Scoring Systems

   Please can anyone offer advice on scoring systems for class racing series?
Our 3000 TT class racing series is currently based on 6 events, including the nationals. In 2004 we reduced the number of events from 8 to 6 to concentrate entries at fewer venues, and only score the best 3 results so people only need to sail 3 events to complete the series. We used a simple scoring system, 1st = 1 pt, 2nd = 2 pts, etc. The nationals results currently carry equal weighting to series events. Most events are 2-days, 5 or 6 races, and we score the overall event result rather than individual races.
In 2005, 29 boats competed in at least one event, 8 boats did 2 events, but only 3 boats did 3 or more events. DNCs scored 29 based on the total series entry. Entries at normal TT events varied from 12 down to 3, with 15 at the midweek Nats (down from 19 in 2004).
For 2006 we've considered bringing in a F1 GP style scoring system where 1st = 10 pts, 2nd = 9 pts, ...., 10th or below = 1 pt, DNC = 0 pts. With a higher entry the Nationals could score double: 1st = 20, 2nd = 19, etc. The aim is not to penalise DNCs so heavily and introduce some novelty value.
Does anyone have experience of this count-down style of scoring system? Can anyone recommend an alternative that works well for them?

Author	Message Share Topic Printable Version Delicious Digg Facebook Furl Google MySpace Newsvine reddit StumbleUpon Translate Twitter Windows Live Yahoo Bookmarks Topic Search Topic Options Post Reply Create New Topic
yellowhammer Send Private Message Find Member's Posts Visit Member's Homepage Far too distracted from work Joined: 08 May 05 Location: United Kingdom Online Status: Offline Posts: 270	Post Options Post Reply Quote yellowhammer Report Post Quote Reply Topic: Scoring Systems Posted: 15 Nov 05 at 12:37pm
	Please can anyone offer advice on scoring systems for class racing series? Our 3000 TT class racing series is currently based on 6 events, including the nationals. In 2004 we reduced the number of events from 8 to 6 to concentrate entries at fewer venues, and only score the best 3 results so people only need to sail 3 events to complete the series. We used a simple scoring system, 1st = 1 pt, 2nd = 2 pts, etc. The nationals results currently carry equal weighting to series events. Most events are 2-days, 5 or 6 races, and we score the overall event result rather than individual races. In 2005, 29 boats competed in at least one event, 8 boats did 2 events, but only 3 boats did 3 or more events. DNCs scored 29 based on the total series entry. Entries at normal TT events varied from 12 down to 3, with 15 at the midweek Nats (down from 19 in 2004). For 2006 we've considered bringing in a F1 GP style scoring system where 1st = 10 pts, 2nd = 9 pts, ...., 10th or below = 1 pt, DNC = 0 pts. With a higher entry the Nationals could score double: 1st = 20, 2nd = 19, etc. The aim is not to penalise DNCs so heavily and introduce some novelty value. Does anyone have experience of this count-down style of scoring system? Can anyone recommend an alternative that works well for them?
	Laser 3000 @ Leigh & Lowton SC www.3000class.org.uk

gordon Send Private Message Find Member's Posts Really should get out more Joined: 07 Sep 04 Online Status: Offline Posts: 1037	Post Options Post Reply Quote gordon Report Post Quote Reply Posted: 17 Nov 05 at 4:56pm
	One of the problems with using a low point system for scoring racing over an extended period is that the winning boat's score is not a reflection of the number of boats entered, nor of the importance of the event. In our club we use a high points system for scoring club racing which seems to satisfy most people. Very simply : boats score 1 point for coming to the start area plus 1 point for every boat that finishes after her plus one point for every boat that came to the start are but did not finish. DNC, DSQ score zero points. We have adapted this for our winter Pico sailing (another story) - one point for entering then 1 point plus 1 point for every boat that finishes after her in each day's sailing. It is necesssary to provide for discards and weightings for more important events. There are many other systems: the Snipes in France use a system that has the advantage of making sure that people come to the National championships and does not define in advance which events will count. The formula is: Pts = K1+K2*((NC-Pl)/NC+Pl-2) NC= number of competitors Pl=place obtained in the event K1=1 K2= 699 for an international event, 599 for the National championship, 399 for an inter regional event, 99 for a Regional event (club racing is not scored). Competitors can count: all open International events held in the country, the Nationals, 3 Inter-regional and 5 regional events. The class publishes a list of events that can count as ranking events. This system means that only the Nationals are really an obligatory event. I'm sure that there are many other system. I seem to remember that the Darts had a system that not only established a rankiong but could calculate each competitors theoretical finishing place in the event - which meant that they could calculate the best performance... does anyone have any details.. Gordon
	Gordon

Scooby_simon Send Private Message Find Member's Posts Visit Member's Homepage Really should get out more Joined: 02 Apr 04 Location: United Kingdom Online Status: Offline Posts: 2415	Post Options Post Reply Quote Scooby_simon Report Post Quote Reply Posted: 17 Nov 05 at 10:05pm
	The Dart 18 system is documented: http://www.dart18.com/Docs/TechTalk/handicapsystem.htm
	Wanna learn to Ski - PM me..