Print Page | Close Window

Self Build Single Hander?

Printed From: Yachts and Yachting Online
Category: Dinghy classes
Forum Name: Dinghy development
Forum Discription: The latest moves in the dinghy market
URL: http://www.yachtsandyachting.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=12299
Printed Date: 08 Jul 25 at 1:59am
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 9.665y - http://www.webwizforums.com


Topic: Self Build Single Hander?
Posted By: rqy99g
Subject: Self Build Single Hander?
Date Posted: 03 Feb 16 at 6:56am
Hi

I've had a few years break from sailing but am now semi retired and have a bit more time on my hands so thought it is time to pick it up again.

I've had all sorts of dinghies over the years (Mirror, Laser, International Moth, Enterprise, National 12, Laser and crewed in lots more) but what initially got me in to sailing was the Mirror which my father built from a kit which he bought at the ideal home exhibition in the mid seventies (M32543). 

I take after my father in lots of ways and one of the things I would like to do is build a dinghy. Looking round I can't see many kits or plans. What I would ideally like is something around the size of a Solution. Previously I've had the plans for a Phantom but just a bit to big for me also thought about a Streaker but just a bit to small!

Looking for ideas and inspiration.



Replies:
Posted By: realnutter
Date Posted: 03 Feb 16 at 7:37am
I believe you can still self build a Hadron, even tho' a Carbon fibre version is about to be launched...


Posted By: rqy99g
Date Posted: 03 Feb 16 at 7:56am
Originally posted by realnutter

I believe you can still self build a Hadron, even tho' a Carbon fibre version is about to be launched...

I'd not seen anything about the Hadron but just looking at Dave Henshall's site it does look like the sort of thing I'm thinking about. Ideally I would like stitch and glue rather than build on a frame.

Dave's site took me back to the 70's when at Leigh Dinghy Store they had a Harrier in stock. I used to go in an drool over that. At that time I was crewing in Merlin's. Oh happy days!


Posted By: Paramedic
Date Posted: 03 Feb 16 at 7:58am
You can get plans from the RYA to build a solo yourself.

You may find a builder (Tony Thresher?) to supply you with pre cut panels for the hull, but i don't think anyone does a proper kit for these anymore. A better idea would be to get a bare hull (Winders will supply one) and deck it yourself.

What I would say is that this is not a project to be undergone as a cost saving exercise because you wont! The labour that goes into building the hull is but a small percentage of total cost if you can't get trade prices on the materials. Then theres the rig, fittings, sail etc etc. You can get rig parts secondhand but if its a new boat..............


Posted By: Van Mentz
Date Posted: 03 Feb 16 at 8:30am
Consider a Farr 3.7   www.uk3-7class.org  You have the option of building from scratch or fitting out a hull.



Posted By: JimC
Date Posted: 03 Feb 16 at 8:48am
Do you want to build in wood or foam sandwich? Wood is IMHO more enjoyable, epoxy/foam IMHO requires less skill and equipment.


Posted By: ChrisB14
Date Posted: 03 Feb 16 at 9:02am
Originally posted by Van Mentz

Consider a Farr 3.7   www.uk3-7class.org  You have the option of building from scratch or fitting out a hull.

"Building from scratch" in this case means that you can have the frames CNC cut from ply. I found this is a good starting point, as the most critical measurements will be correct. 


-------------
B14 GBR 748 Bullet B
In build: Farr 3.7 GBR 410 (both sail number and the current number of loose parts)


Posted By: ChrisB14
Date Posted: 03 Feb 16 at 12:28pm
Having said the above, the Farr is built on a frame and it isn't a hiking boat. So might not quite fit the OPs needs ...

-------------
B14 GBR 748 Bullet B
In build: Farr 3.7 GBR 410 (both sail number and the current number of loose parts)


Posted By: KazR
Date Posted: 03 Feb 16 at 12:48pm
I think there's a lot of OKs being built at home now using laser cut panels that slot together and seem to be properly on the pace. Lots in NZ where it originated, plenty in Denmark and a few over here I think. Have a look at http://okdia.org/features/15_return-of-the-woodie.php" rel="nofollow - http://okdia.org/features/15_return-of-the-woodie.php


Posted By: Gfinch
Date Posted: 03 Feb 16 at 10:24pm
Originally posted by rqy99g

 but what initially got me in to sailing was the Mirror which my father built from a kit which he bought at the ideal home exhibition in the mid seventies (M32543)

I'm looking for the history of mine, 32541, would it be safe to assume it was also bought at the ideal home exhibition too?


