Will you be able to afford to tow in 2009
Printed From: Yachts and Yachting Online
Category: General
Forum Name: Banter
Forum Discription: For all those non-sailing related discussions
URL: http://www.yachtsandyachting.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=4038
Printed Date: 18 Aug 25 at 2:05am Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 9.665y - http://www.webwizforums.com
Topic: Will you be able to afford to tow in 2009
Posted By: Scooby_simon
Subject: Will you be able to afford to tow in 2009
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 12:49pm
Thanks to Mr Darling road fund will be going up in 2009 for most cars that we might use for towing!
Road fund http://petitions.pm.gov.uk/UNFAIR-VED/ - petition
------------- Wanna learn to Ski - PM me..
|
Replies:
Posted By: Webmuppet
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 1:30pm
Whilst I would consider myself one of the very last people on earth to defend anything done by Mr Darling ( and I have signed the petition above)...........doesn't this depend on what you use to tow your boat about. I remember contributing to a thread on this forum which discussed what people used to tow their boats and being surprised to find that a lot of people use small family cars rather than "Gas Guzzling Monsters"
Nigel
------------- I am the milkman of human kindness, I will leave an extra pint (Billy Bragg)
Graduate 2530 'Galaxy'
|
Posted By: radixon
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 1:33pm
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2008/03/12/ncars112.xml - http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2008/03 /12/ncars112.xml
Gives you some idea if you have a new car. As for me, I havn't a clue with my Focus 1.8
-------------
|
Posted By: radixon
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 1:40pm
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/EDITORIAL/car_page_content/41183.html - http://www.autotrader.co.uk/EDITORIAL/car_page_content/41183 .html
This one is a simplified and easier to understand. Now just trying to work out what band my car falls into.
The thing is, to be able to tow anything you need something with some ooommpphh. A Laser is light, but Two Lasers or the 200 is noticable. As for towing a Cat, you need som power to get up hills. Shame this has to be done, we are all conned really.
Why is the Toyota Hybrid car the only one available as standard when we are all meant to go green.
Sailing is a green sport (unlike the P1 series) but Mr Darling is hindering us enjoying ourselves.
-------------
|
Posted By: ellistine
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 1:52pm
Here's another. Even narrows down to the edition of the model of the make!
http://www.parkers.co.uk/cars/road-tax/ - http://www.parkers.co.uk/cars/road-tax/
|
Posted By: Jamie600
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 1:57pm
Just playing devils advocate, but suppose in future any car with a bit of poke is taxed off the road, I'm sure we'd still manage. As Webmuppet said, for most boats a small car is adequete. I've towed two Lasers with a 1.2 Nova and while it wasn't very fast we got there.
I've only had a quick scan through the table but it would appear that the changes only apply to 2001 cars or newer, so surely you can get round it by either having a smaller car or if you need a more powerful one, buy a 2000 model.
Having said all that it is infuriating having your lifestyle and purchasing choices limited by the government, especially when they are blatently just trying to grab extra tax and probably don't give a monkeys about the environment!
------------- RS600 1001
|
Posted By: Chris Bridges
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 2:09pm
Not looking good for the younger people who can't afford a bigger engined car.. Once I can drive I would be borrowing my parents but chances are they will sell it now or make me pay the tax if they keep it for me to tow my boat around! 
Although someone I know manages to pull a 2000 with a Yaris quite easily..
------------- 49er GBR735 (for sale) - Rutland SC
|
Posted By: tack'ho
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 2:11pm
Good God man are you suggesting that this bunch of thieving good for nothing hypocritical oxygen wasting gits would for one moment use convinient excuses such as binge drinking and the environment to wringe yet more money out of us, so they can spunk it away on social inclusion officers, fact finding trips and fancy government office buildings....NO I won't hear a word against them
------------- I might be sailing it, but it's still sh**e!
|
Posted By: ratface
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 2:24pm
woo \o/ the mothers new car only just has a slight increase  and all our other cars we own strangely do not get affected.(3, 4 if u include the motorhome)
and all this just as i'm weeks off from learning to drive 
just a thought. could we sailors try to make car centers let us take the car for a spin with the boat on the back, just to make sure it will tow 
------------- http://www.blym.org.uk/ - BLYM
http://www.blym.org.uk/hydrs/index.htm - Hertfordshire Sailing team
Uk-Cherub 2644
Laser 4000 -4089
|
Posted By: Charlie
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 3:12pm
Well i'm not too bothered as my car was built before 2001, so no increase in tax for me, lucky really as i'm sure a 2.8 beemer would probably be hit hard, but it does making getting down to the coast an absolute breeze!
------------- Finn GBR 657 - Blown It
Laser 164635
Planet Earth: 30% Land, 70% race course!
|
Posted By: Jamie600
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 3:42pm
Thinking long term though, assuming this policy stays in place, we will all fall foul of it one day. Cars don't last forever.
------------- RS600 1001
|
Posted By: Chris Bridges
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 3:46pm
Originally posted by Jamie600
Thinking long term though, assuming this policy stays in place, we will all fall foul of it one day. Cars don't last forever.
|
Well you will not need to worry, you could tow your 30kg with a Ford Ka! 
------------- 49er GBR735 (for sale) - Rutland SC
|
Posted By: radixon
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 5:42pm
KA's can't be fitted with a towbar!!!
My car is in one of the higher bands   wish I didnt look at that website now.
Right, ebay here it comes!
-------------
|
Posted By: Chris Bridges
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 5:52pm
Posted By: ASok
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 5:56pm
I need a big car to tow the dart. By the time you factor in the boat weight, all the gear in the trailor box and overcome the drag when you're too lazy to take the tramp off - it does take some ooompf to get up to my 85mph cruising speed
Also, I could never sleep in the back of a small hatchback at open or TT events!!
-------------
|
Posted By: Jamie600
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 5:56pm
I'm going to sound like an anorak now but the Ka is one of the only, if not the only, car that you cannot legally fit a towbar to. When Ford brought it out they never specified a towing capacity or fitted mounting points so even if you had one made to fit you would be breaking some EU regulation.
I only know because I was thinking of buying one years ago, nearly did til I priced up towbars and found this out, so I went for a Peugeot 106 instead
------------- RS600 1001
|
Posted By: Kudlinski
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 6:03pm
going to be interesting for my transit then, especially as I cant not tow. although the plan was to sell my transit at the end of this year and buy a big engined 4x4 may not happen now
------------- RS400 866
RS300 381
|
Posted By: JimC
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 6:13pm
Is this a good place to mention that the International Canoe class have just voted to reduce the minimum *all up* weight to 50kg, which means you could almost tow one with a pushbike...
|
Posted By: Merlinboy
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 6:31pm
You cant tow with some of the alloy chassis Audis as well!!!! Which is not good!
