Print Page | Close Window

lasers

Printed From: Yachts and Yachting Online
Category: General
Forum Name: Choosing a boat
Forum Discription: Ask any questions about the sport!
URL: http://www.yachtsandyachting.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=1317
Printed Date: 11 May 25 at 2:56pm
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 9.665y - http://www.webwizforums.com


Topic: lasers
Posted By: Prince Buster
Subject: lasers
Date Posted: 22 Dec 05 at 8:29pm
Hi,
does anyone know the optimum weight bands for sailing the laser 4.7, radial and standard rigs.  i keep getting different opinions from everyone and i'm not really sure what to make of it all.  I'm 50kg and was sailing a 4.7 but now it seems like all the racing is in radials.  I find it really difficult when it gets windy but i'm not sure whether I should just put up with it to get some good racing or should go back into the 4.7.  How heavy should one be to sail a radial competitively?
Prince Buster


-------------
international moth - "what what?"



Replies:
Posted By: Strawberry
Date Posted: 22 Dec 05 at 8:41pm

Put the laser down, and walk away........slowly!



-------------
Cherub 2649 "Dangerous Strawberry


Posted By: kasey3000
Date Posted: 22 Dec 05 at 8:52pm

I have a friend who sails a 4.7....not completely sure how heavy he is...would say about 55kg. and he sails a 4.7....not really big enough for a radial above a f3.

I am 60kg and would be competitive up to about a f5 I've been told

 



-------------
49er 908


Posted By: Isis
Date Posted: 22 Dec 05 at 9:52pm
I started in a radial at about the weight and suffered a bit when it got blowwy but would not have swapped it for a 4.7 for any money.

Oh, and buy a decent lightweights boau like a moth or a europe


-------------


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 22 Dec 05 at 9:58pm
Yeah a mothe sounds cool.  i'll never be a heavyweight but i'm a bit of a speed freak so want something fast and i don't care too much if i don't have too much control when it blows!

-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: Strawberry
Date Posted: 22 Dec 05 at 10:05pm

If you want something fast then why does a Laser even enter your mind.

A general rule is that if the PY is 3 figures then it's fast.
(I know this is controversial but it's what I think. I can't be bothered to argue the point so if anyone disagrees or thinks differently, good for them, cos I dont care!!!)



-------------
Cherub 2649 "Dangerous Strawberry


Posted By: Isis
Date Posted: 22 Dec 05 at 10:07pm
Originally posted by Prince Buster

Yeah a mothe sounds cool.  i'll never be a heavyweight but i'm a bit of a speed freak so want something fast and i don't care too much if i don't have too much control when it blows!


and yet you've just moved into a radial...


-------------


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 22 Dec 05 at 10:07pm
cos i'm only 15 and havn't got enuf money 2 buy a really fast boat mr.strawberry. 

-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: Isis
Date Posted: 22 Dec 05 at 10:37pm
but have you seriously looked? if you can afford a half decent laser you can afford a moth... 600s are probibly only just above your weight range and are going quite cheeply at the moment if you want to grow into something

-------------


Posted By: Strawberry
Date Posted: 22 Dec 05 at 10:53pm

This is an awesome boat and your not gonna dind a decent laser for less!

http://www.moth.nl/SecondHand/ItemDetail.jsp?stsh=37&lng=1&shaNr=591 - http://www.moth.nl/SecondHand/ItemDetail.jsp?stsh=37&lng =1&shaNr=591



-------------
Cherub 2649 "Dangerous Strawberry


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 23 Dec 05 at 9:49am
Thank you Isis and Strawberry.  I never knew i could get some good boats for that kind of money!  I'm seriously thinking of selling my laser now and getting something else.  600s are also cool.  they're quite an old boat now but they still look great. 
thanks
Prince Buster


-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: Jamie600
Date Posted: 23 Dec 05 at 4:40pm
If it's speed you want then a Laser shouldn't even be on your list. Let me plant a subliminal thought in your head..

RS600 RS600 RS600 RS600 RS600 RS600 RS600 RS600 RS600
RS600 RS600 RS600 RS600 RS600 RS600 RS600 RS600 RS600

go on, you know you want one

not that I'm at all biased....


Posted By: BBSCFaithfull
Date Posted: 29 Dec 05 at 5:14pm
I have to agree with Jamie 600. I have a laser and it is so boring thats why i sail a 4k .tee hee . Honestly Mr Buster if you get to sail a 600 you will love it!! I have sailed one about twice and instantly became hooked on the boat. It gave me speeds in a force 2 upwind and down i wouldnt get until a force 3-4 in a laser.!! Honestly for a goodfun, cheap, practically indestructible boat the 600 is the way to go!!.

-------------
Greatfully Sponsored By
www.allgoodfun.com
Int 14 GBR 1503!!