-------------
3513, 3551 - National 12
136069 - Laser
32541 - Mirror
4501 - Laser 4000


Posted By: JimC
Date Posted: 03 Feb 16 at 10:28pm
Originally posted by Gfinch

...would it be safe to assume ... bought at the ideal home exhibition too?

Unless astonishing detail of Bell paperwork has survived it will be safe to assume that no-one will be able to prove it wasn't...


Posted By: rqy99g
Date Posted: 04 Feb 16 at 10:15am
Thanks for the replies. 

Yes I want to build in wood, a great material to work with.

The Farr 3.7 looks a nice boat but I won't be going out on a wire any time soon : ) . The Hadron is 10sqm... a bit to much of a handful for me, wouldn't have been 20 years or more ago, however it is a beautiful looking boat. The Solo has never done it for me though I have seen some wonderful examples. The OK... when I first started sailing there was an old battered one down at the club and it always used to catch my eye,  just under 9sqm but an old design...

As I previously mentioned, a wooden Solution would be my perfect boat... my solution: ) 

I'll look more in to the Hadron (it is beamy) and OK (I do like the idea of laser cut panels) as they are options.

As for M32541 it wouldn't surprise me if it was bought at the Ideal Home Exhibition if memory serves me rightly the kit was £55 with rig. I think I might have to spend a few more ££££'s to build now.

Cheers

Simon

PS Anyone want to design a wooden Solutionish dinghy : )


Posted By: ChrisB14
Date Posted: 04 Feb 16 at 10:36am
Simon, have a look at the complete OK "Return of the Woodie" article in the class magazine:

http://okdia.org/features/OK-Magazine-May-2015.pdf

(from page 12 on). It mentions two additional kits, available this side of the equator.

My impression is that using the CNC or laser cut panels of the Leech design would be the most cost efficient means of getting a good boat, as you buy the ply and have it cut, reducing transport costs.

The pricing gets better, if you find someone interested in buying the building jig off you after you are done (sharing the cost of wood, cutting and the cost of the plans, as subsequent builds from the same job only cost design fee).

Cheers, Chris


-------------
B14 GBR 748 Bullet B
In build: Farr 3.7 GBR 410 (both sail number and the current number of loose parts)


Posted By: Van Mentz
Date Posted: 04 Feb 16 at 12:41pm
rqy99g Why don't you contact Dave Butler at Butler Boats, he builds wooden Streakers and may be able to put a kit together for you? Look at his Facebook page.


Posted By: Ardea
Date Posted: 04 Feb 16 at 1:19pm
My understanding is that butler boats will supply you with anything from a kit of parts up to a ready to race streaker.  I think he'll even do you a composite hull for you to build out with tanks decks etc.  

It seems a streaker may well tick many of your boxes too!  Although I am a little biased as I own one.


Posted By: rqy99g
Date Posted: 04 Feb 16 at 3:00pm
Originally posted by ChrisB14

Simon, have a look at the complete OK "Return of the Woodie" article in the class magazine:
http://okdia.org/features/OK-Magazine-May-2015.pdf
(from page 12 on). It mentions two additional kits, available this side of the equator.
My impression is that using the CNC or laser cut panels of the Leech design would be the most cost efficient means of getting a good boat, as you buy the ply and have it cut, reducing transport costs.
The pricing gets better, if you find someone interested in buying the building jig off you after you are done (sharing the cost of wood, cutting and the cost of the plans, as subsequent builds from the same job only cost design fee).
Cheers, Chris


Thanks for the info and PM Chris, I'll bear that in mind.

