to be sailing in Salcombe week with a wife a baby in tow, and you think it might be nice to have drink after the racing the the club. Don't bother, unless you want to spend a little more time away from your family. As I was aggressively told, with a wagging finger pointing to a sign. Absolutely NO children in the yacht club. It's out side for you. What a great club, I always make a bee line for there bar to spend my cash now, every time I'm down that way. |
What a load of balderdash. No children allowed in the bar. It is the terms of the licence. I have noted you talking bull on here on a number of occasions and this takes the biscuit. Club has a cadet room for the kids which allows the olds to have a beer or the half deck area where you can sit with them. Been the same for the seven years when it has been of particular interest to me.
|
Posted By: Andymac
Date Posted: 21 Sep 11 at 10:56pm
I conceded in my last post that I was perhaps being a little unfair in making that generalisation. For the record, I have absolutely nothing against the Royal Burnham (having never visited there). I was just pointing out that you will always find someone who has been left with a sour image of ANY club due to meeting the wrong person on the wrong day. I do however know of two seperate aquantainces who have membership at the same "Royal, Yacht" club (not Burnham), who have both testified that there is a 'snooty' attitude within.
|
|