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 30 Dec 05 at 6:36pm
Are the 600s a dying class cos they're going really cheaply and there are some modern alternatives.  Is there much racing for them?
P.S. i prefer to be addressed by my formal title (Prince) rather than Mr.Buster.
Prince Buster


-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: carshalton fc
Date Posted: 30 Dec 05 at 6:43pm
na mr buster they arnt a dieing class.  there is quite alot of racing for them.  but if u go for something like a mps or a 700 that is going to cost u nearly £5000 and if u went for a laser there is lots of racing but they are boring.  happy sailing

-------------
International 14 1503


Posted By: TheSeaFalcon
Date Posted: 03 Jan 06 at 12:20pm
Hey sorry to kinda change the subject, but someone mentioned PYs - (I think it was Strawberry!!) what on earth are they??!

-------------
x--x--x<x>x--x--x
Topper 41825
Cherub 2539 (going, going and not quite but nearly gone)!


Posted By: Pierre
Date Posted: 03 Jan 06 at 12:24pm
Have you never heard the expression "Who ate all the pys?"


Posted By: Harry44981!
Date Posted: 03 Jan 06 at 1:56pm

PY= Psrtsmouth Yardstick.

This is the standard method in the Uk (most widely accepted) for giving boats a handicap. Most club racing is run by it, using corrected times/ or staggered starts (pursuit race).



-------------


Posted By: HannahJ
Date Posted: 03 Jan 06 at 8:14pm
oh dear pierre, i nkow a girl who used to sing that aaaalll the time...

-------------
MIRROR 64799 "Dolphin"
The pessimist complains about the wind; the optimist hopes it will change; the realist adjusts the sail


Posted By: stuarthop
Date Posted: 03 Jan 06 at 10:21pm

radial optimum weight is around 68kg with the 4.7 being up to about 60 and the full rig anything over about 72kg does that help???



-------------



Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 04 Jan 06 at 9:45am
yep.  thanks for the straight answer stuart!

-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: Strawberry
Date Posted: 04 Jan 06 at 12:32pm
Dude, whatever you do. DON'T BUY A CHERUB!!!

-------------
Cherub 2649 "Dangerous Strawberry


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 04 Jan 06 at 2:20pm
What have you got against Cherubs??  I'm not gonna get one but I was under the impression that you were a bit of a Cherub fan

-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: Strawberry
Date Posted: 04 Jan 06 at 2:40pm
Exactly

-------------
Cherub 2649 "Dangerous Strawberry


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 04 Jan 06 at 3:34pm
Yeah you're right i far prefer one design boats.  Cherubs just don't really interest me!

-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: Isis
Date Posted: 04 Jan 06 at 3:35pm
Originally posted by Strawberry

Exactly





-------------


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 04 Jan 06 at 3:38pm
Originally posted by Isis

Originally posted by Strawberry

Exactly





 

-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: Isis
Date Posted: 04 Jan 06 at 3:40pm
Oh my... Ive just noticed ive joined the exclusive 'Really should get out more' club

Im not sure whether I should be proud or worried...


-------------


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 04 Jan 06 at 3:48pm
Yep 500posts and ur in.  I'm still a newbie though!  Gotta get off that.   As for being proud or worried...      i'd  view it as an honour but u really should think about getting another hobby.

-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 04 Jan 06 at 3:49pm
Originally posted by Strawberry

Dude, whatever you do. DON'T BUY A CHERUB!!!

Please don't call me "Dude"
 

-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: carshalton fc
Date Posted: 04 Jan 06 at 7:06pm
well done isis u should be proud,  i am sure at least one of your posts has been to some use to someone.
 
strawberry dont u own a cherub???
 
dude  get a 4000.


-------------
International 14 1503


Posted By: Black no sugar
Date Posted: 04 Jan 06 at 7:42pm
Originally posted by carshalton fc

well done isis u should be proud,  i am sure at least one of your posts has been to some use to someone.
 
strawberry dont u own a cherub???
 
dude  get a 4000.

Go Isis!! 500 posts is a good start, I say

 

As for the "don't buy a Cherub" advice to HRH, maybe the class regulations don't accept anyone with such an obvious lack of coordination, as seen in the Prince Buster photo below:

 



-------------
http://www.lancingsc.org.uk/index.html - Lancing SC


Posted By: Isis
Date Posted: 04 Jan 06 at 7:50pm
Does anyone else think that looks like cat from red dwarf?

-------------


Posted By: Isis
Date Posted: 04 Jan 06 at 7:53pm
Thanks by the way BnS.... Il catch you someday!!