Originally posted by Ardea

My understanding is that butler boats will supply you with anything from a kit of parts up to a ready to race streaker.  I think he'll even do you a composite hull for you to build out with tanks decks etc.  
It seems a streaker may well tick many of your boxes too!  <span style="line-height: 1.4;">Although I am a little biased as I own one.</span>


I have always liked the Streaker but it's a bit on the small side for me.


Posted By: Ardea
Date Posted: 04 Feb 16 at 5:37pm
If your size issue is due to weight then it might be worth looking at the streaker website, top ten in the nationals varied between 62-80kg.

http://www.streaker-class.org.uk/Streaker/Why" rel="nofollow - http://www.streaker-class.org.uk/Streaker/Why


Posted By: Vronny
Date Posted: 04 Feb 16 at 6:48pm
Originally posted by Ardea

If your size issue is due to weight then it might be worth looking at the streaker website, top ten in the nationals varied between 62-80kg.

http://www.streaker-class.org.uk/Streaker/Why" rel="nofollow - http://www.streaker-class.org.uk/Streaker/Why

Actually that info is a bit dated! Last year the weight range of the top 10 at the Streaker Nationals was from 65 to 105 kg ! Four of the top 10 were over 80 kg.





Posted By: Keith_Callaghan
Date Posted: 04 Feb 16 at 7:40pm
The Hadron plans include full size patterns of all the plywood parts and also CNC files of the same, should you want to have them cut for you. The boat is beamy at 1.95m, but not if you have sailed a Merlin Rocket or N12 - everything is relative! Beam = power = less stress on the old legs and back. Enjoy your sailing!


Posted By: Rupert
Date Posted: 04 Feb 16 at 9:19pm
Does more beam mean less stress or a more powerful rig and just as much stress, in general?

-------------
Firefly 2324, Puffin 229, Minisail 3446 Mirror 70686


Posted By: Keith_Callaghan
Date Posted: 04 Feb 16 at 9:25pm
Rupert, ALL OTHER THINGS BEING EQUAL, more beam (in moderation) does equal less stress, in my opinion.


Posted By: Rupert
Date Posted: 04 Feb 16 at 9:59pm
I was thinking more of human nature than science!

-------------
Firefly 2324, Puffin 229, Minisail 3446 Mirror 70686


Posted By: Mongoose
Date Posted: 04 Feb 16 at 10:28pm
For something a bit more challenging, how about an International Canoe?  There is a wood kit for the Slurp design -

http://www.damesblonde.co.uk/products.php?products_group_id=1000" rel="nofollow - http://www.damesblonde.co.uk/products.php?products_group_id=1000


Posted By: JimC
Date Posted: 05 Feb 16 at 12:50am
In theory the wider the beam the less difference the sinew destroying last couple of inches makes. In practice people do it anyway. I was amused by a video posted on SA of someone who's put some small wings on his Laser, saying its not to increase the righting moment, but just to make it more comfortable an less damaging to sail. Then I looked at the video and the first thing I saw was that he was using some extra toe straps he'd rigged in order to get further ouboard. Seems sailors just can't help themselves!


Posted By: Keith_Callaghan
Date Posted: 05 Feb 16 at 7:32am
Agreed Jim - that's why I inserted the proviso 'all other things being equal'.


Posted By: rqy99g
Date Posted: 05 Feb 16 at 9:20am
Originally posted by Keith_Callaghan

The Hadron plans include full size patterns of all the plywood parts and also CNC files of the same, should you want to have them cut for you. The boat is beamy at 1.95m, but not if you have sailed a Merlin Rocket or N12 - everything is relative! Beam = power = less stress on the old legs and back. Enjoy your sailing!

Thanks for the info Keith, oh and thanks for designing great boats!


Originally posted by Mongoose

For something a bit more challenging, how about an International Canoe?  There is a wood kit for the Slurp design -

http://www.damesblonde.co.uk/products.php?products_group_id=1000" rel="nofollow - http://www.damesblonde.co.uk/products.php?products_group_id=1000

That looks great. Good value cnc kit with hull jig hire. Just wish I was youngerTongue


Posted By: Rupert
Date Posted: 05 Feb 16 at 10:57am
If you want a simple project to get you back into it, how about a Minisail? The wooden Sprite version that I sail is flat bottomed. Stitch and glue construction would work well, but you would need to work from scratch on it. Ronny from Belgium built one a couple of years ago, so would be able to help out with plans. His website https://minisail9000.wordpress.com has lots on it, though you will need to scroll down, and more info on the boats at Minisail.org.uk.