I worked ofr Ford for a while and didnt know you couldnt tow with a KA!!!!
-------------
|
Posted By: Chris Bridges
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 6:36pm
Originally posted by Merlinboy
You cant tow with some of the alloy chassis Audis as well!!!! Which is not good!
I worked ofr Ford for a while and didnt know you couldnt tow with a KA!!!!
|
Is that Audi thing new? Also which models have alloy chasis? As they are about to get an Audi for towing..
------------- 49er GBR735 (for sale) - Rutland SC
|
Posted By: Kudlinski
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 6:38pm
the discovery has to be the ultimate towing car in my opinion.
------------- RS400 866
RS300 381
|
Posted By: Merlinboy
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 6:48pm
Well the TT deffinately, i also heard the A8 couldnt, but one of our club members had a towbar fitted anyway! (they had to drill!) Its not a new thing been around for a while! I think the A8 was 06 plate! Dont hold me to this as i'm not 100% sure if your buying one though i would check with your Audi dealer first!
-------------
|
Posted By: radixon
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 6:58pm
Surely you could put a moth on a car roof rack legally as it would be under the weight limit for the bars. You just wont be able to fit your sails in it with all your other kit!
-------------
|
Posted By: ColH
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 7:02pm
Its a while since I towed with anything less than 3.2 litres - can't imagine having to use a car where you might actually be able to tell you're towing something....
-------------
|
Posted By: Merlinboy
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 7:10pm
It depends on the roof weight limit ffor the car, i roof rack my IC everywhere no probs but that is just over the limit!!!
-------------
|
Posted By: Chris Bridges
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 7:14pm
Originally posted by radixon
Surely you could put a moth on a car roof rack legally as it would be under the weight limit for the bars. You just wont be able to fit your sails in it with all your other kit! |
Quite a few turned up to the Tiger on roof racks, actually looked more practical apart from the drag factor... The ones with a road trailer look really odd, being so small!
------------- 49er GBR735 (for sale) - Rutland SC
|
Posted By: timeintheboat
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 7:17pm
So if I had a new fuel efficient clean burning car I pay more than for a dirty old car. How green is that?
I am increasingly coming around to thinking that the way to go is old banger that's done all it's depreciating, 3rd party insurance - run it unti it drops - throw it away and get another. Some of the old bangers coming through now are pretty reliable. Merc estate here I come....
With the price of fuel as it there is a stronger case for double stackers and sharing the fuels costs. Mind you with a double stacker, 4 in the car and all the sailing gear, tents etc you are going to need something that is large and has grunt. Merc estate here I come....
------------- Like some other things - sailing is more enjoyable when you do it with someone else
|
Posted By: Jamie600
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 7:19pm
I wish I could cartop mine but it's got a one-piece mast so I think it may be a bit too long for safety
------------- RS600 1001
|
Posted By: bert
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 7:37pm
I have a Renualt grand Espace & this will rise in tax by £90 but if I attend 1 open meeting and sleep in the van ( which is the reason i brought it ) then i will save the extra, The van will still tow a double stacker & return 32MPG when towing ( diesel ) & when I refit the seats all 7 then it back back to normal.
Nowever I also think that the threiving b*a*sta*ards in cloud 9 land should be told that WE pay for their Goverment cars,drivers,houses,expences NOT them & when WE lose our jobs WE do not get payed a years wages as compension to allow US to get back in to the swing of life after losing a job like they do.
If we did such a bad job as Brown did and put the country in the red to the levels he has I DOUTH THAT WE WOULD HAVE BEEN PROMOTED & BE GIVEN THE TOP JOB.
Sorry for the spelling mistake -spell check not working
Just my 2P`s worth.
------------- Phantom 1181
AC-227 IC 304
blaze / halo 586
|
Posted By: jeffers
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 7:42pm
Just looked at my 2 modes of transport, the Citroed stays at £120 (from what I can see) 2.0 HDi 11bhp, plenty for towing most dinghies and double stackers around.
The Corsa 1.2 that we have as a run about actually goes down!
The Citroen turns in around 56Mpg on a run even with the boat on the roof. The Corsa doesnt get used for things like that!
Just means you need think carefully about what you tow with. Don;t forget you have to drive at a lower spped when towing anyway so is there really any point using the biggest engined car you can lay your hands on!
Just my 2p as always!
------------- Paul
----------------------
D-Zero GBR 74
|
Posted By: Chris Bridges
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 7:44pm
Sailors Uprising against Brown brewing on Y&Y 
------------- 49er GBR735 (for sale) - Rutland SC
|
Posted By: radixon
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 8:08pm
Yep.
There is a classic example in this CO2 thing with the new London Low Emmission Zone thing, AKA LEZ. If you have a stinking 2 Ltr Diesel Old banger polluting the atmoshpere your free cos your a car. If you drive a 51 reg Transit or VW Transporter van, you have to pay what will be £100 a day come 2010. This sucks really.
As for my "polluting" focus, I might change to an Espace thats cheaper, and means I too can use it as a multivehicle!!
-------------
|
Posted By: Ross
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 8:29pm
Register your car as a mini cab!
------------- Ross
If you can't carry it, don't sail it!
|
Posted By: JimC
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 8:31pm
Originally posted by Jamie600
I wish I could cartop mine but it's got a one-piece mast so I think it may be a bit too long for safety |
Can't be that long...
|
Posted By: Scooby_simon
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 8:41pm
Thinking I might well the Scooby, Buy an older RS4 and a vintage Proka as I'll pay less road tax.
Feckin govt.
------------- Wanna learn to Ski - PM me..
|
Posted By: tmoore
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 9:01pm
Originally posted by JimC
Originally posted by Jamie600
I wish I could cartop mine but it's got a one-piece mast so I think it may be a bit too long for safety | Can't be that long... |
im sure it would be ok if you were careful, a guy drove up from hayling island with a nice new shiny rs300 mast on roof racks (in one piece) when i broke my old one.
possibly an 18ft skiff mast would be rather large. . . . 
------------- Landlocked in Africa
RS300 - 410
Firefly F517 - Nutshell
Micro Magic RC yacht - Eclipse
|
Posted By: timnoyce
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 9:43pm
I was a bit worried when I heard the news on the radio earlier but luckily my car has only gone up by £15! A similar spec'd Cooper S has gone up by well over £100. £550 in the first year! Madness. Not only do they rape you for tax on fuel with your 'performance car' they decide to stick it in again for the vehicle tax!