[evildeformedmeglomaniaclaugh]MUHAHAHAHAHAHAHA[/evildeformedmeglomaniaclaugh]

-------------


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 04 Jan 06 at 8:23pm
[/QUOTE]

Go Isis!! 500 posts is a good start, I say

 

As for the "don't buy a Cherub" advice to HRH, maybe the class regulations don't accept anyone with such an obvious lack of coordination, as seen in the Prince Buster photo below:

[/QUOTE]He's a legend



-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: Calum_Reid
Date Posted: 04 Jan 06 at 8:38pm
ur not

-------------


Posted By: Black no sugar
Date Posted: 04 Jan 06 at 8:44pm

Ohh you're such a tease!

Go on, let it out... you'll feel better afterwards.



-------------
http://www.lancingsc.org.uk/index.html - Lancing SC


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 04 Jan 06 at 9:21pm
Originally posted by Calum_Reid

ur not

Personal abuse..... not called for.
 

-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: Strawberry
Date Posted: 04 Jan 06 at 9:56pm

Originally posted by Prince Buster

Originally posted by Calum_Reid

ur not

Personal abuse..... not called for.
 

I'm not so sure bout that...

Maybe this thread should be moved to the "Banter" section?!



-------------
Cherub 2649 "Dangerous Strawberry


Posted By: Phat Bouy
Date Posted: 04 Jan 06 at 11:13pm
Originally posted by Prince Buster

[/QUOTE]

Go Isis!! 500 posts is a good start, I say

 

As for the "don't buy a Cherub" advice to HRH, maybe the class regulations don't accept anyone with such an obvious lack of coordination, as seen in the Prince Buster photo below:

[/QUOTE]He's a legend

[/QUOTE]

A legend? Surely you don't mean a foot??


-------------
Je suis Marxiste - tendance Groucho


Posted By: Black no sugar
Date Posted: 05 Jan 06 at 8:57am

Enough boys, enough! 
To be honest Callum, I thought that "outburst" Dead of yours would be at home in a primary school playground !  Did you know who Prince Buster (the real one) was before HRH came on the forum? 

Then there's HRH himself... Chill out, dude. Life is too short to be taken seriously .

Now, I hope you will all play nice from now on - Thank you xxxHeart

 

To come back to the topic,

Originally posted by Prince Buster

Hi,
does anyone know the optimum weight bands for sailing the laser 4.7, radial and standard rigs. I keep getting different opinions from everyone and I'm not really sure what to make of it all.  I'm 50kg and was sailing a 4.7 but now it seems like all the racing is in Radials.  I find it really difficult when it gets windy but I'm not sure whether I should just put up with it to get some good racing or should go back into the 4.7.  How heavy should one be to sail a Radial competitively?
Prince Buster

have you found the answer? Everyone voicing an opinion here tells you to stay clear of Lasers, but hey, if you've got a Laser, go for it!

http://www.blithfield.org.uk/fleets/laser.htm - http://www.blithfield.org.uk/fleets/laser.htm

There's a table of crew weights for the 3 different rigs (in stone, sorry).

Just a question: from your profile, I see you're very young. At 15, you probably haven't reached your adult weight. Are you likely to switch to another boat next year or can you consider growing into a Radial? Besides, all optimum crew weights are only a guide. If you're a good sailor, you can tune a Laser, can't you?



-------------
http://www.lancingsc.org.uk/index.html - Lancing SC


Posted By: Jamie600
Date Posted: 05 Jan 06 at 10:27am
You can't tune a Laser - on flat water you may be able to get away with being underweight if you are very fit, but the only tuning is pulling loads of downhaul and kicker on which distorts the sail shape and affects pointing.


-------------
RS600 1001


Posted By: Isis
Date Posted: 05 Jan 06 at 2:48pm

Originally posted by Jamie600

You can't tune a Laser - on flat water you may be able to get away with being underweight if you are very fit, but the only tuning is pulling loads of downhaul and kicker on which distorts the sail shape and affects pointing.

Radials at least are notorious for people pulling cunningham eyes out of even brand new sails trying to get more tension on, dont ya just love smods?



-------------


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 05 Jan 06 at 5:16pm
I think the laser's a good boat and it's certainly stood the test of time but i think i will move into something else this season - something with more speed for the effort input!  Also what is meant by smods?  I've seen it said a lot on this forum.

-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: Calum_Reid
Date Posted: 05 Jan 06 at 5:47pm
SMOD = Single Manufacturer One Design, u need to wash ur mouth out everytime u mention 1!

-------------


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 05 Jan 06 at 6:11pm

That explains a lot!
Apart from moths and RS600s which i've been told to get loads of times can anyone recommend a good lightweight's boat (i'm just over 50kg) that is relatively fast and has good racing?  I really want something other than a laser but a moth seems like it would be more of a lifetime's hobby and i think i'd be too light for a 600.
Prince Buster


-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: Isis
Date Posted: 05 Jan 06 at 6:45pm
Originally posted by Prince Buster


a moth seems like it would be more of a lifetime's hobby


You say that as if if were a bad thing?