-------------
Firefly 2324, Puffin 229, Minisail 3446 Mirror 70686


Posted By: Vronny
Date Posted: 05 Feb 16 at 3:20pm
If you want to build your own wooden boat and be part of a well-established class, then the Streaker has to be a good bet. At last year's Nationals there were at least 4 home-built boats competing. You can get a kit from Butler Boats or plans from the class assoc.


Posted By: JimC
Date Posted: 05 Feb 16 at 4:15pm
It is funny though: other than the OK there's not an obvious mid range singlehander you can build. Streaker and Solo are much of a muchness on peformance then its up to the Phantom or of course the IC )


Posted By: Jack Sparrow
Date Posted: 05 Feb 16 at 4:18pm
From the Farr 3.7 Thread...

Originally posted by Jack Sparrow

https://www.facebook.com/groups/1092602470772759/" rel="nofollow - https://www.facebook.com/groups/1092602470772759/

For anyone interested:- the Farr 3.7 Class now has a Facebook Group for people building Farr 3.7's. It's primarily there as a place to ask for and share advice on building. Take a look if you are thinking about self building. The Group is a bit bear at the moment (it's only launched today) but will fill up with info soon I'm sure.


-------------
http://www.uk3-7class.org/index.html" rel="nofollow - Farr 3.7 Class Website
https://www.facebook.com/groups/1092602470772759/" rel="nofollow - Farr 3.7 Building - Facebook Group


Posted By: ChrisB14
Date Posted: 05 Feb 16 at 4:31pm
Originally posted by Vronny

If you want to build your own wooden boat and be part of a well-established class, then the Streaker has to be a good bet. At last year's Nationals there were at least 4 home-built boats competing. You can get a kit from Butler Boats or plans from the class assoc.

I know the Streak Owners Association website mentions those kits, but has anyone recently actually contacted Dave Butler and asked? I remember being told that such a kit does not exist. Maybe things have changed.


-------------
B14 GBR 748 Bullet B
In build: Farr 3.7 GBR 410 (both sail number and the current number of loose parts)


Posted By: davidyacht
Date Posted: 05 Feb 16 at 5:15pm
Whilst I would love to think of lots of people re-engaging with building wooden racing dinghies, I suspect that only the retired can find time for such projects in today's world; which is a shame.

-------------
Happily living in the past


Posted By: ChrisB14
Date Posted: 05 Feb 16 at 6:22pm
I disagree. There are people out there building boats while still working and in many cases with families. 
In my case, spending time in the workshop working on the Farr is a nice alternative to an evening on the couch in front of the TV and I can't wait to get back to it. I only took a break as I knew we had a move coming up and wanted the boat in an easy to move state.


-------------
B14 GBR 748 Bullet B
In build: Farr 3.7 GBR 410 (both sail number and the current number of loose parts)


Posted By: rogerd
Date Posted: 05 Feb 16 at 9:17pm
Originally posted by davidyacht

Whilst I would love to think of lots of people re-engaging with building wooden racing dinghies, I suspect that only the retired can find time for such projects in today's world; which is a shame.

In todays world we come home play on our computors ipads etc. Its a myth that you have less time than the generations that built wooden boats.
My dad worked full time, maintained his own cars, extended and maintained his house(no plastic windows)had a huge veg patch to feed four hungry kids in the high inflation late sixties and seventies. Helped us build and maintain Mirrors and canoes etc.
The only thing I don't remember him doing was sitting watching telly except to watch the rugby on the occasional Saturday afternoon.
We choose to spend our time on Y&Y forum and social media and say we are to busy to build and maintain wooden boats.
Oh and he only got two weeks holiday a year.