------------- http://www.facebook.com/bearfootdesign - BEARFOOT DESIGN
Cherub 2648 - Comfortably Numb
|
Posted By: Wrighty
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 9:47pm
I converted my 4x4 to LPG and the goverment gave me £15 back, now £195 a year, I get 22mpg towing at 46 pence a litre. If you say diesel is 114 by me the thats 114/46 x 22mph thats 54mpg towing and green as well.
Should get my £1600 back in two years or 20000 miles, my volvo paid for its conversion in 12 months and I still have it, Iv done 70000 miles on lpg with my volvo.?
------------- Wrighty
|
Posted By: JimC
Date Posted: 13 Mar 08 at 11:01pm
Originally posted by tmoore
]im sure it would be ok if you were careful, a guy drove up from hayling island with a nice new shiny rs300 mast on roof racks (in one piece) when i broke my old one. |
I've just been trying to research the law and not winning.
If I read right up to 1m each end doesn't need any special treatment at all.
Up to 2m each end appears to be fine provided the ends are clearly visible (rags etc).
Beyond that you get into special markers and things.
|
Posted By: Wes
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 9:31am
What's the problem? You drive a 300hp, four wheel drive car and have to pay more in running costs than a little old lady in her micra shocker?
You don't need a powerful car to tow, (I used a 205 to tow gliders at 600kg+ all over Europe for a years) you can barely drive it quickly because of the road congestion, why worry? Get something economical instead!
Of course, you can just ignore that advice and get a van that you can sleep / cook and take all your kit safely stowed and a TT for the week like me, but then I won't be the one complaining that it costs more than a micra!
Me on the way to a Taikwon-do tournament oops!

|
Posted By: Merlinboy
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 9:44am
The whole congestion charge/road tax/fuel debate is one that really works me up! Only 24% of road taxes and fuel duties gets put back into our roads to make them a safer place for motorists!!!!! that means that 76% is going into a pot to subsidize Europe, The lazy benefited culture of todays Britain and the fat self serving pigs at Westminster!!! What the government are forgetting is that if they do eventually kill off the 4x4 market (which is coming) then 10,000 people will be made unemployed at the land rover plant in the UK, probably most of the Jaguar workers too!! Apparently also the only car that falls into the "free" road tax bracket is a VW polo "Blue motion" now i don't know about anyone else here but i couldn't fit my whole family and dog in one of those poxy little things!!! I certainly couldn't take them all away with a boat on the back!!!!!!! I'm one of the many people that is part of a 2.4 family, meaning i probably drive a Mondeo or Renault espace etc. (i don't) and these cars are also going to get nailed under the taxable emissions as well!
mmmmmfffffffffff!!!!!!!!!!!!!
-------------
|
Posted By: Charlie
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 9:56am
Well there's a lot more than the VW Polo thing that falls into the free tax thing my last car did, it was a two seater sports car, probably chucking out a fair bit of Co2, but it was made before 1973 so my triumph spitfire was tax free! Any car made before that date pays no road tax and there were plenty of big powerful cars that i'm sure would have no trouble towing if you needed to.
------------- Finn GBR 657 - Blown It
Laser 164635
Planet Earth: 30% Land, 70% race course!
|
Posted By: iwsmithuk
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 10:11am
Really.
Grow up a bit.
Nobody needs large fast powerful cars. A modest size car and engine will easily tow any Dinghy (I use a 1.9 deisel Polo). OK so you can't go at ridiculous speeds BUT there are these little things called speed limits anyway.
If you want to race cars....fine...take up car racing BUT do it on a track, NOT the road.
Have any of you had to deal with the aftermath of high speed car crashes? I have and it's not pretty. Speed limits are there for a reason.
Polluter pays. Fine by me.
|
Posted By: Scooby_simon
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 10:19am
Originally posted by Wes
What's the problem? You drive a 300hp, four wheel drive car and have to pay more in running costs than a little old lady in her micra shocker?
You don't need a powerful car to tow, (I used a 205 to tow gliders at 600kg+ all over Europe for a years) you can barely drive it quickly because of the road congestion, why worry? Get something economical instead!
Of course, you can just ignore that advice and get a van that you can sleep / cook and take all your kit safely stowed and a TT for the week like me, but then I won't be the one complaining that it costs more than a micra!
Me on the way to a Taikwon-do tournament oops!

|
My point is that this tax will hit people who CANNOT afford to change their car; they saved up hard for their new car and bought it a couple of years ago. NOW they may not have a 300+BHP car but they may not be able to afford to change it.
What hacks me off is that the govt has punished people for decisions the may have made 7 years ago.
I can afford the extra money, it just means that my extra 230 quid will be “spent” by the Govt. supporting the idle, or unwilling to work who appear to be the most important people in our country
The 230 quid will not be spent on something useful.
I do feel upset that as I do only about 7K miles a year, the effect of the change in my road fund is the same as if darling had added 18pence per litre of petrol:
Miles PA |
7000 |
|
MPG |
25 |
|
Gallons |
280 |
|
convertion to L |
4.55 |
|
L |
1274 |
|
|
|
|
increase |
230 |
GBP |
Increase / L |
0.180534 |
GBP |
Rip-off
------------- Wanna learn to Ski - PM me..
|
Posted By: NickA
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 11:48am
My car costs £165 a year to tax now and will eventually cost £180. £15 a year = £1.25 a month. Come ON folks, this is peanuts.
At 150BHP it will happily tow anything I'd want it to, certainly at the 60mph legal towing speed! In fact the 80kg all up V3000 + lightweight trailer barely registers as being on the back of the car (though the fuel consumption goes up a lot).
The torquiest car I ever drove was a 2 litre TDi Skoda Octavia estate which has a boot you could sleep in and would have towed a BUS; that will cost LESS to tax.
What's all this whinging about?
My only objection is that Mr Darling will probably spend the extra money on extra expenses for MPs and tax breaks for stock brokers!
------------- Javelin 558
Contender 2574
|
Posted By: Jamie600
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 12:13pm
After all this business of "we're killing the planet with all these gas guzzling cars, let's tax them off the road and save some tree", I was very suprised to find out on the news this morning that there is a place in Derbyshire that emits five times the CO2 that Heathrow airport does.