-------------


Posted By: Jamie600
Date Posted: 05 Jan 06 at 7:01pm
Tricky one.

Generally fast boats have large sail areas which means you need some lard to keep them flat.

The only other way of making a boat go fast is to make it really light, so that's a Moth.   

Maybe look at a Vareo, they are a little quicker than a Laser upwind and you've got the kite to play with downwind.
Not sure what the weight range is on a Vareo, I've only seen adult men racing it so maybe that answers the question.


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 05 Jan 06 at 7:06pm
Yeah i think you have to be pretty big for the vareo.  I tried one in the summer and i found it quite tough going in pretty light winds.  it's got quite a powerful main.  I don't know if i've just got a warped view on moths but it just seems to me as if it's a lifelong commitment of tinkering and working on the boat to try to improve it and that's not really the kind of thing i'm into.

-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: Jamie600
Date Posted: 05 Jan 06 at 7:11pm
How tall are you out of interest?

-------------
RS600 1001


Posted By: Ian29937
Date Posted: 05 Jan 06 at 7:43pm

At your weight you are a bit limited.  Two classes which do come to mind are the Splash and Byte - links available from the classes section...... 

The Byte in particular looks good with the new rig..

Ian



Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 05 Jan 06 at 8:00pm
Originally posted by Jamie600

How tall are you out of interest?

I'm 5ft5 (165cm). 

I was kind of hoping for something a bit faster/more Xtreme than a Byte.
 

-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: Strawberry
Date Posted: 05 Jan 06 at 8:08pm

Going fast comes from having big powerfull sails, which means u have lots of healing moment, which therefore has to be counteracted by righting moment. So if you wanna go fast you either gotta learn to sail when overpowered (get an RS600), face it that u sail a slow boat (get a Byte), or learn to sail a development class where you can personalise the rig (get a moth).

Or of course you could get some friends (preferably heavy ones) and sail a double hander.

This is the word according to Strawberry



-------------
Cherub 2649 "Dangerous Strawberry


Posted By: les5269
Date Posted: 05 Jan 06 at 8:09pm

I know it doesn't seem to be that popular now (I may be wrong !)but what about the rs300? 50kgs sounds a bit light for the 600.Tho the moth may be ok

By the way i say this with never having sailed either the 600 or the moth!And I weigh a bitmore than 50kgs!



-------------
49er 531 & 5000 5025 and a mirror(now gone to mirror heaven)!

http://www.grafham.org/" rel="nofollow - Grafham water Sailing Club The greatest inland sailing in the country


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 05 Jan 06 at 8:32pm
I think i'm most interested in the 600 having been overpowered in every boat i've ever sailed when the wind gets up and i'll have probably put on another stone or two in a year anyway.  But is it a BIG new thing sailing a single handed trapeze boat or is it just something you get used to.  Also what kind of wind strength would i be able to sail in up to the point when i'm swimming more than i'm sailing?

-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: Harry44981!
Date Posted: 05 Jan 06 at 8:37pm

at 50kg and 165cm you're way too small for most things. For example you're over 10kg too light for the optimum topper weight, which says something considering it's such a small slow boat!

Get a fast 2 man boat with a single trapeze, and get a gorilla to hang off it eg: fireball.



-------------


Posted By: Contender 541
Date Posted: 05 Jan 06 at 10:11pm

Normally I would say that if you wanted something faster and requiring a bit of a learning curve then go for the Contender as I did (I only started getting excited about being in a full rig laser when everyone else was saying no way!!)

At 50kg though I would wait a couple of years and a couple of stone and a couple of inches

"But is it a BIG new thing sailing a single handed trapeze boat or is it just something you get used to" - I bought a Contender having never been on a trapeze let alone been on a single hande trapeze - ask me again in about 6 months ofter I have climbed this everest of a learning curve



-------------
When you find a big kettle of crazy it's probably best not to stir it - Pointy Haired Boss

Crew on 505 8780



Posted By: 5420
Date Posted: 05 Jan 06 at 10:48pm

to be honist i think you are going the rong way about it

i think 50 kilos is on the light side for a 4.7 but i think you should stay with that and get in the teams and things as you have to be about 70 kilos for a radel and i was 75 kilos when i was in the full rig and i was 5 kilos to light you need to be 80kilos for it to be fast

i think you sloukd get a cheep moth that you can sail when you are not racing for fun then see wot you want to do in a year or 2

 

geting a bout you are too small for sounds good at the time but all you do is put your self off stay with the 4.7 and go to all the opens

 

i know this is not wot i done but it is the right thing to do i think from my experuns

 

 

 



-------------


Posted By: Jamie600
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 10:34am
Contender 541 is right, you need to wait a while. Don't forget you are still growing, in fact you are around the age when most people grow fastest, and you do not stop growing til around 20 years old.