Posted By: rqy99g
Date Posted: 05 Feb 16 at 9:20pm
Originally posted by JimC

It is funny though: other than the OK there's not an obvious mid range singlehander you can build. Streaker and Solo are much of a muchness on peformance then its up to the Phantom or of course the IC )


I agree and apart from the Hadron the classes mentioned are old designs.


Posted By: realnutter
Date Posted: 05 Feb 16 at 10:18pm
Originally posted by rqy99g



I agree and apart from the Hadron the classes mentioned are old designs.


You say that like it's a bad thing....

The fact that they're old designs still being home built and raced proves that they're GOOD designs.

Actually, a bigger indicator that they're good designs is that they're still being commercially produced too....


Posted By: davidyacht
Date Posted: 05 Feb 16 at 10:18pm
Originally posted by JimC

It is funny though: other than the OK there's not an obvious mid range singlehander you can build. Streaker and Solo are much of a muchness on peformance then its up to the Phantom or of course the IC )

Jim suggests that there may be a gap for a mid range singlehander you can build ... My point is that there is no mass amateur (or professional) plywood movement as existed in the 70's, therefore it seems unlikely that any boat intended to fill that gap would be built in sufficient numbers to gain traction.

Back in the day a significant proportion of Jack Holt designs were built by amateurs, or by one man band professional boatbuilders.

It might be possible to build such a boat in either plywood or FRP, however in most classes where both constructions are allowed, FRP seems to dominate.

I must admit to liking the look of the Hadron ... But I wonder whether the RS300 might appeal to a similar market in FRP, i.e. A technical one design that resembles a single handed N12/Merlin or Skol Moth.


-------------
Happily living in the past


Posted By: Do Different
Date Posted: 05 Feb 16 at 10:19pm
Spot on rogerd. 


Posted By: realnutter
Date Posted: 05 Feb 16 at 10:46pm
Originally posted by davidyacht

. A technical one design that resembles a single handed N12


AFAIK there's only one N12 kit available.... It might form the basis of a new single handed class...  Beamy and moderately powered...

http://www.fyneboatkits.co.uk/kits/sailing/national-12/" rel="nofollow - http://www.fyneboatkits.co.uk/kits/sailing/national-12/


Posted By: JimC
Date Posted: 06 Feb 16 at 6:01am
Originally posted by davidyacht

Jim suggests that there may be a gap for a mid range singlehander you can build ...

No, I'm making no such suggestion.

All I was saying was that its kinda odd that there isn't one, but thinking back to those days when the Laser came out, there wasn't really much in the way of popular singlehanders much faster than a Solo until you got to the two real performance boats. We shouldn't forget that the Laser was quicker than most hiking singlehanders back then.

I suppose it could be said that just because there appears to be a gap in the market, it doesn't mean there's a market in the gap...


Posted By: Paramedic
Date Posted: 06 Feb 16 at 8:06am
One of the main problems is see with single handers in general is they tend to be slow, overpowered or both.


Posted By: Rupert
Date Posted: 06 Feb 16 at 8:44am
Originally posted by Paramedic

One of the main problems is see with single handers in general is they tend to be slow, overpowered or both.


Doesn't that describe dinghies as a whole?

-------------
Firefly 2324, Puffin 229, Minisail 3446 Mirror 70686


Posted By: rqy99g
Date Posted: 07 Feb 16 at 7:57am
Originally posted by realnutter

Originally posted by rqy99g



I agree and apart from the Hadron the classes mentioned are old designs.


You say that like it's a bad thing....

The fact that they're old designs still being home built and raced proves that they're GOOD designs.

Actually, a bigger indicator that they're good designs is that they're still being commercially produced too....

I just thought (maybe naively) that there would be newer designs (Solo 56, OK 57, Minisail 61, Phantom 71, Streaker 75) utilising a more modern approach to building which had perhaps developed on the stitch and glue method. There has been a lot of development using composite material such as foam sandwich, carbon, kevlar, etc and I'd hoped that the builders side may have developed where using CAD and CNC machines could produce kits which are easy(ish) to build with accurately cut parts at an affordable price. I'm probably looking for the Holy Grail of single handed sailing which just suits meWink

Ironically I'm tempted by the Minisail idea.