The peat bogs in the Peak District National Park
So it begs the question, do we really make that much difference in the great scheme of things? My guess would be no, so it's even more galling to see all these stealth taxes in the name of saving the environment
------------- RS600 1001
|
Posted By: tack'ho
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 12:53pm
Originally posted by iwsmithuk
Really.
Grow up a bit.
Nobody needs large fast powerful cars. A modest size car and engine will easily tow any Dinghy (I use a 1.9 deisel Polo). OK so you can't go at ridiculous speeds BUT there are these little things called speed limits anyway.
If you want to race cars....fine...take up car racing BUT do it on a track, NOT the road.
Have any of you had to deal with the aftermath of high speed car crashes? I have and it's not pretty. Speed limits are there for a reason.
Polluter pays. Fine by me.
|
A, Wes.....it that your wifes car???
B, Above......Speed doesn't kill, inappropriate speed kills. There are times when it is safe to do 90mph there are other times on the same strech of road when 30mph is too fast. The governments insitence on using discretion free speed cameras rather than thinking Policeman to enforce traffic regulation is yet another shining example of their idiotic Stalinist agenda. Gotta hit them targets!!
ps. Yes the reason for the National speed limit is the Oil shortage caused by the Egyptian Government closing the Suez Canal, can't wait till they sort that one out, it's been dragging on a bit now!!
------------- I might be sailing it, but it's still sh**e!
|
Posted By: jeffers
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 12:58pm
Originally posted by Jamie600
After all this business of "we're killing the planet with all these gas guzzling cars, let's tax them off the road and save some tree", I was very suprised to find out on the news this morning that there is a place in Derbyshire that emits five times the CO2 that Heathrow airport does.
The peat bogs in the Peak District National Park
So it begs the question, do we really make that much difference in the great scheme of things? My guess would be no, so it's even more galling to see all these stealth taxes in the name of saving the environment |
The difference is that we cannot do anything about the Peat bogs. We can however do something about Heathrow sirport and the cars we drive. I live in a small town just outside Peterborough. We are just on the edge of the fens so it is FLAT. There are very few off road tracks that people have to drive down but there is a disproportion amount of chelsea tractors round here.
Why? School run mum! They would argue that they need their 3L 4WD to take their darlin 2 children to school. I would argue differently. People managed with large estate cars before chelsea tractors/people carriers came along and they would manage again (perhaps walk the 1/4 mile between their house and the school gates). I can honestly say that if I lived opposite the school I would make a point of standing outside my house and ensuring that my driveway was not blocked. Then in the afternoons from around 2pm they all appear again and sit there for an hour with the engine running so they can have the radio on and read their book. Again rather than walk the short distance. Some may argue that they work so they have to drive but from what I have seen most of the drive straight back home again. Given the hassle of getting all the kids into the car, safely strapped in and then finding somewhere to park (or just abandon in the street as someone did in front of me the other morning) and going home, I would guess that walking would probably take them 10 minutes per day more.....
OK rant over...it is a pet subject of mine but anyone who lives near a school knows the chaos that takes place every day. There was even a fight between 2 mums over a parking space in a nearby town.
Outside the school near me there are no parking restrictions that are in force from 8.30am to 9.30 am and then again from 2pm to 3.30pm which are consistently ignored but never policed. My idea would be to have a 0.5 mile parking exclusion around all schools between the drop off/pick up times (except for residents). It may encourage some of our obsese teenagers to get off their lazy behinds and put the nintendo/gameboy/xbox down for a minute and get some exercise!
Right rant is actually over now!
Just my 2p...(as always)
------------- Paul
----------------------
D-Zero GBR 74
|
Posted By: ASok
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 1:18pm
Originally posted by iwsmithuk
Polluter pays. Fine by me.
|
The point is that the polluter is already paying extra at the petrol station. These stealth taxes packaged up as green initiatives are an outrageous method of stinging the tax payer - again. Well at least we can help those poor MP's sort out another kitchen refit and TV.
The whole green issue is being cleverly spun to make people think that the CO2 issue is one that is killing the atmosphere. Anyone that has done GCSE biology will undertand the importance of CO2 in the most basic of life cycles. A zero carbon society will not work.
-------------
|
Posted By: gary
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 1:41pm
Originally posted by tack'ho
Originally posted by iwsmithuk
Have any of you had to deal with the aftermath of high speed car crashes? I have and it's not pretty. Speed limits are there for a reason.
|
B, Above......Speed doesn't kill, inappropriate speed kills. There are times when it is safe to do 90mph there are other times on the same strech of road when 30mph is too fast. The governments insitence on using discretion free speed cameras rather than thinking Policeman to enforce traffic regulation is yet another shining example of their idiotic Stalinist agenda. Gotta hit them targets!!
|
tack'ho's right. Speed kills in built up area's, but not on the open road. Out there mistakes kill - do you run up the back of someone on a motorway because you're driving too fast, or is it because you didn't leave enough room.
And yes, I have had to deal with the aftermath of large accidents, and in my experience you don't have to be going fast to create a right mess. The vast majority are caused by something other than excessive speed. The speed is just one of many factors.
|
Posted By: iwsmithuk
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 1:44pm
Originally posted by tack'ho
Originally posted by iwsmithuk
Really.
Grow up a bit.
Nobody needs large fast powerful cars. A modest size car and engine will easily tow any Dinghy (I use a 1.9 deisel Polo). OK so you can't go at ridiculous speeds BUT there are these little things called speed limits anyway.
If you want to race cars....fine...take up car racing BUT do it on a track, NOT the road.
Have any of you had to deal with the aftermath of high speed car crashes? I have and it's not pretty. Speed limits are there for a reason.
Polluter pays. Fine by me.
|
A, Wes.....it that your wifes car???
B, Above......Speed doesn't kill, inappropriate speed kills. There are times when it is safe to do 90mph there are other times on the same strech of road when 30mph is too fast. The governments insitence on using discretion free speed cameras rather than thinking Policeman to enforce traffic regulation is yet another shining example of their idiotic Stalinist agenda. Gotta hit them targets!!
ps. Yes the reason for the National speed limit is the Oil shortage caused by the Egyptian Government closing the Suez Canal, can't wait till they sort that one out, it's been dragging on a bit now!!
|
Quite right, it was done to reduce fuel use in a time of shortage.
Lower speed limits = less fuel used.
Surely a good thing?
Taxing cars that use unnecessarily large amounts of fuel, discourages the purchase and use of these cars. Again, surely a good thing?
|
Posted By: Wes
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 1:51pm
Originally posted by tack'ho
A, Wes.....it that your wifes car???
|
Cheeky bleeder!
