Print Page | Close Window

Topaz Xenon

Printed From: Yachts and Yachting Online
Category: Dinghy classes
Forum Name: Dinghy development
Forum Discription: The latest moves in the dinghy market
URL: http://www.yachtsandyachting.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=977
Printed Date: 15 Aug 25 at 12:34pm
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 9.665y - http://www.webwizforums.com


Topic: Topaz Xenon
Posted By: Marine Boy
Subject: Topaz Xenon
Date Posted: 01 Sep 05 at 11:52am
Hello to all,
Please go gentle, this is my first post...am looking for an exciting, forgiving club racer with occasional use with young children.
Anybody got any opinions, experience of the Xenon in comparison to L2K, Vision etc
Anything else in the 'low maintenance' bracket I should consider?
Thanks
 
 
 



Replies:
Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 01 Sep 05 at 1:43pm
I'm looking for something similar, and the Xenon is on my list.

Vision and L2000 are essentially similar - great boats but not particularly
exciting, which is where I hope the Xenon will deliver.

Vago is a smaller boat than the Xenon, so less good for kids (which are
going to get bigger, remember!)

Be interested to hear how you get on.

Cheers

Phil


Posted By: Marine Boy
Date Posted: 01 Sep 05 at 2:04pm
I like the look of the L2K but it is expensive (in comparison) and I am not too keen on damage repairs to GRP. I have sailed the Vision, but the kite/pole pulley block pulled straight out and couldn't easily be fixed (brand new boat). The kite cover (a dark grey plastic moulding) buckled very badly in the sun. All in all, for quality I would go for the L2K but I'm hoping the Xenon will fit the bill for the excitement bit and better build quality than RS. I will be trying the Xenon out next week so will report back.


Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 01 Sep 05 at 2:07pm
I agree re the L2000 - expensive and not as durable for family use.

I liked the Vision to sail but wasn't happy with the finish - that kite cover is
ugly.

Look forward to hearing how you get on with the Xenon. I was going to try it
this Friday, but work got in the way :(


Posted By: JimC
Date Posted: 01 Sep 05 at 4:05pm
One thing that might be a consideration is that its a pretty heavy boat - the manufacturers quote 118 kg which is between an Enterprise and a GP14. This is probably inevitable with a thermoplastic boat of this size in the present state of the art, but could be quite a bit of weight to tow round the dinghy park.


Posted By: simsy
Date Posted: 01 Sep 05 at 4:29pm

Well I wouldnt reccomend the Vago, anything has gotta be better then that.



Posted By: redback
Date Posted: 01 Sep 05 at 6:15pm
I don't think you should write the Vago off quite so glibly.  However its not the same sort of boat as the others mentioned here.  I see the Vago as a boat which would be sailed by people learning how to use a trapeze and race, whereas the Laser2K, the Xenon and the Vision are more for cruising/racing.


Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 01 Sep 05 at 9:06pm
I suspect the Vago is too small for my needs, but it sounds a good bit of kit.
Why do you not recommend it, Simsy?

Redback, I reckon the Xenon will be faster and more fun than the L2000 and
Vision, so a good in-between boat.

Phil


Posted By: simsy
Date Posted: 02 Sep 05 at 12:24am

I sailed one the other day, it was blowing about a force 5. I honestly found this boat rockier then an 800. I found it difficult to to keep the crew out on the wire, and was constantly looking to get more power out of the main, as the boat just kept wanting to capsize on top of us.

Plus the mast looks like a scafold pole, we went swimmin a couple of times, as soon as your over, we found the boat turn turtle almost instantly, then just to add to the fun, the centerplate fell down.

I personally wasnt impressed, and everyone else that I spoke to last week that had tried it, wasnt completly satisifed either.



Posted By: Sumo
Date Posted: 02 Sep 05 at 5:51pm
Originally posted by simsy

Well I wouldnt reccomend the Vago, anything has gotta be better then that.

I would recomend the Vago, in terms of size it isn' t that much different than the L2000, but has the advantage of a gnav instead of a vang giving more room for crew. It also has a much larger sail area and a larger genacker making it a racier boat particularly downwind on the plane. It is also has the advantage of being cheaper than the L2000.



Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 02 Sep 05 at 5:55pm
Originally posted by Sumo

Originally posted by simsy


Well I wouldnt reccomend the Vago, anything has gotta be better then
that.



I would recomend the Vago, in terms of size it isn' t that much different
than the L2000, but has the advantage of a gnav instead of a vang giving
more room for crew. It also has a much larger sail area and a larger
genacker making it a racier boat particularly downwind on the plane. It is
also has the advantage of being cheaper than the L2000.



Interesting reply. The L2000 is ideal for up to two adults and two kids,
would you say the same for the Vago?


Posted By: Sumo
Date Posted: 02 Sep 05 at 6:26pm
Originally posted by Philsy

Originally posted by Sumo

Originally posted by simsy


Well I wouldnt reccomend the Vago, anything has gotta be better then
that.



I would recomend the Vago, in terms of size it isn' t that much different
than the L2000, but has the advantage of a gnav instead of a vang giving
more room for crew. It also has a much larger sail area and a larger
genacker making it a racier boat particularly downwind on the plane. It is
also has the advantage of being cheaper than the L2000.



Interesting reply. The L2000 is ideal for up to two adults and two kids,
would you say the same for the Vago?

Personaly I wouldn't sail at L2000 with that many people?, my point is that with the gnav, what room there is in the Vago, which isn't that much smaller than the L2000 can be more easily used. The kicking strap on most dinghies, even quite large ones like the RS400 or Stratos means that more than one person in the front cockpit causes problems when trying to tack.



Posted By: simsy
Date Posted: 02 Sep 05 at 8:05pm

I have to disagree with you there Sumo, I find that the L2000 is has much more space then the Vago. Iv sailed a L2000 many times, and have never found problems with gettin people in there. To be honest, the kicker really doesnt pose much of a problem, I never found it did anyway.

The L2000 really isnt much slower then the Vago, it was said that the Vago would sail off of a PY of 980, but thats just silly (ploy to sell the boat really). I would have thought its more along the lines of about 1030. So to be honest its not much racier, seeing as a L2000 sails off of 1089.

Also, in a breeze, you would be surprised how fun a L2000 is!



Posted By: Guests
Date Posted: 03 Sep 05 at 5:37pm
Hi guys
On the subject of the Vago i have to honest and say that i havnt actually sailed one.  Although we had a demo boat come to our club for a few days and a whole range of sailors from our club tried it.  People who sail fireballs, laser 2000's + 4000's , phantoms - and many more people from different classes and i struggled to find a good comment from any of them about the Vago.  I always try to look for good points with any boat but the shear amount of bad reviews is less than inspiring.  Maybe it just wasnt right for a river.....anyone know what its like on waves??


Posted By: Marine Boy
Date Posted: 10 Sep 05 at 2:45pm
Well, had a sail in the Xenon on thursday and bought one today. What a great boat this is. We had it in a 3 and try as I might, I could not tip her up - so that's the kids sorted. She was very light on the tiller and very quick to change direction. I know she has a 2m beam but I couldn't believe the space and lack of clutter. The gnav and stainless hoop give even more room and somewhere to grab hold of if you lose your balance. The fittings and fixings looked good and sturdy. The see-through main is a godsend for racing. Single handing is a doddle. All in all it has everything I want and with no gel coat chips to repair, I can spend more time on the water. To think that she has a PY of 1036 and 30% more sail area than the L2K means i'm not going to get bored. I would thoroughly recommend the Xenon.


Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 10 Sep 05 at 6:24pm
Well, I'm envious. Still not had time for a demo sale (Datchett is not that
handy for me) but I've a gut feeling this is the boat for me.

I'll be interested to hear how you get on with the boat. When do you get
yours? Do please keep us posted!

Cheers

Phil


Posted By: Marine Boy
Date Posted: 10 Sep 05 at 7:58pm
Phil, I think it would be worth you making the time if you fancy a good deal.
I am having one of the ex Endeavour Trophy boats. Topper are selling the kite boat, combi, cover with full guarantee for £4.6K. I couldn't resist !
There are 30 boats in the Trophy of which six have been reserved in the last week.
Will post more when I get to play...
 
 


Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 11 Sep 05 at 6:31am
Umm, that is a very good deal. Financially, though, I wasn't planning on
buying until next season....

Have to think about taht one...