Posted By: Paramedic
Date Posted: 07 Feb 16 at 8:54am
Originally posted by Rupert

 Doesn't that describe dinghies as a whole?

No i don't think so, certainly not to the same extent at least. Most two man boats dramatically increase their sail area once round the top mark, so you don't need a mainsail thats big enough to fast downhill while still being sensible up the beat.

Much as i think the standard of racing in the Solo class is really good and it's on the whole a pleasant boat to sail, it's a lot of work for not a lot of speed. There are classes that do the speed/work ratio better like the Supernova but are - IMO - less pleasant to sail. We'd all love a Phantom downwind, but only the larger fraternity can turn the bottom corner if its a three or more.

Sure, there are two man boats like that but if you don't like busting a gut to go slowly there are loads of options :). There are fewer options in the singlehander category, though i'd be interested to have a go in an Aero and the H2 Hadron looks interesting, though unfortunately i can't see it being a big hit without the marketing might of RS behind it.


Posted By: Keith_Callaghan
Date Posted: 07 Feb 16 at 9:49am
You are of course right about the marketing power of RS. But we are hopeful that the H2 will sell on its merits once there are a few out there. Aero and H2 are completely different in basic concept.


Posted By: 423zero
Date Posted: 07 Feb 16 at 1:20pm
Plenty of help and advice at minisail.org.uk
friendly informal group.
Regularily for sale on ebay etc, usually for next to nothing.


Posted By: ChrisB14
Date Posted: 07 Feb 16 at 1:23pm
Originally posted by rqy99g

 
I just thought (maybe naively) that there would be newer designs (Solo 56, OK 57, Minisail 61, Phantom 71, Streaker 75) utilising a more modern approach to building which had perhaps developed on the stitch and glue method. There has been a lot of development using composite material such as foam sandwich, carbon, kevlar, etc and I'd hoped that the builders side may have developed where using CAD and CNC machines could produce kits which are easy(ish) to build with accurately cut parts at an affordable price. 

There are classes that have a strong home-build tradition that use composite materials. The Cherubs, Aussie Javelin, possibly some N12s. I am not aware of any single handers, though.

But I think it is wrong to draw the conclusion wood = old fashioned. Wood is cost efficient, easy to work for an amateur, and has quite a few advantageous properties. And keep in mind that wood can be used as a core for composite builds. There is a reason it is still finding use in high performance projects. More historically, Julian Bethwaite built 18s on a balsa strip plank core. And today you will find people building high performance sports such as the Shaw 650 using strip planked cedar cores.

Sure, carbon on a foam core would have many advantages to these solutions, but it would be more hassel and more expensive to build for an amateur builder. Not that it wouldn't be fun :)


-------------
B14 GBR 748 Bullet B
In build: Farr 3.7 GBR 410 (both sail number and the current number of loose parts)


Posted By: ChrisB14
Date Posted: 07 Feb 16 at 1:37pm
Originally posted by Paramedic

Originally posted by Rupert

 Doesn't that describe dinghies as a whole?

No i don't think so, certainly not to the same extent at least. Most two man boats dramatically increase their sail area once round the top mark, so you don't need a mainsail thats big enough to fast downhill while still being sensible up the beat.

But doesn't your statement above already contain the answer? RS Vareo, RS 100 and D-One all do exactly that: increase their sail area once round the top mark. Losing some of the simplicity of a single hander of course. But yes, the *eros seem to be an option.


-------------
B14 GBR 748 Bullet B
In build: Farr 3.7 GBR 410 (both sail number and the current number of loose parts)


Posted By: JimC
Date Posted: 07 Feb 16 at 5:19pm
Originally posted by ChrisB14

I am not aware of any single handers, though.


Moths and ICs. But the modern Moth is a stretch for most home builders.

Originally posted by ChrisB14

But I think it is wrong to draw the conclusion wood = old fashioned. Wood is cost efficient, easy to work for an amateur, and has quite a few advantageous properties.


I'd contend that wet layup epoxy foam is a lot easier for an amateur to build a decent strong light boat than wood. Less dust with wood though, and maybe less fairing and sanding. There's some ideas being worked out with pre laminated foam/carbon panels too.