I just have asperations of being a hair dresser!
|
Posted By: Merlinboy
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 2:10pm
I can see why labour keep getting into power! Most of the forum-tees are left wingers!!! I work BLOODY hard for my money and i just don't see any of the benefits coming back to me, apart from a small increase in child allowance! Has anyone else heard today about the parlamont expenses row? This is where your extra road tax is going politicians can claim back Mortgage payments and have there London pads fully fited out under expenses (ie they get a £750 budget for a TV.)
We live in a society where people are meant to have freedom of choice, if you want a fast car and can aford it then great! I have no problems with people that drive things like that paying for it! the problem i have is with normall Joe public like me having to pay an increased Tax for driving a bloody 1.8 mondeo!! The problem is that the increased taxs arnt moving in line with vehicle manufacturers developments, car manf. are spending Billions trying to develop low Co2 output vehicles but it just cant happen over night!!!
-------------
|
Posted By: iwsmithuk
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 2:20pm
Originally posted by gary
Out there mistakes kill - do you run up the back of someone on a motorway because you're driving too fast, or is it because you didn't leave enough room.
And yes, I have had to deal with the aftermath of large accidents, and in my experience you don't have to be going fast to create a right mess. The vast majority are caused by something other than excessive speed. The speed is just one of many factors.
|
Quite right, mistakes kill. BUT the faster you are going when you, or someone else, makes a mistake then the less likely it is you will be able to avoid the consequences of that mistake.
Speed may be "just one of many factors" but it is undeniably a factor.
It's not rocket science (or whatever it is clever people do these days).
|
Posted By: iwsmithuk
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 2:25pm
Originally posted by turnturtle
Ask anyone in car sales and they would say that most new car buyers have already got a very clear idea of what they want before they even walk into a showroom
|
So surely the job of any responsable government is to influence what they want in a manner which benefits society as a whole.
Tax 'em hard and they won't want gas guzzlers.
|
Posted By: Merlinboy
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 2:36pm
Originally posted by iwsmithuk
Originally posted by turnturtle
[QUOTE=iwsmithuk]
Ask anyone in car sales and they would say that most new car buyers have already got a very clear idea of what they want before they even walk into a showroom
|
So surely the job of any responsible government is to influence what they want in a manner which benefits society as a whole.
Tax 'em hard and they won't want gas guzzlers.
I think your missing the point here, taxing Gas Guzzlers is all very well and good, but people need to understand that "most" Family cars fall into the Gas Guzzler category (not class G but still a sizable increase)
Digressing slightly i would have no problems paying these stealth taxes at all, if it was safe for my Wife and daughter to walk down the street at night or the fact that in a few years my daughter will have to speak polish as a second language. The trouble is it is just take take take with nothing back!
I have had enough of it, if i wanted to live in a society like Cuba i would move there!!
I say VOTE MERLINBOY at your next election! Out with the scroungers! No road tax! and an official bank holiday to celebrate beer and boobs! Amen to that!
|
-------------
|
Posted By: iwsmithuk
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 2:44pm
Originally posted by turnturtle
True it is the job of responsble government to influece, however you miss my point; most people in 'gas guzzlers' will just pay and not really give a sh*t... how does that promote the green agenda?
From the same budget we see beer going up 4p a pint... erm, beer's going to be going up a bit anyway with the market price of cereals on the increase, do the government think this is the answer to a so-called social problem of 'binge drinking'.
Besides, it's a fruitless exercise in curbing excessive alcohol consumption, there's plenty of margin to be squeezed from the supermarkets and chain pubs responsible for these 'irresponsible promotions' before 4p per pint will affect typical consumer price levels.
|
Tax 'em harder. Sooner or later they will "give a sh*t".
Now tax on beer.......that's another story. A tragedy of truly monumental proportions.
To the barricades my friends!!
|
Posted By: iwsmithuk
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 3:06pm
Originally posted by turnturtle
Nope you'll just get Sweden Syndrome, where it becomes pointless to seek out a higher paid domestic career and your country's economy will lack any sense of opportunity for would-be entrepreneurs... they're over taxed on beer too, but I guess all the hotties they have make up for it.

|
Ah, but there is a middle (dare I say "third") way. (Runs for cover before lynching by antiBlairites).
This country has really quite lax tax laws/regulations for entrepreneurs/financial intitutions etc, many traditional left wingers would argue too lax, whilst at the same time using tax to influence social issues such as the environment. Plenty of entrapraneurs here, look in any London estate agents window. No Sweden Syndrome here.
Anyway.....
Back to sailing......
|
Posted By: Charlie
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 3:08pm
Yeah i love the way that a topic about cars/taxes has had way more responses in such a short time than the sailing topics!
------------- Finn GBR 657 - Blown It
Laser 164635
Planet Earth: 30% Land, 70% race course!
|
Posted By: Scooby_simon
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 3:17pm
Are you sure about that?
A fair few opf my mates who work in The City / for themselves or who are successful are looking at leaving the country.
I pay so much tax and get so little for it I really wonder where all the money goes.
The NHS is falling to bits thanks to financial interfering by the govt. They give masses of money and then force the NHS to spend it in a way that makes not sense at all, on staff they do not need and for meeting targets that make no sense at all. People are leaving the NHS in drives (my wife works in the NHS and it is at breaking point).
The infrastructure of the country is falling to bits, we are overrun by people who do not work – not because there is no work, but because they cannot be bothered and can earn more “on the social”.
The govt does not crack down on crime, caring more for the feelings of the robbers and scum than those who feel the effects of crime.
I would say we have a fair sized section of the country that has gone beyond the “Sweden Syndrome” and have moved onto the “lazy fecker supported by the govt” syndrome.
Labour have been very clever, they have created a sub-set of society who are totally dependent on this version of the labour ethos of govt. – Tax to the hilt and spend like water (and in this govt’s case waste as much money as possible).
Would you stop voting for someone who gave you money for doing nothing?
------------- Wanna learn to Ski - PM me..
|
Posted By: Roger
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 3:20pm

For 155 days of the year, every penny earned by the average UK resident was taken to support government expenditures. In fact its not till 3rd June this year that you will start earning for yourself, everything you earn before that date goes to the government.
This figure includes taxation of all sorts and not just income tax.
