Laser 2000 or RS Vision or what
Printed From: Yachts and Yachting Online
Category: General
Forum Name: Choosing a boat
Forum Discription: Ask any questions about the sport!
URL: http://www.yachtsandyachting.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=1025
Printed Date: 06 Aug 25 at 3:33am Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 9.665y - http://www.webwizforums.com
Topic: Laser 2000 or RS Vision or what
Posted By: IanMitchell
Subject: Laser 2000 or RS Vision or what
Date Posted: 17 Sep 05 at 10:36pm
Hi all. New to all this so please go easy. The family (me,
wife and 6 year old) have done some sailing on holiday (usual
markwarner pico stuff) and enjoyed it. We now think we'd like to
do some more regular sailing back home as a family. Clearly a
pico is too small for all of us (particularly when I'm 6ft 2 and 14
stone odd) so we went and had a look at a Laser2000. Seems lovely
and we're having a 'test sail' (I suppose that's what it is) next
weekend. Anyway, I've now spent nearly all day on the internet
and I'm wondering if it's the right choice or rather why I should buy
one of those when, say, an RS Vision seems similar but significantly
cheaper. There's probably a Topper something that does much the
same too. So...thoughts please on the pros and cons of the
Laser2000, thr RS Vision and anything else you feel I should be
considering.
Thanks.
|
Replies:
Posted By: TonyL
Date Posted: 18 Sep 05 at 7:02pm
Glad you're considering getting your own boat, it's a great sport at
whatever level you want to get to. There are many classes of boat that
might meet your requirements, some shiny and new from the likes of
Laser and RS are some that have been around somewhat longer. A lot
depends on your budget. I suspect you won't find an RS Vision for much
under £4k, alternatively your family could learn to sail quite
adequately in a 15 year old glass Ent or GP14 for a few hundred pounds
- not so glitzy but you'll always get back virtually what you paid for
it once you want to move onto something else!
Probably the best single thing you can do is get round a few local
clubs, and join one that seems to welcome newcomers - assuming you
haven't done this already. See what people sail there, be polite and
you'll get offered a few rides in different classes too.
|
Posted By: HannahJ
Date Posted: 18 Sep 05 at 7:50pm
I agree, club sailing is much more fun than on your own, and you get free advice as well!
------------- MIRROR 64799 "Dolphin"
The pessimist complains about the wind; the optimist hopes it will change; the realist adjusts the sail
|
Posted By: IanMitchell
Date Posted: 20 Sep 05 at 9:44am
Thanks for replies. I've now decided that it's the Topper Xenon that should be added to the comparision mix. Damn, this is complicated.
|
Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 09 Mar 06 at 11:57am
Just spotted this thread.
I've been through exactly the same thought process.
I eliminated the Xenon as being too extreme as a family boat - shame
because it looks fun.
The L2000 and Vision offer similar things, but the Vision wins on price.
It's also a newer design and has the advantage of being more durable
when pulled up on beaches.
Be interested to hear what you decide (or have decided)
Phil
-------------
|
Posted By: mike ellis
Date Posted: 09 Mar 06 at 4:34pm
the wayfarers are built like brick s*** houses. i used to be sailed in 1 of them with parents when i was 4ish. from what i can remember it was well built stable and my dad didnt have a problem keeping it up with me and him and the full rig on in a force 3-4. he was fat and i was 4 at the time. with a wayfarer you can be fairly competitive racing aswell. the other day the parents took out our clubs wayfarer and had a great race on handicap. me and my sister where sailing our feva at the time but not against them. i remember once we all slept in the boat when i was 6ish with a boom tent. it was a bit cramped but warm. i cant remember much of wayfarer sailing but it always seemed safe with parents.
------------- 600 732, will call it Sticks and Stones when i get round to it.
Also International 14, 1318
|
Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 09 Mar 06 at 4:38pm
I agree Mike, I was brought up with a Wayfarer and have happy memories.