Posted By: ChrisB14
Date Posted: 07 Feb 16 at 5:32pm
Originally posted by JimC

Moths and ICs. But the modern Moth is a stretch for most home builders. 


Yes, I did forget the IC. 

Originally posted by JimC

I'd contend that wet layup epoxy foam is a lot easier for an amateur to build a decent strong light boat than wood. Less dust with wood though, and maybe less fairing and sanding. There's some ideas being worked out with pre laminated foam/carbon panels too.

Ultimately "ease" is probably also a question of which material someone prefers. But I see your point.


-------------
B14 GBR 748 Bullet B
In build: Farr 3.7 GBR 410 (both sail number and the current number of loose parts)


Posted By: Paramedic
Date Posted: 07 Feb 16 at 5:48pm
Originally posted by ChrisB14

But doesn't your statement above already contain the answer? RS Vareo, RS 100 and D-One all do exactly that: increase their sail area once round the top mark. Losing some of the simplicity of a single hander of course. But yes, the *eros seem to be an option.

The Vareo is no more exciting to sail than a Solo, at least the one i sailed wasn't. It's a dog upwind and overpowered on the reaches in any kind of breeze. Useless for round the cans racing. Ive not sailed either of the others, but i suspect they fall into the same category - happy to be proven wrong. I also think that they are a bit too much of a fiddle once you turn the corner round the mark as most people i know only have one pair of hands! The 700 and the MPS are just too much boat for most people and are venue restrictive.

Keith, I wish you the very best with your venture and I do hope it works out. I'm sure you know only too well what you're up against!!


Posted By: Riv
Date Posted: 07 Feb 16 at 6:05pm
Wood is good but the boat has to be the right shape to make the most of it. In a dinghy you need (unless you are sailing a Finn) the boat to be as rigid as possible. The OK is great for this as if you look at it as an engineering structure you have a deep box section between the sailor and the mast, excellent in torsion.

If you have something with a big open cockpit such as a phantom, solo, then you have to lock it up with tanks down each side and it's more complicated in shape, more joints, more panels maybe better for non wood composites.

The Minisail is another ideal boat to build from wood as it is a box with a very small hole cut in it. The ones that were flush decked (Monaco?) are even better.

So some boats are good for wood and some just aren't.

The next thing is epoxy and carbon. Frankly though it looks beautiful when finished, but the smell, the stickyness, the waste, the environmental impact, the dust hazzards, the unknown health hazzards. Skin cancer/lung cancer here we go!  Uck!!

This sort of material is really unatractive to work with.

So wood is good in the right place and can use a small amount of epoxy in a stitch and glue type system and get a nice result and limit your exposure to the stuff.

(BTW I have no love for styrene based resins, almost killed myself with them when much younger)

What I'd like is for a design specifically using the new polyurethane glues, less off gassing, easier clean up. Fewer environmental impacts, esier for Jo average to use, ie me.

A slightly wider OK  type wood be nice




Posted By: RS400atC
Date Posted: 07 Feb 16 at 6:10pm
Originally posted by Paramedic

...

The Vareo is no more exciting to sail than a Solo, at least the one i sailed wasn't. It's a dog upwind and overpowered on the reaches in any kind of breeze. Useless for round the cans racing.....


The Vareo is not the fastest thing on the planet, but the people who sail them round the cans at our club seem to enjoy it. It wouldn't be my choice, but neither would 95% of the singlehanders which seem to offer nothing in the way of USP.


Posted By: realnutter
Date Posted: 07 Feb 16 at 6:11pm
Originally posted by JimC

  There's some ideas being worked out with pre laminated foam/carbon panels too.


What? Like an artificial plywood? Where can I find out more?


Posted By: JimC
Date Posted: 07 Feb 16 at 7:08pm
Read up about Clive Everest's boat on the Cherub website, also the flatpack IC project http://icflatpack.blogspot.co.uk/2008_09_01_archive.html



Print Page | Close Window

Bulletin Board Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 9.665y - http://www.webwizforums.com
Copyright ©2001-2010 Web Wiz - http://www.webwizguide.com