Each of these little tax increases adds further to this figure, and the current government certainly seems to be of the opinion they can manipulate the population by increasing the tax burden in certain areas.
|
Posted By: iwsmithuk
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 3:24pm
Originally posted by turnturtle
Absoultely, yet you advocate 'taxing 'em hard'....
sounds like a plan, but I can also say that the google image search for 'swedish hotties' to illustrate my last post yielded a fine detraction from budgetary analysis.
|
Hard but selective.
|
Posted By: iwsmithuk
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 3:49pm
Originally posted by Merlinboy
I can see why labour keep getting into power! Most of the forum-tees are left wingers!!!
|
Quite the reverse it seems.
|
Posted By: Guests
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 4:10pm
I haven't read the lot, this thread is moving so fast, but I can guess what it's
about.
So just to fuel the fire a bit further in the quest for general peace harmony
and contentment that we are being justly served by our political elite..
Doesn't it give you a nice warm feeling knowing that all those expenses for
the 2nd home - don't attract tax either because they're exempt?
Yes?
|
Posted By: iwsmithuk
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 4:32pm
Originally posted by turnturtle
Scoobs & Roger,
You both have very fair points made, but what's the alternative? How do you reverse the dependency culture without sounding terribly right wing in a society indoctrinated with political correctness?
Personally I have not voted since 1997... and yes I was one of the naive idiots who fell into the trap of seeing 'youth leaders' like Damon Albarn rubbing shoulders with the New Labour massive as a sign that there was positive change afoot.... on reflection what really needed changing, a bit of tory pants down action... pails into insignificance these days with the current sleaze-mongering in whitehall.
A year later and my demographic was sold down the river with tuition fees... something that's progressively got worse/ more expesive and imo, the total antithesis of the egalitarian values the party was founded on.
I enjoyed my uni life to the full and I've spent every working day since trying to earn enough to take Mercutio's attitude towards both our major political parties and their lightweight, crowd-pleasing policies.... seem to get shafted either way.
Maybe it's time to reconsider... alternatively I'll continue to accept some of the benefits that our country offers- reasonable state education where I live, relatively low taxation (compared to similar european economies), fairly supportive of businesses and the self-empoyed and I'll hoepfully continue to earn enough to pay for private cover on the bad things... NHS, income protection, pension (of sorts) etc This leaves the rest of my taxes to be squandered on the idle and inept... and as long as I have as little to do with them as possible, then fine, that's life.
|
Nice.
A little harsh perhaps. But nicely written. I suppose we all get like that after a while. I see a lot of benefit culture every day, often 2nd or 3rd generation who have no intention of ever working. There really isn't an answer.
Incidentally lots of sl*gging off the Poles on here. Not fair. All the ones I've met are hard working honest types just here to earn a wage doing stuff people here can't be arsed to do for the money. Good luck to them.
I do like a good "heated debate" (said in best Caroline Ahern voice).
|
Posted By: iwsmithuk
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 4:49pm
Anyway.......
Like I said a while ago....
Back to sailing!
|
Posted By: Charlie
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 5:05pm
Come on you've got to be impressed by a labour govt that introduces a tax "cut" that means everyone on less than £17,500 is paying more tax, and people above that end up paying less.
I'm not complaining i'm one of the lucky ones above that amount!
------------- Finn GBR 657 - Blown It
Laser 164635
Planet Earth: 30% Land, 70% race course!
|
Posted By: Merlinboy
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 6:02pm
I wasn't sl*gging off the Polish folk, more the immigration trap that we have fallen in to! We used to have polish folk valeting cars and they would work hrs solid. But If the government hadn't let people slip into benefit culture by paying them more benefits then they would have to take the lower skilled jobs like the polish people! To earn enough money to live! Now in any society you will get lazy b**tards, but if you stopped the incentive then these people would have to work, meaning less jobs for immigrants and more money staying in our economy! its impossible for us to have an open door policy with Europe unless A) we switch to the euro and B) The benefit systems are the same where ever you live in the EU!!!!
-------------
|
Posted By: ColH
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 6:34pm
I employ a Polish graduate - works his backside off, doing a skilled job. Had it advertised it for ages before he found us, and in that time no-one British had applied. That's what happens when govt policies balls up the country's technology capabilities and education systems...
-------------
|
Posted By: ColH
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 6:43pm
OK, since the subject has been raised (and some!), I'm confused by this 'gas guzzler' stuff. Surely all modern cars burn petrol in stoichometrically efficient ways these days? So big cars are really only worse polluters because they use a greater amount of petrol for a given distance*. Surely we already have a tax that relates to the amount of CO2 put into the atmosphere - this relates primarily to the actual quantity of fuel consumed and is called fuel duty! Why tax pure ownership of a vehicle when it only actually pollutes according to the amount it is used?
This seems so obvious to me, so what is it that I'm missing..?? 
* edit: cos the bands appear to be measured in g/km, not g/l
-------------
|
Posted By: Chris Bridges
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 7:19pm
Originally posted by Merlinboy
I wasn't sl*gging off the Polish folk, more the immigration trap that we have fallen in to! We used to have polish folk valeting cars and they would work hrs solid. But If the government hadn't let people slip into benefit culture by paying them more benefits then they would have to take the lower skilled jobs like the polish people! To earn enough money to live! Now in any society you will get lazy b**tards, but if you stopped the incentive then these people would have to work, meaning less jobs for immigrants and more money staying in our economy! its impossible for us to have an open door policy with Europe unless A) we switch to the euro and B) The benefit systems are the same where ever you live in the EU!!!! |
I am 16 yet I can still see how stupid benefits are getting.. Its just an easy option for people who are lazy (obviously this isn't the case for all, but I bet it is for a lot..)
Also this might seem slightly harsh but I really don't think imigrants EU or not should be given benefits and free housing... They are just coming in and milking it?
I don't claim to know anything about politics, but it doesn't take much of a brain to see the problems with the benefit/immigration system, slightly worrying when 16 year olds can see that yet the Prime Minister and other government people don't seem to!!
I was going to say something else yet I can't remember what . If I think of it again and it is not too harsh I will say it .
------------- 49er GBR735 (for sale) - Rutland SC
|
Posted By: bert
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 7:56pm
Just a idea on school run mums,
If you have to drive your kids to school then the school is not local to you & as such you should look for a more local school,That hopfully would sort out the problem!
Like jeffer`s i also have a school at the end of the road & they abandon their cars all over the place,So when an old boy was driving at about 15 MPH through the parked cars when one of the kids run out & he stopped in time but was very upset,Then the mum of the kid turn up with her mates & blamed him for nearly knocking her kid over.