Phil


Posted By: Wave Rider
Date Posted: 12 Sep 05 at 5:41pm
hmmm why have they name a dighy after an element, lol i was in science and thought i recognised Xenon, on the periodic table!

-------------
           -[Franko]-
Chew Valley Lake Sailing Club
           RS600 933


Posted By: Jon Emmett
Date Posted: 12 Sep 05 at 6:45pm
An an inert one at that. Why not something highly reactive or radioactive??? Hmmm actually... name is quite appropriate!

-------------
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Be-Your-Own-Tactics-Coach/dp/0470973218/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1312565831&sr=8-1 -


Posted By: Marine Boy
Date Posted: 12 Sep 05 at 7:14pm
Or how about naming a boat after the users IQ ?


Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 13 Sep 05 at 9:48pm
I like the name. The xenon headlamps on my car are bright, powerful and a
joy to use. Maybe the boat will be the same


Posted By: NickA
Date Posted: 13 Sep 05 at 10:29pm

The NSSA "mount hayes trophy" was sailed in Xenons this year.  Described by my kids as "a huge plastic RS400 substitute".  Despite which it can be sailed by a determined 15 year old with a mite-sized crew.  Way to go James & Elly!

Not totally sure what this boat is for.  They already make the Magno and the Omega.  Hardly a Vago competitor as it has no trapeze.

Any ideas?

 



Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 13 Sep 05 at 10:44pm
Someone in another thread here claims a trapeze is available.



Posted By: AngusJT
Date Posted: 14 Sep 05 at 9:16am
Definitely can have a Trapeze fitted as does mine. A simple 5-minute job on a very stable platform. I would be surprised if the Endeavour Xenons were not to be fitted with them given those sailing them!!


Posted By: Iain C
Date Posted: 14 Sep 05 at 10:44am

I think it's Toppers route into development sailing.  It comes with an electric iron as part of the package, and if you feel that the point of max width is a bit far forward, or you want to turn the chines in a bit at the transom, you just warm the iron up, turn the old rotomoulded girl upside down and get to work on her.

Just don't apply too much heat or you'll end up with something that looks like a Vortex...



-------------
RS700 GBR922 "Wirespeed"
Fireball GBR14474 "Eleven Parsecs"
Enterprise GBR21970
Bavaria 32 GBR4755L "Adastra"


Posted By: Black no sugar
Date Posted: 14 Sep 05 at 11:54am

That's how they designed it!

The Vortex proves a point: never store your rotomoulded too near the barbecue!



-------------
http://www.lancingsc.org.uk/index.html - Lancing SC


Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 14 Sep 05 at 4:51pm
Why the negativity towards rotomoulded boats? Glassfibre doesn't cope well
with heat, don't you know?

I like the idea of a boat that's essentially maintanence free and is more
durable than a glassfibre one. The only downsides I can see are a less
attractive surface finish and a slight weight increase.

Or am I missing something?


Posted By: Marine Boy
Date Posted: 14 Sep 05 at 5:07pm
It's just plain simple snobbery Phil, the GRP fanatics put down rotomoulds just as the wooden boats put down GRP when it first came out. I would expect nothing less from the carbon/kevlar brigade. In my humble opinion, rotomoulding is the way to go from the point of view of cost and more time on the water, less getting the repair kit out. If rotomoulding encourages more people to get out on the water and get stuck in rather than worrying about their precious gelcoat, then i'll drink to that...


Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 14 Sep 05 at 5:14pm
I think you're right.

My daughter has a Topper (yes, I know that's not rotomoulded but it's
plastic) and that is so durable - and we can chuck it around without
worrying about it cracking or chipping.

Of course, maybe I should really be getting a tree trunk and use fire to
hollow it out, instead of going for one of these new fangled boats

-------------


Posted By: Black no sugar
Date Posted: 14 Sep 05 at 5:54pm

Eeh tell me about it!
I usually sail my Topper up the beach at Lancing, at that's mostly pebbles. My baby's bottom's a bit scratched, OK, but how many boats can do that without damage?

Tree trunk, eh? Can you trapeze it?  



-------------
http://www.lancingsc.org.uk/index.html - Lancing SC


Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 14 Sep 05 at 5:56pm
Originally posted by Black no sugar

Eeh tell me about it! I usually sail my Topper up
the beach at Lancing, at that's mostly pebbles. My baby's bottom's a bit
scratched, OK, but how many boats can do that without damage?