However, I wouldn't want one now. Things have moved on and, to me, the
Wayfarer is too slow and heavy compared to newer offerings. Just my
opinion...
Phil
-------------
|
Posted By: Villan
Date Posted: 09 Mar 06 at 6:05pm
I learnt to sail (from the age of 9) in a Wayfarer.
Great boats ... stable, fast in a breeze, but they DO scoop up a lot of water if / when you capsize them (even with self bailers ... they are a bit of a pain to empty .. until you get going again)
------------- Vareo - 149 "Secrets"
http://www.TandyUKServers.co.uk" rel="nofollow - TandyUK Servers
|
Posted By: carshalton fc
Date Posted: 10 Mar 06 at 10:55am
well it depends on what u really want to do. because the 2000 has a very friendly class association that organise events all over the country etc and the rs vision doesnt have a class association but would be great for club racing and doing open events or the orcassional trip to the coast. the vision doesnt seem to hold its price very well condidering newish boats go for about £2000 but a secondhand 2000 would cost u around £4000ish.
personaly i would go for the 2k much more stable nice to sail in genral and will be a blast when the wind picks up. happy sailing
------------- International 14 1503
|
Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 10 Mar 06 at 11:09am
The Vision does have a class association, but it's quite new.
Be interested to know where you can buy a secondhand Vision for £2000.
Can you let me know?
Phil
-------------
|
Posted By: carshalton fc
Date Posted: 10 Mar 06 at 11:10am
it was in y&y a while ago!!
------------- International 14 1503
|
Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 10 Mar 06 at 11:12am
Most of the used ones I've seen have been just under £4000.
-------------
|
Posted By: carshalton fc
Date Posted: 10 Mar 06 at 11:14am
well keep looking the 2000 is a better boat anyways
------------- International 14 1503
|
Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 10 Mar 06 at 11:18am
Originally posted by carshalton fc
well keep looking the 2000 is a better
boat anyways
|
In what way?
Better residuals are worth considering, I'll give you that.
-------------
|
Posted By: carshalton fc
Date Posted: 10 Mar 06 at 11:23am
well i think it is laid out better and sheet loads are nicer. also i find that in the 2k is was easyer to sail in the windy stuff (f5) and if u wanted to sit back and relax u could compaid with the vision that i found the control lines a pain in the ars to get at(by the mast) and the loads are alot more. and in genrally it is a narsty plastic boat. sorry but they havent made a good one yet!
------------- International 14 1503
|
Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 10 Mar 06 at 11:25am
Ummm....
I wish I'd taken up something easy like golf...
-------------
|
Posted By: carshalton fc
Date Posted: 10 Mar 06 at 11:28am
yer but golf has never been cool but sailing is!! 
------------- International 14 1503
|
Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 10 Mar 06 at 11:30am
You're right - that was a sick and depraved thing to say. I apologise
unreservedly.
-------------
|
Posted By: carshalton fc
Date Posted: 10 Mar 06 at 11:36am
Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 10 Mar 06 at 11:39am
I'll race yer! Anyway, a 49er is no good with two sprogs!
-------------
|
Posted By: neilboys
Date Posted: 10 Mar 06 at 7:17pm
I recently posted a similar question re the Topper Omega.....stirred up some thoughts on the newer boats such as the Vision/Omega/Xenon. I was looking at all of them to replace my old Enterprise as a family boat whist the kids and myself also sail lasers/topper.
All have strengths, the L2000 is good and a strong class asociation as does the wayfarer. Wayfarer great boat but not as easy to deal with post capsize. The others above seem to get some flak for being 'plastic' but I think they are very flexible, low maitenance and fit the market they were made for. The Xenon is more sporty not really a cruiser, Vision has the RS pedigree but can cruise and the Omega is more of a cruiser with options for fun sailing.
In the end I bought a Laser Stratos which does the same as the Vision/Omega but is heavier (GRP) and even second hand can be quite expensive but I like the boat and it perfoms well but can be very stable when required.