Sumthing not right there,
------------- Phantom 1181
AC-227 IC 304
blaze / halo 586
|
Posted By: jeffers
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 8:00pm
Originally posted by turnturtle
Originally posted by jeffers
Why? School run mum! They would argue that they need their 3L 4WD to take their darlin 2 children to school. I would argue differently.
|
I'm sure most 'school run mums' would not argue any such thing, but they might well point out that we live in a free society where the consumer decides what products they want where by and large the free economic rule of supply and demand will set the agendas of the motor car manufacturers for their socio-economic demographic...
Fine tax 'em a bit more if you think it'll make a difference; it won't, they'll pay up and keep driving the chelsea tractors because they believe they are safer and look better than a boring old MPV... besides is there any real proof that a 'mum' in a 4x4 doing 5,000 miles per annum dropping the kids off and going to the tanning salon is really over-polluting? So some are annoying because some park inconsiderately; either way not really justification for hammering all drivers of 4x4s is it?
Police it better and educate the public in the process, as somone with 5 speeding convictions in just over 10 years of driving, I only really took notice when the policeman stopped me and explained why I was getting a ticket... one problem of course, policing via educating drivers costs money, rather than generating it through speed and red route cameras. |
I feel that you may wish to swap the SOME for MOST. That is certainly true round here. Some roads are impassable in the morning because of cars that are literally abandoned whilst the kids are dropped off.
Just my opinion and going on the observations that are around the area in which I live and work.
Don't forget the knock on as well. When I used to commute from Huntingdon to Peterborough (a journey of 26.2 miles door to door) it was noticable when the schools were not in. I could easily knock 10 minutes off this journey purely in the last 4 miles because of less traffic on the roads. It is not just the simple issue but there are the significant knock on effects.
As always just my 2p ;-)
------------- Paul
----------------------
D-Zero GBR 74
|
Posted By: jeffers
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 8:05pm
Originally posted by Chris Bridges
ill see how stupid benefits are getting.. Its just an easy option for people who are lazy (obviously this isn't the case for all, but I bet it is for a lot..)
Also this might seem slightly harsh but I really don't think imigrants EU or not should be given benefits and free housing... They are just coming in and milking it?
I don't claim to know anything about politics, but it doesn't take much of a brain to see the problems with the benefit/immigration system, slightly worrying when 16 year olds can see that yet the Prime Minister and other government people don't seem to!!
I was going to say something else yet I can't remember what . If I think of it again and it is not too harsh I will say it . |
Chris,
I hope more young people your age think the same way. I am of the same opinion. We have to get hard on benefit claimants. I am not saying that all benfits should be cut off after a period of time but for those who are physically fit and able to work should be told that if they do not accept a job they are able and capable of doing then their benefits will be cut off.
For those who live in the area where the BBC programme was film there were interview with both immigrants and local young men on the subject. The immigrants were of the opinion that the work, although hard, paid well and gave them a good standard of living. The young english men (complete with gold neck chains, burberry caps and kappa tracksuits) we 'nah mate I'd rather go collect me giro that work in a field'. They then go and complain that immigrants are taking their jobs....
Roll on the revolution comrades!
   
------------- Paul
----------------------
D-Zero GBR 74
|
Posted By: 29er310
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 8:10pm
Originally posted by Chris Bridges
Also this might seem slightly harsh but I really don't think imigrants EU or not should be given benefits and free housing... They are just coming in and milking it?
|
Please correct me if I am wrong but I was not aware the migrants from inside the EU were able to claim benefits in the UK without citizenship which from what I have heard from a foreign member of my family is pretty hard to come buy. It does depend on what you mean by benefits, for instance the NHS is a public good and in my opinion it should be open to working migrants from the EU.
------------- ----------------------
International 14 GBR1485
29er 310 for sale
Laser 138462 for sale
Optimist 4626 For sale
|
Posted By: Kudlinski
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 8:12pm
I am 18 and agree completely with chris, I am an apprentice and ean £3.95 an hour less than minumum wage. I could probably get more if I was on the doll but whats the point, then people come here just to claim benifits and send there child benefits back home. out of my wages I only get taxed about £10 but is still a considerable amount when I am only earning £140 a week.
------------- RS400 866
RS300 381
|
Posted By: Chris Bridges
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 8:21pm
Did say I don't know much about politics . Your are probably right though.
I meant benefits as in umemployeed and free council housing.
Even if the NHS is pretty rubbish we are lucky to have it, and yea that should be open to migrants but they pay taxes still don't they? So they should be allowed it. If they work like most migrants do, and pay their taxes, of cause they should have it.
I reckon if your just one of the lazy buggers, that has a free house, gets weakly money from the government for sitting on their arse all day and don't pay taxes, now they shouldn't be allowed to use the NHS... Do nothing all day, get fat and then when your diabetic get free health care for being a waster milking the government.. Fair enough if they actually try to get work, but probably most on the doll want to be and have no intention of finding a job.. Even when perfectly capable of it.
If teenagers can get full time jobs over the Summer etc surely they should be able to so what is stopping them??
------------- 49er GBR735 (for sale) - Rutland SC
|
Posted By: radixon
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 8:49pm
Its those that live in the "free housing" get pregnant, smoke and use the NHS and all whilst on the dole. Then teenager gets free house too from having a kid all cos they have nothing to do in live.
Us lot over here have a life, sail every week, work our socks off and pay for the above lazy sods to have the life they do!
(grrr 2p over - for now!!)
-------------
|
Posted By: Chris Bridges
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 8:55pm
Good point, I forgot most of them smoke cigerettes or some other substances.. Habits of cause funded by the dole, putting them into those convenient hospitals that they didn't have to pay for 
i don't understand how it doesn't get boring.. Surely spending all your money on cigerettes, drink and other substances, living in some nasty council flat with no hobbies gets pretty dull!!!
------------- 49er GBR735 (for sale) - Rutland SC
|
Posted By: radixon
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 9:09pm
yep, so they smokea bit more, drink more, then rob/steal/nick etc to fund their other habit that goes alongside their rollies!
-------------
|
Posted By: Kudlinski
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 9:13pm
why would they be bored when they have day time tv lol
------------- RS400 866
RS300 381
|
Posted By: Chris Bridges
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 9:23pm
True, what a barrel of laughs that is... Probably not got a tv license either...
------------- 49er GBR735 (for sale) - Rutland SC
|
Posted By: redback
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 10:49pm
Let's face it we've got to do something to get those big 4x4s off the road. They are gross and a pain for everybody else. Have you tried to park next to them in a multi story or met one coming down a narrow country lane and have you noticed how they wobble across two lanes when going around roundabouts. Most of them are hopeless off road - if you want something effective off road then use a Landrover.