Tree trunk, eh? Can you trapeze it?  



Trapeze? Nah, lead weights around my waist    

-------------


Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 19 Sep 05 at 8:34pm
Had a good look at a Xenon at the Boat Show. Looks very tempting. My only
slight concern is whether it will be too 'sit on' for my small kids and non-
sailing wife. The RS Vision, for instance, has a deeper cockpit.

Phil

-------------


Posted By: Marine Boy
Date Posted: 19 Sep 05 at 9:23pm
A buddy of mine has a Stratos and the children have fights over who gets to lean against the stainless hoop on the thwart. The thwart seat is perfect for little ones security in terms of something to grab hold of if they are worried. Once children get over their inital concerns you might have trouble getting them to sit in! Your wife might be more of a concern though...
I'm off to the show tommorow to introduce my wife to the Xenon...hope she likes it...or I'll be looking for a budding trapeze artist !
I might have opted for a vision had I not experienced at first hand how badly built they were.
Think you should sail them both...then you'll know.
 
 


Posted By: NickA
Date Posted: 19 Sep 05 at 10:00pm

The xenon's so wide you could probably sit the kids in the bottom and they'd never have to see the water!  But I'd agree with Marine Boy it's keeping the kids away from the water that's the problem after a bit.

Trapeze on a 6ft wide, designed-for-hiking boat - wow, who needs racks!!  Should  be good in a force 8 or so...... unless the fittings rip out the plastic that is.



Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 20 Sep 05 at 8:55am
No problems with the kids - they love sailing. Wife may want a bit more
comfort though. On second thoughts, I could leave her at the bar ;)

I asked a guy on the Topper stand about fitting a trapeze to the Xenon and
he was very hesitant before reluctantly agreeing you could fit one. Not sure
why he reacted in that way.

I've sailed a Vision and a Laser 2000, I'll try to get a demo in the Xenon ASAP

Phil

-------------


Posted By: IanMitchell
Date Posted: 20 Sep 05 at 4:41pm
Originally posted by Marine Boy

I am having one of the ex Endeavour Trophy boats. Topper are selling the kite boat, combi, cover with full guarantee for £4.6K. I couldn't resist !
There are 30 boats in the Trophy of which six have been reserved in the last week.
 

As of about 9.30 this morning when I spoke to Topper, 19 of the 30 have been reserved.  You can reserve at that price for £500 deposit, £440 of which is refundable if you change your mind after a trial.

Laser are also offering a boat show deal on Laser 2000s, which knocks about £700 off the list price of a brand new 2000 with cover and combi, they want a £100 fully refundable deposit.

 



Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 30 Mar 06 at 6:58am
Marine Boy, how are you getting on with the Xenon?



-------------


Posted By: BBSCFaithfull
Date Posted: 31 Mar 06 at 9:59am
Having not sailed a Xenon or A Vision first hand i cannot comment. The only plastic boats i have sailed unfortunately have been fevas and the Omega. Both were completely awful to sail. I can however HIGHLY recomend the 2000. It is a fantastic bit of kit, very stable for what it is.Really gets a move on in the bigger winds (force 8 3 up!) Its very responsive, low mainsheet loads. Responsive Rig Controls, Excellent reefing system, additional trapeze option and great begginners boat. Just generally an excellent boat which is fantastic and in my personal opinion very rearding to sail.


-------------
Greatfully Sponsored By
www.allgoodfun.com
Int 14 GBR 1503!!


Posted By: getafix
Date Posted: 11 Apr 06 at 12:54pm
L2K has a good class assoc and a good bunch of people sailing them , not saying that Xenon  or Vago don't or won't, just that L2K got there first and they've stolen a  march on the rest

Seem well built but a bit heavy on the trailer on land, asymetric makes life easy downwind for the novice crew, sheet loads aren't too bad

... don't sail one meeself, just know a few folks who do


-------------
Feeling sorry for vegans since it became the latest fad to claim you are one



Print Page | Close Window

Bulletin Board Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 9.665y - http://www.webwizforums.com
Copyright ©2001-2010 Web Wiz - http://www.webwizguide.com