Choosing a boat: Another request for advice on the best family boat

Print Page | Close Window

Another request for advice on the best family boat

Printed From: Yachts and Yachting Online
Category: General
Forum Name: Choosing a boat
Forum Discription: Ask any questions about the sport!
URL: http://www.yachtsandyachting.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=7641
Printed Date: 06 Aug 25 at 8:00pm
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 9.665y - http://www.webwizforums.com

Topic: Another request for advice on the best family boat

Posted By: jdbg
Subject: Another request for advice on the best family boat
Date Posted: 10 Mar 11 at 4:52pm

I am in my early fifties and reasonably fit. I am looking to introduce my children, aged 13 and 10, to sailing. After doing research on the manufacturer web-sites I had decided to get a Topper Magno (second hand if possible), but then came to these forums, where the boat gets quite a bit of stick. I am trying to work out whether people are judging it too harshly, maybe because it is plastic, or whether it really is a boat to avoid.

To summarise my requirements:

- I don't want to leave one of the children on the shore, so would want to sail it with the 3 of us

- At the moment, my son (10) is quite nervous of open water, so I wanted something reasonably stable

- I would want to sail it initially on a lake (Whitlingham Broad), but later off the North Norfolk coast

- I want it to be light enough that I can handle it onshore on my own easily

- I want to do as little maintenance as possible, so definitely not a wooden boat

- It would be nice to be able to sail it single-handed

- It would good to feel that the boat would be able to cater for a bit more excitement as the children got older. I learned to sail in a Tideway, at about the same age as my children are now, but quite soon I was wanting more from a boat.

Having read previous forum posts, it would seem that people really like the Laser 2000, which seems a possibility, although it is GRP, so presumably may need more careful looking after. This hadn't come up on my radar when doing research. Is it no longer in production? What would be the good points of the Laser 2000 compared to the Topper Magno?

Replies:

Posted By: winging it
Date Posted: 10 Mar 11 at 5:03pm

The laser 2000 is a good boat, though I'm not sure I'd want to single hand one. It is clearly a well thought through design - everything is very simple and easy to use and maintain - it is nippy if breezy, but still pretty stable, and certainly spacious, with lots of room under the boom. it is very much still in production. Two instructors here at Hunts have them, for family sailing and for racing, as does their SI (me) who is in her very late 40s and reasonably fit. If you want to come down to Hunts (between Cambridge and St Ives) to try one out, drop me a pm. I might be selling mine, but I've got quite fond of it so I might be keeping it!

Nessa

-------------
the same, but different...

Posted By: winging it
Date Posted: 10 Mar 11 at 5:04pm

and I'm not a fan of the magno - all the toper range of bigger boats seem a bit crude and plasticky...just my opnion.

-------------
the same, but different...

Posted By: asterix
Date Posted: 10 Mar 11 at 5:38pm

the L2000 is a really good boat, it is still in production and there are loads of them. It is also a very friendly class - there is a lot of information at http://www.laser2000.org.uk/ - http://www.laser2000.org.uk/

It is stable, and will take three especially if two are children. It can be reasonably fast and of course will capsize (like any dinghy) but not if you sail it conservatively. Definately try one out

Posted By: radixon
Date Posted: 11 Mar 11 at 8:54am

Could I add something in here...

Have your kids stepped foot in a boat and understand what goes on? If they do then great, but from your original post you say you want to "introduce" them to sailing.

i like a fair few on here are sailing instructors and would recommend you pop along to Whitlingham OEC ( http://www.whitlinghamoec.co.uk/ - http://www.whitlinghamoec.co.uk/ ) to try out sailing as a family. According to their site you can "try a wayfarer" as a family and have an instructor in the boat as well, they will be able to give you the intro needed for the family before spending money on a boat that the kids will not like. The other courses available also introduce the kids to sailing (normally run in holidays) to give them experience and knowloedge so they know what to do and are not always learning from you.

As for boats, the Laser 2000 is a great boat and is normally lighter to handle than plasitc ones, as for maintanence, there is not a lot in it, if you handle it with care, it will treat you well. If you want to stop, carry and anchor.

Boat choice also depends on budget. I would recommend seeing the boats up close rather than relying on pictures and websites.

-------------

Posted By: Late starter
Date Posted: 12 Mar 11 at 8:48pm

I've got nothing against the Magno as such, but many of us who have sailed dinghies for a long time tend to conclude that the bigger "tupperware" type boats that many of the big manufacturers are pushing now aren't actually that pleasant to sail. Yes they have their place in sailing life, eg perhaps as a hire boat at a training centre where their general indestructability is useful, but for most other uses many more traditional classes will offer a better sailing experience and probably at less cost too.

Re the Laser2000 - nice boat, lighter than equivalent sized tupperware boats, but there are plenty of alternatives around too. The best advice is to find a local club you like, and look at, talk about, and sail some of the boats that are sailed there. I've seen so many people join our club having bought the latest and greatest plastic fantastic, sail it for a season, then sell it at a substantial loss as they realise they should have bought something more suitable for the water in the first place.

Posted By: kfz
Date Posted: 13 Mar 11 at 6:07pm

Some good advice here, but not sure the original poster is around to read it.....

-------------
GP14 Fleet Captain
Liverpool Sailing Club

http://www.liverpoolsailingclub.org/ - Liverpool SC

Posted By: jdbg
Date Posted: 14 Mar 11 at 10:45am

Firstly, thanks for all of the advice - it is much appreciated.

Secondly, sorry for going quiet, but I have been away over the weekend - my daughter is keen on dogs, so we took her to Crufts for a birthday treat!

Following Richard's post, I have been in contact with Whitlingham Outdoor Centre. As he suggested, they can meet my immediate needs. I was also pleasantly surprised to find out that, following a competency test, they will hire out a boat to me, even though I don't have any recent RYA qualifications. Admittedly, they won't let me take out the children, as everyone aboard has to be competent, but it does add an extra dimension.

If the children love it and want to do more, then hopefully I will return to the dilemma of which boat to buy in the future.

Thanks again,

Jonathan