I love a good 4x4 when crossing deserts, fording rivers and exploring logging tracks, but they are inapproprite on tarmac and especially on our crowded roads. I think some people drive them in the miss-guided idea that they are safer however they don't stop as quick as a modern car and having a high centre of gravity they topple over more easily.
Road tax is probably the best way to discourage them since this will not affect farmers very much since they drive effective 4x4s like landrovers which with a 2.5ltr diesel is economical and can better any other 4x4 when off the road.
I used to trail a Scorpion all over the country with a 600cc 35bhp car - that was pushing it, but possible. I now drive a 80bhp lightwieght car which copes very well with a 4000 which is a heavy boat. I once trailed the 4000 non stop to Garda in less than a day - no problem with 97bhp. Big 4x4s are rarely justified.
|
Posted By: JimC
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 11:24pm
Originally posted by Chris Bridges
I don't understand how it doesn't get boring.. Surely spending all your money on cigerettes, drink and other substances, living in some nasty council flat with no hobbies gets pretty dull!!! |
Well it does of course... these people lead more awful lives than you can possibly imagine... And as far as they can see the only way to live better is to steal and deal drugs... This is one appalling society for these people to live in, and there doesn't seem to be any way out..
|
Posted By: 29er310
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 11:27pm
Originally posted by JimC
Originally posted by Chris Bridges
I don't understand how it doesn't get boring.. Surely spending all your money on cigerettes, drink and other substances, living in some nasty council flat with no hobbies gets pretty dull!!! | Well it does of course... these people lead more awful lives than you can possibly imagine... And as far as they can see the only way to live better is to steal and deal drugs... This is one appalling society for these people to live in, and there doesn't seem to be any way out.. |
Spoken like a true lefty
------------- ----------------------
International 14 GBR1485
29er 310 for sale
Laser 138462 for sale
Optimist 4626 For sale
|
Posted By: Merlinboy
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 11:36pm
Originally posted by 29er310
Originally posted by Chris Bridges
Also this might seem slightly harsh but I really don't think immigrants EU or not should be given benefits and free housing... They are just coming in and milking it?
|
Please correct me if I am wrong but I was not aware the migrants from inside the EU were able to claim benefits in the UK without citizenship which from what I have heard from a foreign member of my family is pretty hard to come buy. It does depend on what you mean by benefits, for instance the NHS is a public good and in my opinion it should be open to working migrants from the EU.
|
You are wrong as long as you are a citizen of an EU country you can qualify for residential benefits including Health Service. There have even been instances recently of eastern European migrants claiming child benefit for children that they have back in there father county!!!
Its all so corrupt it stinks!
-------------
|
Posted By: JimC
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 11:50pm
Originally posted by 29er310
Spoken like a true lefty |
First time I've *ever* been called that!
No, if I was a lefty I'd believe that massive state support, state planning etc would be the way to make things better, and I don't believe that works at all. I don't know what does work though: I don't see anywhere in the world that's really cracked the problems.
|
Posted By: tack'ho
Date Posted: 14 Mar 08 at 11:55pm
Originally posted by 29er310
Originally posted by JimC
Originally posted by Chris Bridges
I don't understand how it doesn't get boring.. Surely spending all your money on cigerettes, drink and other substances, living in some nasty council flat with no hobbies gets pretty dull!!! | Well it does of course... these people lead more awful lives than you can possibly imagine... And as far as they can see the only way to live better is to steal and deal drugs... This is one appalling society for these people to live in, and there doesn't seem to be any way out.. |
Spoken like a true lefty
|
Actually he has a point. What we now have in this country is an very materialistic society where we idolise the idol rich. A lot of people who don't have a lot believe they have a right to it but don't see that hard work and graft is the way to achieve it. In short to some extent many of us now want something for nothing. Can anyone here really imagine living the same life as a miner at the turn of the century when there was virtually no social mobility. Until hard work, commitment and resposibilty are placed higher on the agenda than rights and social equality then this will continue to perpetuate. I no more blame someone bought up on a sink estate for choosing the easy option (giro/drug dealing etc) than I blame someone living in a shack in Africa for wanting to get into this country. It is human nature.
Mind you despite what the Daily Mail would have us believe the majority of people in the country a law abiding hard work tax paying folk.
------------- I might be sailing it, but it's still sh**e!
|
Posted By: foaminatthedeck
Date Posted: 15 Mar 08 at 3:53pm
I have been out of work and claimed benifit and its maybe not as easy as people make out; you get very little money and there is load of quite difficult paper work to compleat. The people you talk to had no interest in helping me to find work and just seemed to be there to make life more miserable. I do feel though that if you want it there is nearly always work some where. I feel that after a period of time unemployed rather than get money you should just be given food and basic clothing and get basic living cost paid for, nothing extra. Posisble a bit harsh but I'm fed up of watching a woman on my road send her little s*** of to school with a splif in her mouth. Oh the joys of Plymouth.
As for the car thing I'm just not sure that it will make a difference to towing as I plan to continue with sailing, I'l just cut down on the shandy. We are thinking about getting rid of our second car as things get more expensive (no tow bar on that)
------------- Lark 2170
|
Posted By: Neal_g
Date Posted: 15 Mar 08 at 10:21pm
upping prices p***es everyone off if they really wanted 4x4s off the road just introduce a law to ban them they have for everything else, speed as much as it is plastered about doesnt kill its bad driving at the end of the day.
i'd love to use my car less save the planet all that perhaps i should move closer to work but i cant why as the labour governemnt have held interest rates low which has allowed irresponsible lending meaning house prices have gone through the roof, so now i cant afford a house and soon i wont be able to run my car.
job done i think where do i sign for the dole???
the governement needs the taxes to pay off the northern rock fiasco i live in newcastle and if a bank goes bust it goes bust end of shoudlnt be given help as they were careless dont remeber seeing rover get the same treatment etc
END of the DAY we live in rip off britain i cant call it great anymore as its been spoilt by years of abuse in all areas of governement
rant over
------------- (Redoubt Sc)
Miracle 4040
GP14 13407
Crewsaver phase 2 range now available to buy online on at http://www.gibsonsails.com
|
Posted By: redback
Date Posted: 15 Mar 08 at 11:46pm
I would like to see a bit more joined up government. In my area instead of supporting our local schools we have a status lead system. In consequence we now have thousands of parents driving kids all over the place (often in inappropriate vehicles). During school holidays the roads are considerably quieter. During term time I know there are many kids having to leave for school at 7:30 am rather than walk around the corner to their local school. Get this sorted and we can save a lot of CO2.
|
|