Having two boats may be the best option, a 'normal' boat for racing and something a bit more special for fun, or maybe racing in suitable conditions. For the price of a nearly new Laser you could get a reasonable second hand one and have a thousand or so left for an old 600 or Moth.

My first boat was an OK, which normally requires 14-15 stone but I only weighed 9! Let me tell you it is no fun at all being completely blown away.

You need to carry on in something that suits your weight.
Topper, Byte, 4.7, Splash have all been mentioned, but it may be worth also looking at a Europe, which is quicker than most of the others mentioned and a bit more lively, so would at least give an impression of speed.

If you did go for a 600 you would need to reef it in about 12-14 knots of breeze and anything above about 17-18 knots I reckon you would be swimming constantly and very p**sed off with the whole thing.
Bear in mind also that boats like that are designed with adult-sized sailors in mind, so you need to consider things like, can you handle the mainsheet, can you right it from a capsize unassisted, even pulling the thing up the slip at the end of sailing.


Posted By: 5420
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 11:10am

i think jame600 is talking sense there now

 

but i also think that you should stik with a laser 4.7 or topper for your normal boat as that way you can get the benafit of all the free traniong you can get in them and that way you can do things in the squde

anther idear could be to keep the laser and get nofing sels and save your money and look for a big crew that is your age and get a 29er when you find one then try and get in to the 29er team

but i would not go out and get the boat and look for the crew after that is the mastak i made

just wonduring where do you sail



-------------


Posted By: Jamie600
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 12:37pm
[QUOTE=5420]

i think jame600 is talking sense there now


 



There's a first time for everything I guess   


Posted By: 5420
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 1:29pm

lol

i think with some of your ealyer postes on the subject i disagreed a bit

but its only persanl prefrance



-------------


Posted By: Contender443
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 4:13pm

There is a problem here - I get the feeling that there is the need for a trapezing singlehander for leightweigts in the 50 to 60kg range.

Why do we force our leightweights to stay in Lasers 4.7s, Toppers and Oppies when they could be sailing something more exciting.

So come on RS, noboday wants your RS500 (see other thread). Develop a leightweight single handed trapeze boat to meet this gap in the market.



-------------
Bonnie Lass Contender 1764


Posted By: Isis
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 4:45pm
When I was in that same situation I talked to a number of people in the industry and none were interested, but I agree, there is a need for a kind of singlehanded mini-skiff

-------------


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 5:07pm
Originally posted by Contender443

There is a problem here - I get the feeling that there is the need for a trapezing singlehander for leightweigts in the 50 to 60kg range.

Why do we force our leightweights to stay in Lasers 4.7s, Toppers and Oppies when they could be sailing something more exciting.

So come on RS, noboday wants your RS500 (see other thread). Develop a leightweight single handed trapeze boat to meet this gap in the market.


WOW got it in 1!!!!!
You couldn't be more right!!!
That really is what is needed cos lots of my friends are in the same position as me but most are too light to sail any fast boats on the market.  Forget the RS500 it's gonna be a waste of time against the laser 4k. 
5420: just wondering where do you sail
Thorpe Bay on the Thames Estuary


 

-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: 5420
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 5:11pm

it is grate for us to sit hear saying this becuse there a coulpe of people hear that would need thing but rs and laser are company and they need to make money so they make things that a lot of people could buy and that is people around the 75-90 kilo range most people are i have resonty been to rs and laser and if you look around and think about it they are not boat bilders any more ok they bild boats but they are more like argos or tesco there just providing what most people want that is what i think is the good thing about ovington where they have not got big enof yet to be like that so if you want that kind of boat know it would have to be a class like phatom where any one can make them so people can make theem as one offs and make money on them but not sell that boat as to make lots of money thats why laser stoped making the EPS and the vortex ok they where ok and selling but there where never going to sell in the same numbers as the sb3 and they could not make every boat they desine so the thy had to make a chose what one to make and that was not ones where the best boat it was the one that was going to make them the most money



-------------


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 5:17pm
Originally posted by 5420

it is grate for us to sit hear saying this becuse there a coulpe of people hear that would need thing but rs and laser are company and they need to make money so they make things that a lot of people could buy and that is people around the 75-90 kilo range most people are i have resonty been to rs and laser and if you look around and think about it they are not boat bilders any more ok they bild boats but they are more like argos or tesco there just providing what most people want that is what i think is the good thing about ovington where they have not got big enof yet to be like that so if you want that kind of boat know it would have to be a class like phatom where any one can make them so people can make theem as one offs and make money on them but not sell that boat as to make lots of money thats why laser stoped making the EPS and the vortex ok they where ok and selling but there where never going to sell in the same numbers as the sb3 and they could not make every boat they desine so the thy had to make a chose what one to make and that was not ones where the best boat it was the one that was going to make them the most money


Not wanting to be confrontational here 5420 but can you please use some punctuation.  It makes reading a fairly long response like that much easier.
 