I looked at second hand prices for all of them, not many Visions/Omegas (but RS and Topper do sell second hand boats), L2000 holds price well and you really are looking at paying over £4000 and the Stratos £4500 - £7000. wayfarers are about £1500 - £2500 depending on what you want (you can obviously pay more).
Good luck but I would recommend paying a bit more and getting a Stratos for the family
|
Posted By: Medway Maniac
Date Posted: 10 Mar 06 at 10:54pm
Neilboys, you criticise the Wayfarer for not being easy post capsize. True, it takes a while to bail out, but it's easy to right (well, the ones without a double bottom, anyway), after that it's just a question of sailing off the wind for a while (or being handy with a bucket) till it's dry.
The problem with the L2k and many other boats with double bottoms is that while they do self-drain once up, they're difficult to get up! They tend to invert completely unless you're very quick getting on the centreboard - I've seen a light guy standing for what seemed like 30 minutes on the gunwale of an inverted L2k without it responding at all!
|
Posted By: Villan
Date Posted: 10 Mar 06 at 11:22pm
Also, Double bottom boats (or open-transom ones - rs200) may have a high cockpit floor ewhen upright, but when inverted, it is VERY low ... meaning no air pocket if someone gets trapped under it
------------- Vareo - 149 "Secrets"
http://www.TandyUKServers.co.uk" rel="nofollow - TandyUK Servers
|
Posted By: neilboys
Date Posted: 11 Mar 06 at 12:54pm
Totally agree with the above........was'nt crticizing the wayfarer at all...sailed one many times and would'nt dare to fault it ! Having sailed an Enterprise for many years bit like the Wayfarer in inexperienced hands they can be difficult to drain. However, I accept the points re ease of initial recovery and issues re inversion (don't think the L2000 is that bad really)....
I should have said if you are looking for a cheap starter family boat you can't go wrong with the Enterprise (or GP14) dependent on what your local club sail
|
Posted By: Rob.e
Date Posted: 13 Mar 06 at 12:26pm
Above all, find what they sail at your local club and go for that!
Re: the poly boats, I do wonder what the "life expectancy" of these designs will be. They seem to be "up to the minute" now but if they are overtaken by fashion and dumped by the manufacturer their value could plummet. I gather that the initial cost of moulds etc is high, which means the builders will have to stick by them to re-coup the costs to an extent, but if some other "next big thing" comes along and a partic design stops selling, who knows? At least the 2000 has a race circuit and a bit of a following so if Laser drop it someone else might pick it up (a la 3000). Older classes like the Ent and Wayfarer have stood the test of time (for a good reason) have an established 2nd hand market, and a good pool of boats available at a range of prices.
-------------
|
Posted By: IanMitchell
Date Posted: 27 Mar 06 at 12:47pm
Gosh I'd forgotten all about this thread. I see it's grown somewhat since I last looked at it. Anyway, after much deliberation we went the Laser2000 route. The thinking was:
- that the hull weight was lower than the alternatives - so easier to get up slipway
- that concerns about the speed at which it inverts could be overcome with the fitting of a masthead float - and that given the shallow lake it's going to be sailed on having one of them on is better than having a muddy mast anyway
- 20,000-odd owners can't be wrong and the relative lack of 2nd hand ones on the market suggests that those that buy them are happy with them
- 2nd hand values seem to hold up anyway
- there are a number of them at the club we've joined
- we felt comfortable on the test sail
- Laser did us a good deal on price
So we've got one, it's sitting on its trolley waiting for the weather to warm up. Can't wait.
|
Posted By: Philsy
Date Posted: 27 Mar 06 at 1:13pm
Sounds a sensible choice. I'm sure you'll have a lot of fun with it.
I'm still deliberating, and lack of room at the club pound means I'm not in
too much of a rush...
Phil
-------------
|
Posted By: jeffers
Date Posted: 27 Mar 06 at 1:46pm
Originally posted by IanMitchell
- 20,000-odd owners can't be wrong and the relative lack of 2nd hand ones on the market suggests that those that buy them are happy with them
|
Have they really sold 20,000 of them? That is getting pretty close to Laser 1 sales figures.....