-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: 5420
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 5:20pm

sorry i was never any good at that i still ant

 

but you still get what im saying right



-------------


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 6:03pm
Yep and I think you're probably right.  The companies make boats to appeal to a wide range of sailors and that's mostly adults.  But I still think the idea of a lightweight singlehanded trapezing dinghy needs to be seriously considered as a new design.

-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 6:26pm
YESSS!
I've finally got off that Newbie status!  I'm goin up in da world


-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: Black no sugar
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 6:51pm
Originally posted by Prince Buster

Originally posted by Contender443

There is a problem here - I get the feeling that there is the need for a trapezing singlehander for leightweigts in the 50 to 60kg range.

Why do we force our leightweights to stay in Lasers 4.7s, Toppers and Oppies when they could be sailing something more exciting.

So come on RS, noboday wants your RS500 (see other thread). Develop a leightweight single handed trapeze boat to meet this gap in the market.


WOW got it in 1!!!!!
You couldn't be more right!!!
That really is what is needed cos lots of my friends are in the same position as me but most are too light to sail any fast boats on the market.  Forget the RS500 it's gonna be a waste of time against the laser 4k. 
5420: just wondering where do you sail
Thorpe Bay on the Thames Estuary


 

Get a FARR 3.7 !  (I'd love to have one too)

Anyone interested in importing them from NZ???



-------------
http://www.lancingsc.org.uk/index.html - Lancing SC


Posted By: Strawberry
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 7:03pm
BNS, Farr sell the plans. Build one! Or if you cant't be arsed, pay a boat builder to build one for you!

-------------
Cherub 2649 "Dangerous Strawberry


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 7:09pm
Kind of a cross between a contender and RS 600 but a skiff version.  Look quite good.   Let's get a ship load of them tomorrow!



-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: Isis
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 7:27pm
Originally posted by Prince Buster

Kind of a cross between a contender and RS 600 but a skiff version.  Look quite good.   Let's get a ship load of them tomorrow!



Sorry, but why is it half RS600? and without wanting to spark the whole debate up again id struggle to call it a skiff...


Loosing the n00b label obviously didnt have the effect you'd expect...


-------------


Posted By: Jamie600
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 7:54pm
Cute, it's a baby contender!


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 8:40pm

[/QUOTE]

 why is it half RS600?  id struggle to call it a skiff...


Loosing the n00b label obviously didnt have the effect you'd expect...
[/QUOTE]

Dunno it's a singlehanded trapeze dinghy isn't it.  But probably more of a contender. You tell me why you'd "struggle" to call it a skiff.  It says it's a skiff on the website so i'm kind of inclined to believe that.  And actually I feel more fulfilled as a person now i've lost the so-called "n00b label" so yes it has had the expected effect.
 

-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: Isis
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 9:03pm
It says skiff on the website? well f*ck me! it must be a skiff then!

Your username describes you as a prince, but will I be hailing you as the future king? I think not...


-------------


Posted By: allanorton
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 9:23pm
What's the difference between a skiff & a dinghy, I thought the word "skiff" was an old word for "dinghy", as in the 18' skiffs, rowing skiffs etc..?!


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 9:37pm
Originally posted by Isis

It says skiff on the website? well f*ck me! it must be a skiff then!

Your username describes you as a prince, but will I be hailing you as the future king? I think not...


My username does not describe me.  it is the name of a Jamaican Reggae/Ska singer.  What does Isis mean?  Aside from the sarcasm can you tell me why you would struggle to call the Farr 3.7 a skiff and how you would define a skiff.
 

-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: Strawberry
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 10:06pm
Buster Boy, your makin yourself sound like a propper twat. Probably a good idea to drop it. If you care that much about what a skiff actually is I suggest you can and find yourself a description.

-------------
Cherub 2649 "Dangerous Strawberry


Posted By: Strawberry
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 10:16pm

I personally like this definition:

I would say ot be classed as a skiff you must meet most if not all of the following points.

1.History, can your class point to a history of development under its own name as a class not as a couple of prototypes?

2. Are you accepted by the establishment?

3. Do you embrace the "high performance" eithos?

4. Do you have to build it yourself, have it customade?

5. Very few rules? I know that in rescent times both the 16 and 18 have lost this, pity realy

6. NO SAIL NUMBERS. sorry to the 14 blokes

7. Have or did have a feeder system, for new blood into the class, that WASN'T created by the company building the boat?



-------------
Cherub 2649 "Dangerous Strawberry


Posted By: allanorton
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 10:31pm
Originally posted by Strawberry

I personally like this definition:

I would say ot be classed as a skiff you must meet most if not all of the following points.