I would be sceptical on that figure (unless independant proof can be given).
------------- Paul
----------------------
D-Zero GBR 74
|
Posted By: IanMitchell
Date Posted: 27 Mar 06 at 3:21pm
Well I may just be naive but I was basing that on the sail numbers they are now issuing. Ours is 217somethingsomething.
|
Posted By: kevg
Date Posted: 27 Mar 06 at 3:27pm
Originally posted by jeffers
Originally posted by IanMitchell
- 20,000-odd owners can't be wrong and the relative lack of 2nd hand ones on the market suggests that those that buy them are happy with them
|
Have they really sold 20,000 of them? That is getting pretty close to Laser 1 sales figures.....
I would be sceptical on that figure (unless independant proof can be given).
|
The numbering goes from 2000 to 2999 then 21000 to 21764 (and rising). The change occured in 2002.
This was to avoid clashing with the Laser 3000 numbering, and maybe the Laser 4000 or 5000!
Kevin
|
Posted By: IanMitchell
Date Posted: 27 Mar 06 at 3:36pm
Ah OK then, I was being naive.
I should revise to "nearly 2000 owners can't be wrong"
|
Posted By: Otto
Date Posted: 24 Oct 11 at 6:55pm
Well... My club (Hastings) have just bought 3 Visions... We think they're great. One of the best plastic boats we've ever sailed. They even get a bit of speed up in a blow. I suppose it all depends on where you are though. We sail from a beach... that covered in rocks... and pebbles... and children... so you need something bulletproof to land. So plastic is great for us. If you sail on a pond though (See my prejudice?) a 2000 could be great as they can race a bit more. The fiberglass makes for a slightly nicer boat but then if you're just starting then that doesn't really matter. Give both a test sail before you decide. Both are worth it. :)
|
Posted By: themeaningoflife
Date Posted: 24 Oct 11 at 8:20pm
Given that this topic could be useful to lots of newcomers, the new RS Venture could fit the bill in this situation perfectly, almost a cross between the two!
------------- Cambridge University Lightweight Rowing Club
RS800 1128
kindly sponsored by http://www.rwo-marine.com" rel="nofollow - RWO Marine
|
Posted By: Medway Maniac
Date Posted: 24 Oct 11 at 10:50pm
Originally posted by Otto
Well... My club (Hastings) have just bought 3 Visions... We think they're great. One of the best plastic boats we've ever sailed. They even get a bit of speed up in a blow.
|
Just shows how opinions can vary. I always cite the Vision as the worst boat I've ever sailed (heavy sheet loads, heavy helm, ......heavy), and I have sailed quite a few.
We have had two of them as club boats at Wilsonian for a few years, and there has been a unanimous vote to replace them with something else (probably an L2k - because we have class racing for those - and a MkIV Wayfarer, despite the shortcomings of those boats as outlined above).
------------- http://www.wilsoniansc.org.uk" rel="nofollow - Wilsonian SC
http://www.3000class.org.uk" rel="nofollow - 3000 Class
|
Posted By: r2d2
Date Posted: 25 Oct 11 at 10:30am
having sailed and crewed both the 2000 and the vision I think the choice depends on what you want (i.e., what type of sailing you will do and where). I have a 2000 and it is great to sail, good for learning, and has a good racing circuit, but my friend who owns a vision prefers that because he can fit a small outboard, pull it up the beach without worring too much about scratching the hull, and stow an anchor and enough stuff for picnic etc. He thinks my 2000 is a bit cramped in the crew area because of the kicker and oher lines running forward along the floor (he is 6 foot), I think the vision feels heavy and isn't as responsive or as nice to sail. Both will capsize and turtle. The 2000 may turtle quite quickly, but it dosent if you use a 40 litre masthead float. I am 12 stone and can recover the 2000 from turtled - it helps if you uncleat the main and kicker.
|
|