1.History, can your class point to a history of development under its own name as a class not as a couple of prototypes?

2. Are you accepted by the establishment?

3. Do you embrace the "high performance" eithos?

4. Do you have to build it yourself, have it customade?

5. Very few rules? I know that in rescent times both the 16 and 18 have lost this, pity realy

6. NO SAIL NUMBERS. sorry to the 14 blokes

7. Have or did have a feeder system, for new blood into the class, that WASN'T created by the company building the boat?

Who came out with this then?



Posted By: Calum_Reid
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 10:42pm
Scottish Skiff Racing came up with this:
Monohull Asymmetrics with a PY of 930 or less AND Monohull single-sailed boats with a PY of 990 or less.
They had a poll to decide!

-------------


Posted By: Strawberry
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 10:45pm
Originally posted by allanorton

Who came out with this then?

An guy on the forum called "Skiffe"



-------------
Cherub 2649 "Dangerous Strawberry


Posted By: Prince Buster
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 10:46pm
Originally posted by Strawberry

Buster Boy, your makin yourself sound like a propper twat. Probably a good idea to drop it. If you care that much about what a skiff actually is I suggest you can and find yourself a description.


Strawberry i seem to remember you're reaction when you received a similar response on a different thread:

Quote:
RickPerkins:
Strawberry old boy you are making yourself look a bit daft with these sweeping statements. Quote

Quote
:Strawberry:
I am expressing an opinion, the point of an open forum.  To have a counter opinion is one thing, but to personally attack someone's opinion..........more fool you. Quote

How hypocritical of you Strawberry!

I wish to talk about boats.
That is why I joined the Yachts and Yachting Forum.
I didn't join to have petty arguaments with other members.


 

-------------
international moth - "what what?"


Posted By: Strawberry
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 10:53pm

Expressin my opinion,

eg. I think your a fool who has less knowledge of sailing, or sailing boats, than my forestay!



-------------
Cherub 2649 "Dangerous Strawberry


Posted By: Wave Rider
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 11:05pm

Not taking sides but Prince Buster has joined the forum to seek advice on certain topics and ask questions as have most of us. He has asked completely fair questions and hasn't made any sweeping statements what so ever. Whats wrong with asking things, im pretty damn sure you didn't learn your knowledge from osmosis, you must of had to ask someone.

Statements like:

eg. I think your a fool who has less knowledge of sailing, or sailing boats, than my forestay!

Make you look a completely unhelpful tw** and destroys the whole point of having a forum, if all the members made comments like that all the time (thanks christ they don't) and if you asked a question somebody ripped the piss into you, im pretty damn sure nobody would post...When you want something answered and get something wrong i doubt everyone will come out with comments like yours....im suprised Mark Jardine hasn't already said something!



-------------
           -[Franko]-
Chew Valley Lake Sailing Club
           RS600 933


Posted By: CurlyBen
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 11:25pm
I agree, personal attacks are never helpful. I've learnt a lot from this forum and it'd be nice if people could continue to do so without being laid into because they don't know everything there is to know about sailing.

-------------
RS800 GBR848
Weston SC


Posted By: Isis
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 11:28pm
Originally posted by Strawberry

Originally posted by allanorton

Who came out with this then?

An guy on the forum called "Skiffe"



IIRC Skiffe sails 12s down under so if anyone on this forum knows what a skiff is its probibly him


My username does not describe me.  it is the name of a Jamaican Reggae/Ska singer.  What does Isis mean?  Aside from the sarcasm can you tell me why you would struggle to call the Farr 3.7 a skiff and how you would define a skiff.


The only 'skiffs' are the original 6s, 8s, 10s, 12s 14s, 16s, 18s etc and things like the Rclass. A number of other classes are 'grandfathered in' IN MY OPINION such as the 49er, MPS...
Im not going to go any further into the debate as weve had this several times before and classes like the moth/rs800/5k/4k will always be a shady area.
I dont think a 'skiff' can ever be fully defined and there will always be argument as to where the line lays but look at any of the classes ive mentioned, and even those in the 'grey' area and you will see a patern emerging. Nothing in this patern fits with a mini-contender, as nice a boat as it might be, hence me not calling it a skiff.

Isis, seems as you asked, is another (largely unused) name for the upper Thames where I do most of my marathon kayaking training and was the first word to come into my head when I signed up.


-------------


Posted By: Black no sugar
Date Posted: 06 Jan 06 at 11:39pm
Originally posted by Strawberry

Expressin my opinion,

eg. I think your a fool who has less knowledge of sailing, or sailing boats, than my forestay!

That's never stopped ME from trying to talk about boats! (mind you, I've never met your forestay... )

And honestly, I do agree with Wave Rider. Prince Buster came on this forum to talk about boats and ask for advice. His username is probably a little more unusual than the obvious boat name/sail number combination; it's got the great advantage that it won't be outdated when he sells his boat (eh, Contender443!?! ).
I'd never heard of Prince Buster (the singer) before our man came on the forum and I've researched and learnt something! It can't be a bad thing Clap

Finally, I think everyone in their life has asked candid questions, or made sweeping judgements, Strawberry, Isis, plenty more and me included! We're all here to share an interest on the same sport, not bicker and call one another names like Asbos-aspiring kids in a primary school playground.

Now, I've said it before: PLAY NICE! (or else AngryAngry...)

xxx BnS

 



-------------
http://www.lancingsc.org.uk/index.html - Lancing SC


Posted By: maxim
Date Posted: 07 Jan 06 at 12:11am
Originally posted by Black no sugar

Now, I've said it before: PLAY NICE! (or else AngryAngry...)

xxx BnS

 

Why do teachers always have to go and ruin a good fight??!!



Posted By: 49erGBR735HSC
Date Posted: 07 Jan 06 at 2:55am

Why does the boat have to be a single-hander? There doesn't seem to be a single-handed trapeze boat that meets your requirements appart from the Farr which you'd have to get imported. Get a mate on board and go for a double-hander because there are a lot of suitable double-handed trapeze boats that would give you the excitement you are looking for. For £2000 and under you could get a decent Laser 2, 3000, Buzz or Fireball. As 5420 mentioned you could go for a 29er with a little bit more money or alternatively move into a 420. The Cherub may be another option and as you get bigger, with that boat you can modify an older boat to new rules allowing her to carry more sail area. Such boats will provide you with the experience to move into other things when you get bigger for example single handed skiffs like the RS 600, 700 and MPS, or double-handed skiffs or boats like the 505.



-------------
Dennis Watson 49er GBR735 http://www.helensburghsailingclub.co.uk/ -
Helensburgh S.C
http://www.noblemarine.co.uk/home.php3?affid=560 - Boat Insurance from Noble Marine



Posted By: allanorton
Date Posted: 07 Jan 06 at 8:41am

12' THAMES SKIFF

Thames Skiff with rig

Slightly slower upwind than an ausy 12' skiff, but I bet they'll be quaking in their wet boots when they see the rate of developement of these british "skiffs"!!!!



Posted By: Strawberry
Date Posted: 08 Jan 06 at 1:20am

hmmm, how come it's ok to sl*g someone off for sayin summin so bloody stupid on the sailin anarchy forum, but not on this....?!

I'm trying to raise the standard of this forum and doing you guys a service by trying to educate you!

It's all in the interest of Y&Y.



-------------
Cherub 2649 "Dangerous Strawberry


Posted By: 49erGBR735HSC
Date Posted: 09 Jan 06 at 12:17am
?????????????

-------------
Dennis Watson 49er GBR735 http://www.helensburghsailingclub.co.uk/ -
Helensburgh S.C
http://www.noblemarine.co.uk/home.php3?affid=560 - Boat Insurance from Noble Marine



Posted By: Strawberry
Date Posted: 09 Jan 06 at 12:00pm

Haha, you edited your post!

I was about to ask you what you have against Americans?



-------------
Cherub 2649 "Dangerous Strawberry


Posted By: TimF
Date Posted: 10 Jan 06 at 7:10pm

Check out this bargin

http://www.boatsandoutboards.com/view/F81967/ - http://www.boatsandoutboards.com/view/F81967/



Posted By: Black no sugar
Date Posted: 10 Jan 06 at 7:20pm
MWAAAHHAWWAHH! At last someone who's got a sense of reality!

-------------
http://www.lancingsc.org.uk/index.html - Lancing SC


Posted By: Isis
Date Posted: 10 Jan 06 at 7:42pm
I wouldnt pay that much for one of them unless it happened to have a cherub sized kite I could nick, in which case... BARGIN!

-------------


Posted By: Black no sugar
Date Posted: 10 Jan 06 at 8:25pm

http://www.boatsandoutboards.com/view/F83827/ - http://www.boatsandoutboards.com/view/F83827/

If you believe the sail number, that's another overpriced boat! It's been on ebay a couple of months ago, but hasn't sold. Hmmmm I wonder why?  Big smile 
(K63!!)



-------------
http://www.lancingsc.org.uk/index.html - Lancing SC



Print Page | Close Window

Bulletin Board Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 9.665y - http://www.webwizforums.com
Copyright ©2001-2010 Web Wiz - http://www.webwizguide.com